[quote]ZEB wrote:
andy bumphren wrote:
I think body-part splits are not efficient because they use excessive amounts of time to train every bodypart. Everyone seems to agree that training time is precious for MMA atheletes. Inevitably, on chest day, other extensors will be worked as well, but body-part splits disregard this fact, and choose to needlessly stimulate these other extensors “separately”.
But you have no clue as to the type of training Hughes is doing. Other than he splits his body parts over a couple of days.
He might be doing some sort of training with short rest periods to simulate his sport.
That’s the problem with Internet advice…on all our parts. We just don’t have enough information.
True I have no idea how he actually trains, but I can say with confidence that body-part splits are designed for asthetics;
Like I said above you don’t have a clue as to how he is doing what he is doing. But this is the Internet and we all have to comment…
Training for strength is done by movement.Training for strength by body part is absurb,
Bull…someone better tell Ronnie Coleman that he has no strength.
Please stop this nonsense.

because isolation movements cannot be safely used with heavy loads.
Who says he is using excessively heavy loads…? False assumption number…?
You state that it is possible that he might have trouble maintaining muscle mass; this is a function of diet.
Oh I get it…it matters not how you train…loads, reps, sets time between sets…it’s all about diet.
LOL, shut up.
I’m sorry I couldn’t help it.
These aren’t superficial reasons why body-part split training is not optimal, they are REAL reasons, backed by science and not just rhetoric.
You have NO real reasons…no not one why Matt Hughes is training wrong.
Do you know why?
Because you don’t know how he is training other than he splits his routines.
Everything else that you state is a crude assumption.
[/quote]
You’re getting around my arguments by passing them off as mere speculation so I’ll state explicitly why body-part splits, regardless of their nature are not optimal for an athlete:
-Body-part splits are time consuming. Despite what special methods he may use, he is needless doing them several times per week.
Here are my references spelled out, since you completely ignored them:
Supertraining, p. 66:
“Except for a few sports, such as bodybuilding and sumo wrestling, in which an increased bodymass without greater relative strength may contribute to performance, sarcomere hypertrophy is far more important than sarcoplasmic hypertrophy in most atheletic activities.”
p. 67
“The data (Nikituk & Samoilov, 1990) shows that the longer and more strenuous the submaximal loading (but not the rapid, near maximal low-repetition load of Olympic weightlifting), the less there is sarcomere hypertrophy and the more there is sarcoplasmic hypertrophy.”
If you piece this information together it spells out why type of training is optimal for MMA atheletes; rapid, near-maximal, low repetition lifting. Someone mentioned a fighter who trains with Louie Simmons, who does complexs: this is optimal, Chad Waterbury’s program is optimal, body-part splits: not optimal.
This information also explains why he doesn’t need a body-part split routine to promote growth, and that, if your speculation is correct (that he has trouble maintaining weight), it must be a function of diet.
From Matt Hughes’ website, his workout exactly:
“4:00 p.m. lift weights, no more than 1 hour”
Monday- Chest (I hate chest workouts, and if I don’t start the week with chest, I won’t do it).
Tuesday- Back
Wednesday- might take the day off (lift Saturday if I do), maybe arms.
Thursday- shoulders (always separate shoulders and chest as much as possible because they are both push muscles).
Friday- Arms
Saturday- Legs
Sets:
1st- 15 reps
2nd- 10-12 reps
3rd- no more than 6
4th- 10-12
4 exercises per bodypart"
www.matt-hughes.com/training.html
So you see his workout is a standard body-part split, and therefore not optimal. This workout could easily be consolodated into a simpler, and more effective program. True he does pyramid with each exercise into an intensity that certainly promotes sarcomere hypertrophy, but he is also wasting time and energy as well as not maximizing the benefits of his lifting.
I understand that conditioning and technique is where it’s at for fighters, and he does a lot of conditioning and must have great technique, but his lifting IS a sore spot.
Maybe next time dig a little, and you won’t be defending a losing argument with lack of evidence as your only premise.