[quote]Magarhe wrote:
Avocado wrote:
Magarhe wrote:
Did you seriously just recommend that this dude drink extra MILK in order to LOSE FAT?
Yeah, i think filling him with fast digesting sugars and insulinogenic proteins will really help him lode fat.
Fast is the dude isnt really fat at all likely. Even so the last thing he needs is any more milk.
And 20 rep squats for a dude with a bowflex and no real experience squatting? good advice. What if his max is like 100 #? you think sitting around squatting 65 or 70 pounds for 20 reps with beginner form deteriorating quickly at rep 8 onwards will really cop him some monster results?
You sir, have enough good advice to choke a horse.
I wish you would write an article on “4L of milk for fat loss!”
-chris
You are an idiot. Pay attention.
What the kid was asking and what he needed are two different things.
He is not fat. Rather than convince him that I gave him something that would be useful i nthe meagre 4 weeks he has.
Sprints to get him in shape and prepared to return to a REAL GYM at college.
A book to read to get him up to speed.
A toy to play with - the bowflex - to keep him interested and at least get his muscles used to producing force in unusual ways.
Milk - because he does not NEED to lose fat - and he will need more nutrition - and being a kid, he WON’T do it any other way that is inconvenient, like actually preparing meals himself. (but if he has probs with milk, no good). If you have anything against 4L of milk a day then you haven’t a clue.
So what if he can squat only 50 pounds? Who gives a sh#t? In 4 weeks on holiday with no weights and probably goofing off all day, what do you think he is going to do? He can do worse than crappy squats with a backpack on his back weighing 30 pounds to get him at least a bit fitter, and some sprints around the block.
But instead of spending 4 weeks sprinting and flexing and reading and learning, he will try some half assed thing, because numbnuts like you will come along and shoot down everything I said, WITHOUT giving a useful alternative.
“4L of milk for fat loss!” - with 20 rep squats is exactly the fat loss a skinny-fat kid needs.
Sorry for calling you an idiot but you really have not got a clue, and seemed to enjoy attacking everything I said with a lot of half assed opinions. Give a better plan for this kid for his 4 weeks off, or shut up.
[/quote]
fair enough. my criticisms in general were fairly half-assed. I was still mildly agitated from another thread i had just looked at unfair of me to be an outright cunt.
Even so, With his overall lack of ability or access to train legitimately HARD I’d say the milk is still not an optimal idea. And make no mistake, I recommend and use the “Sq’s & Milk” method for training teenage, non-cooking athletes with grand success.
Thing is I have no idea where all the milk is going to go when he has no great ways to cause muscle micro-trauma and adaptation response. Without the squats the milk is just milk, which is not good for most people to overeat without need [ie. the widowmaker Sq sets].
So yeah when he gets back to college Squats and milk might be a great program depending on his ability and level. But for now i think there are better alternatives.
Without a legit training area I’d say his best options are to use the bow flex and work on body weight lifts.
Despite being a highly suboptimal tool the bow flex is some form of graduated resistance. I’d say if he puts his ass into some training on the bow flex 5 days out of 7 he could develop at least some overall work capacity.
Between that and some body weight training, squats, pistols, various presses and chins [if available] he would likely be more than ready for some legit program in the coming year.
And you’re right in saying that he does not likely need to lose fat. Since he is at home though and has all the time in the world there is no better time to learn to cook. Now that he’s in college and is a going to be a big boy who can tie his own shoes it’s about time to learn to cook some shit.
Start with the slow cooker and move onto the counter-top grill. both things you can use in school.
If he isnt willing to put a small amount of his massive span of free time into cooking then i highly doubt he has the dedication to get results out of any program. Learning to eat a planned nutrition program of solid foods like meat, veggies, fruits and some grains will assist him further into his life than the extra unnecessary calories from the milk he’d be drinking while not training hard enough to warrant it.
Getting protein out of animals and their unborn offspring are far more stable ways of gaining lean weight. That and he will likely have a bunch of home-cooked mom meals to hook into.
-chris