[quote] Matt wrote:
apwsearch wrote:
WhiteFlash wrote:
AP, I’m sure you bench over 300, as do I. I have missed 315 before and I’m still here. I haven’t put on a shirt and benched 300 over what I’m naturally capable of [I obviously know that no shirt in the world is gonna double my current max or that I can throw one on and automatically bench more, I’m just saying this for arguements sake.] and had the bar cave in my ribs/sternum/head.
I’m aware of strains and tears and all of the inherent dangers that come with heavy ass weight.
But, the difference between 300 and 500 is huge, and the difference is even bigger from 500 to 800, and 800 to a grand,etc… These are numbers these people are not capable of without the equipment they’re using, and at some point there’s gonna be a limit to what the most heavy duty shirt can realisticlly take.
I was wondering what those more knowledgeable than myself think that number might be, or are we gonna have to witness a horrible situation before the answer is known?
I don’t consider dumping on your chest or stomach catostrophic. I view it as damn lucky.
I was at a meet 2 years ago where a new female lifter with 155 on the bar touched too low in her shirt got up about 3-4 inches and proceeded to lose the bar over her head and neck. Arguably b/c of the weight the spotters were more relaxed and they missed.
The only thing that saved her was she slid off the bench as it was happening and the bar landed crooked hitting the right side of the bench first, catching her chin as she fell. She had a nasty scrape on her chin from the center knurling but that was it. What do you think would have happened if she would not have somehow acrobatted herself out of it?
Try dumping 300 on your neck, then if you are still with us and game, dump it on your face and report back. Hell, do it with 225. The point I am making is irregardless of weight if it lands unchecked in a vulnerable area you’re screwed.
Does more weight make you more screwed? I would argue not really. Dead, disfigured or disabled is dead disfigured or disabled.
That’s why having attentive spotters that know what they are doing is so important. Even then, shit happens. You take a risk every time you push the limits of your body’s capabilities.
There have been two situations I am aware of in IPF where lifters have dumped on their face. One was pretty bad. You don’t hear much about them, though but it was what prompted the safety bar requirement.
It’s almost impossible to alter risk tolerance in a performance based sport. People will continue to push the envelope. It’s the nature of the beast.
I remember a story from a couple years ago where a kid (15 or 16) here locally died from 135 across the throat. He was working out alone and the father found him dead, I think in the end they found out that he dropped the bar and crushed his throat causing him to suffocate.
No different really from NFL players breaking their necks etc from hitting so hard. Sports are dangerous, so is getting in your car every morning. How many people die everyday in cars?
[/quote]
Matt, I think you’re thinking of the 17yr old in Katy [maybe Spring]. It was 245, but your point remains. Somehow it didn’t make that big of a splash in the local news.