[quote]Ruggerlife wrote:
WhiteFlash wrote:
apwsearch wrote:
beeph wrote:
As far as safety goes you’d have to think it would be easier to spot 600-700 lbs than 1100 lbs. The gear which was meant for safety reasons has gotten to the point where its counterproductive.
I remember listening to a brilliant road designer or something for safety and he was talking about all the features of this new road with the banking, phosphoresecent lightning, high-tech road material etc make the road sooo safe it allows people to act like idiots and not pay attention to the road… making accidents just as likely as if it were not safe.
He said that the safest car in the world would be a car with a giant metal spike pointed directly at the driver’s heart to relate the dangers to our primitive mind of driving a 2 ton piece of steel at 70 mph.
I’m not dissing gear or the lift, im just questioning the ‘safety’ rationale behind it… nothing else.
I understand your point but we are talking about catastrophic failure. Not just missing a lift.
Let me provide this for perspective. When the Fury first came out people were freaking out b/c lifters were trying to use them like the old blast shirts (put them on once or twice before the meet) had no clue what they were doing and were popping out of the groove about 4" off their chest and throwing the weight over their head and neck. All the sudden, spotting became a much more frightening proposition.
In my mind this was kind of the jump-off point and it has lead to a lot of changes in how benches are spotted. Including mandating the use of spotting bars on IPF platforms, which honestly I think all feds should do.
The point I am trying to make is in a catastrophic incident, independent of weight being handled, your lift is literally in the hands of the spotters. If they miss, you’re done. Wether it’s 300 or 1100.
AP, I’m sure you bench over 300, as do I. I have missed 315 before and I’m still here. I haven’t put on a shirt and benched 300 over what I’m naturally capable of [I obviously know that no shirt in the world is gonna double my current max or that I can throw one on and automatically bench more, I’m just saying this for arguements sake.] and had the bar cave in my ribs/sternum/head. I’m aware of strains and tears and all of the inherent dangers that come with heavy ass weight.
But, the difference between 300 and 500 is huge, and the difference is even bigger from 500 to 800, and 800 to a grand,etc… These are numbers these people are not capable of without the equipment they’re using, and at some point there’s gonna be a limit to what the most heavy duty shirt can realisticlly take.
I was wondering what those more knowledgeable than myself think that number might be, or are we gonna have to witness a horrible situation before the answer is known?
Well Gene Rychlak dumped over a grand on his stomach (1,008?) a few years ago (2005 I think). Obviously he was injured, but he survived and came back.
You’re looking for a magic number, but there are too many variables. Weight is one, but also where does the bar land, how quickly do the spotters get it, the size of the lifter…[/quote]
That dump broke his back.