Crossfit vs Powerlifting

The Crossfit Total has been around since it started pretty much. I think Ripp brought that in.

And what Ripp has even stated “I don’t even like Greg Glassman. I don’t have a cult like allegiance to the guy. I really don’t like him. He’s too hard to get on the phone and he doesn’t drink my kind of scotch.”

I am a Crossfit owner and I have tons of problems with HQ, clients, other boxes, trainers, etc etc. But so does EVERY program. No one gets along really. What I have found in CF is some super humble individuals that possess some incredible physical skills, especially females.

This whole thing started with Gym Jones for me then I drank the kool aid then I took the red pill then some acid and saw god and realized it was all in all the same. I originally got turned on to this site because people were bashing the shit out of CF and I came running to their defense. Then I started reading the articles, talking to the coaches, liking what I saw basically.

Are there things wrong with CF, absolutely. But the same goes for any program. It?s not perfect.

Now the contest, sport, games whatever you want to call them has exploded. I?ve competed, they?re ridiculous but they are fun at the same time. Tons of hott chicks, barely wearing clothes, doing all kinds of crazy movements. Then there are dudes in board shorts, skins, doing the same thing but demonstrate some crazy abilities. It?s not going anywhere. CF has been around for almost 9 years now and every year it grows. The crazy thing is it grew from nothing. 1 guy (coach/couch) 1 girl (his wife) expelled from a globogym working out of a garage to what it is now. A multi-multi million dollar event.

But it?s give and take. Glassman, despite how he comes off, has given loads to military and law enforcement+FD and others. All of their certs are free including sponsorships and donations.

Ultimately this is how a group of people chose to improve themselves and for them and what they do it works/ed, BUT because it?s not what others do it?s bullshit, fake and should be drug out back and shot in the face.

The ditching of rational and logic has been abandoned for “Rounds” and “Time.”

They may have million dollar prizes and Rebok sponsorships, but I don’t see a forum for crossfit on T-Nation… I say advantage Powerlifting.

[quote]hipsr4runnin wrote:
The Crossfit Total has been around since it started pretty much. I think Ripp brought that in.

[/quote]

Had no idea Rippetoe has been involved that long. I found rules for it showing squat depth and all that online and it was pretty simple stuff.

Might be interesting if they also just had a Crossfit total event at the competitions to show off some pure strength athletes as well.

I don’t consider myself a powerlifter but do use some of the principals. Here are my .02 cents:

Powerlifting requires a certain mindset that the majority of people do not entertain. Most people have no (true)desire to move hundreds of pounds. The common joe can’t connect/relate. Take football or bball for example: on any sat afternoon a group of guys can go out and pretend to be their favorite athlete but they can’t go in and duplicate 1200/1500lb total. Also, there’s no real competition on PWL. Its YOU vs YOU.

Lastly, correct me if I’m wrong but are there any hot chx in PWL.

Barge: oh yeah he was in it for a while and for the past 2 years (?) has been out of it but still runs a SS and CF program at his gym, of hybrid sorts. MOST boxes actually do this. When Ripp left they moved in with Louie Simmons for a “powerlifting cert.” Before it was a “strength cert” with Ripp. Ive met Ripp and still follow all of his stuff. Dude is just awesome.

One of the big differences too between CF and other programs is that at ground level and Floors 1-3 EVERYTHING is free and if it isnt free it costs just a little. But just like the screens in Starship Troopers “Do you want to know more?!” Its going to cost you, as with anything.

CF has certs for almost everything, with instructors that are amazing and super intelligent in what they teach. They have a CF cert for kids for the sake of Moses. Does powerlifting? (Im not asking with an assinine tone either Im serious are their any teachings for powerlifting with kids? And then expand that to; are there any certs that someone could get for powerlifting with kids? I would love to get one.) The thing about CF is anyone, even disfigured handicapped soldiers and civilians can do it . Seniors can even do it.

Just out of curiosity THEUOFH where can I find that info on “couch?” I have my own bones with the dude and like to have as much info as I can gather.

I’ve considered getting crossfit lvl1 and powerlifting cert just to try to get into a crossfit gym and give people who really want to be athletes some structure to improve.

My buddy plays rugby at a pretty high level here in the US (specified US because international is a bit different) and they are all doing crossfit now but it’s just haphazard with no model for progression or real strength gains. I see them being fit but just getting destroyed because of their strength.

The trendy/popular culture aspect of CF is definitely kind of lame but coming from an endurance sports background (cross country/rowing/track) and having done a lot of circuit training/team circuit competitions this seems relatively cool if you take it seriously and do it right. At high levels I think it’s just another interesting way to see how far someone can push themselves.

At the local levels theres definitely a lot of douchebags who are in it because its the new cool thing to do but you get that in just about everything. Just my opinion

[quote]hipsr4runnin wrote:
Just out of curiosity THEUOFH where can I find that info on “couch?” I have my own bones with the dude and like to have as much info as I can gather.[/quote]

I said it before, google the couch thread. Well over 1000 pages w/ 1,000,000+ views. Start from page one and read on. Sometimes it slow, but there is some interesting stuff in there.

It may appear Crossfit has their shit together at a corporate level, but they are too young of an organization to really know what they are doing. Only thing they have, is a big new corporate sponsorship.

The Crossfit drama is huge, and I find it entertaining but don’t really give a shit either way. I would like to see more ‘good’ Crossfit gyms everywhere, as it presents a viable business opportunity to people make a good living off these group conditioning classes. It also opens the door for well, equipped more serious facilities, where former couch potatoes start getting exposed to and potentially competing in strongman, powerlifting, and oly lifting.

Either way, Couch got a divorce and I’m sure his wife got half the company. If you look at Crossfit mainsite, Lauren is posting the daily WODs who is his ex-wife and it hasn’t always been that way. Supposedly, the disheveled guy whose pic I posted earlier has had his dick in some very nice pieces of ass, all due to his leader status of the crossfit cult.

The qualifers for regionals were done online in a submit a video format. The submission system was screwed up for a long time, and now people are already bitching about unfair judging at regionals. There is no qualifty control for crossfit certifications, so you end up with people who go to a crossfit level 1, then end up coaching a room full of people when they are most likely unqualified to even coach themselves. Theres also a big hullaboo that judges at regionals had no qualifications whatsoever, not even a level 1 cert.

A big exodus occurred awhile ago, where I bunch of big name coaches/gym owners in the crossfit community, either quit crossfit or were kicked out for slanderous talk of crossfit HQ. A lot of the crossfit claims, i.e. 600lb+ deadlifts produced from metcons are unsubtantiated, on tops of numerous and common devastating injuries. There are numerous people who end up with Rhabdo, spend a week in the hospital, think they are awesome for it, then end up back in the hospital a month later with the same condition. On top of ripped and bloody callouses, SLAP tears, busted shins from high rep box jumps, and general malaise from starving themselves on a shitty, eating disorder related zone diet.

The criticisms are huge, coming mostly from qualified and good crossfit affiliate owners and gyms. Not to mention, any and all lawsuits directed towards crossfit gym owners go to the gym owners with no help at all from crossfit HQ, except for their shame at a collective RRG? or something group, where everybody pays in 10k.

Also, there are some franchise considerations, where Crossfit has a trademark on the crossfit name and collect dues from affiliate owners. As of now, you need to pay crossfit to call yourself a crossfit gym, however this may be making some franchise laws but nobody has had the balls to sue HQ yet.

Its still a young organization compared to Powerlifting who has been around forever, so we will see what happens.

[quote]Loudog75 wrote:

Lastly, correct me if I’m wrong but are there any hot chx in PWL.[/quote]

Hannah “The Minx” Johnson.

I said it before, google the couch thread. Well over 1000 pages w/ 1,000,000+ views. Start from page one and read on. Sometimes it slow, but there is some interesting stuff in there.

—I looked at it. Its cute. Weird guys.

It may appear Crossfit has their shit together at a corporate level, but they are too young of an organization to really know what they are doing. Only thing they have, is a big new corporate sponsorship.

—The people involved have had businesses and or run companys before. Glassman has stated and Ive seen it, which is crazy, that everyone who approaches this with an MBA or related knowledge fails. If you look at PL gyms its the same way. Corporate gyms, like one I worked for, have their heads so far up their ass its astonishing. To the point that any money made is almost made on accident and or off the abilites of others. I like Tates qoute :“A students work for B students work for C students.” Yeah some of the main coaches, including those on this site, read business books and postive thought books but as far as classes and degrees, most of the best trainers dont have em, they have training knowledge.----

The Crossfit drama is huge, and I find it entertaining but don’t really give a shit either way. I would like to see more ‘good’ Crossfit gyms everywhere, as it presents a viable business opportunity to people make a good living off these group conditioning classes. It also opens the door for well, equipped more serious facilities, where former couch potatoes start getting exposed to and potentially competing in strongman, powerlifting, and oly lifting.

----Its sad and enteraining in a Lohan kind of way. I dont wish bad on some of the people involved, despite ego or elite-ism. My box I run different than the norm and because of this we only search out and associate with boxes with similar mindsets. Ill talk to some owners and their like “we dont program our own stuff, we just follow the main site.” I usually end the relationship there, Im not in the business of changing peoples mind. I coach moms of 3 oly lifts and power lifts. Our clients want to go heavy anyone who doesnt, doesnt stick around long. I took my business philosophies from Mark Twight. It makes a difference—

Either way, Couch got a divorce and I’m sure his wife got half the company. If you look at Crossfit mainsite, Lauren is posting the daily WODs who is his ex-wife and it hasn’t always been that way. Supposedly, the disheveled guy whose pic I posted earlier has had his dick in some very nice pieces of ass, all due to his leader status of the crossfit cult.

----It has always been that way. There have probably been problems for a while. He lived in Santa Cruz and travelled all over while she lived in AZ. Shes always run the main site. She is actually run a large part of the operation. If you actually met them they are super, super nice people. I just dont agree with all they preach. Ive had my own really bad experiences with conversing with him.—

The qualifers for regionals were done online in a submit a video format. The submission system was screwed up for a long time, and now people are already bitching about unfair judging at regionals. There is no qualifty control for crossfit certifications, so you end up with people who go to a crossfit level 1, then end up coaching a room full of people when they are most likely unqualified to even coach themselves. Theres also a big hullaboo that judges at regionals had no qualifications whatsoever, not even a level 1 cert.

—I competed in these. 2nd year for me. It was a fukcing joke for me. I disliked all 6 weeks and how they did it. The judging was way off. I wouldnt be surprised about regionals, Ive heard some horror stories. Ive also been a judge several times, Ive been cussed out, miscounted, let shit slide and be an asshole. They are claiming the the judging is now too strict (from what ive heard). There is quality control in some ways, we test now, but it still has loop holes. A lot of places who do certs dont have quality control. I hear tons of people complain about getting lost at a Poliquin cert. And those people go home with the abiliy to just crush you hormonally in so many ways. Its the same mostly everywhere. Ive met (and most will complain on here) of Dr’s who dont know a fucking thing. Stupid people are stupid people, we need them to look good. I didnt hear about noncerted people judging - I cant believe that.—

A big exodus occurred awhile ago, where I bunch of big name coaches/gym owners in the crossfit community, either quit crossfit or were kicked out for slanderous talk of crossfit HQ. A lot of the crossfit claims, i.e. 600lb+ deadlifts produced from metcons are unsubtantiated, on tops of numerous and common devastating injuries. There are numerous people who end up with Rhabdo, spend a week in the hospital, think they are awesome for it, then end up back in the hospital a month later with the same condition. On top of ripped and bloody callouses, SLAP tears, busted shins from high rep box jumps, and general malaise from starving themselves on a shitty, eating disorder related zone diet.

—Im glad the left. They work better without being under that umbrella and they are allowed to speak their minds so the info is way different. I hear dudes on this site claim all kinds of crazy shit - impossible shit - its everywhere. Devasting injuries is usually an overexaggeration by most. Ive never seen it or heard from it. Our worst injury was a dude who CNS was done for the day and decided to try a highbox jump and scrapped his knee, to the bone. No one with Rhabdo, no one pulling disks, no broken bones. All the gyms I associate with have never reported it either. I just got done teaching a highschool track team who 85% of the team had busted shins - and they dont box jump. Ive torn my hands twice in 4 years. Dont know why its more frequent in others. Ripp taught me how to hold a bar, maybe thats the difference. Never heard anyone starve themselves either. Zone works, in theory, but just like slim fast or WW, people swear by it.—

The criticisms are huge, coming mostly from qualified and good crossfit affiliate owners and gyms. Not to mention, any and all lawsuits directed towards crossfit gym owners go to the gym owners with no help at all from crossfit HQ, except for their shame at a collective RRG? or something group, where everybody pays in 10k.

—Its not HQ’s fault - its directly the trainer on hand at that moment. RRG was/is a joke.—

Also, there are some franchise considerations, where Crossfit has a trademark on the crossfit name and collect dues from affiliate owners. As of now, you need to pay crossfit to call yourself a crossfit gym, however this may be making some franchise laws but nobody has had the balls to sue HQ yet.

—this is done for quality control. HQ can remove you from the list and sue you for using their program. Some people try to run their own boxes in a park or another gym and when someone, like an actual box or HQ finds out they threaten with a suit. I love it and have been apart of it. It helps to weed out dipshits.—

Its still a young organization compared to Powerlifting who has been around forever, so we will see what happens. [/quote]

I only know two things:

  1. I want that chick at the end of the video.
  2. Winning that shit and using the money to fund something you actually enjoy (powerlifting) would be pretty fucking sweet. Time to learn shitty form?

[quote]Grey Sweatpants wrote:
I think of Crossfit as fitness hipsters.

It’s funny that reebok is a big sponsor since so many of them wear either five-fingers or oly shoes. It’s also funny that for a minimalist sport dues are so expensive. But still it’s good that cross fit gets some wealthy professionals off of the elipticals at planet fitness.

II think one of the reasons crossfit is getting ahead of powerlifting is that powerlifting has three lifts that are measured in absolute terms. And some guys are unwilling to compete until they get their bench above 300. But crossfit has unconventional exercises. So a crossfit hipster can smugly announce he can do 30 burpees and 50 kippers in 15 minutes and his peers and like “what is a burping kipkins?!”[/quote]

“Fitness Hipsters” is absolutely hilarious. My hat is off to you. I’m going to steal this one.

[quote]unstable wrote:
you going crossfit?
[/quote]

No. I cherish strength too much to get weaker on purpose. I posted this because I was impressed the organization of the competitions leading up to the games. Valgus squats, rhabdo, and laying on the ground (which seems to be a MAJOR training principle in crossfit), on the other hand, does not impress me.

[quote]DixiesFinest wrote:

[quote]Loudog75 wrote:

Lastly, correct me if I’m wrong but are there any hot chx in PWL.[/quote]

Hannah “The Minx” Johnson.[/quote]
Or many of the Powerful Women here, who train PL.

Oh wait, did you mean “there are MANY hot chix in PL”?

[quote]Jim Wendler wrote:

[quote]Grey Sweatpants wrote:
I think of Crossfit as fitness hipsters.

It’s funny that reebok is a big sponsor since so many of them wear either five-fingers or oly shoes. It’s also funny that for a minimalist sport dues are so expensive. But still it’s good that cross fit gets some wealthy professionals off of the elipticals at planet fitness.

II think one of the reasons crossfit is getting ahead of powerlifting is that powerlifting has three lifts that are measured in absolute terms. And some guys are unwilling to compete until they get their bench above 300. But crossfit has unconventional exercises. So a crossfit hipster can smugly announce he can do 30 burpees and 50 kippers in 15 minutes and his peers and like “what is a burping kipkins?!”[/quote]

“Fitness Hipsters” is absolutely hilarious. My hat is off to you. I’m going to steal this one.[/quote]

Go ahead. The way crossfit does obscure exercises is just like how hipsters are like, “The band I listen to is one you’ve never heard of.”

If powerlifters start beating them at their own exercises, they will resort to smugly saying, “Well, I was into muscle-ups way before you were. And I have the torn labrum to prove it.”

my two cents from working with elite athletes : I see crossfit as I do the sport of triathlon “putting together different events because you SUCKS at any one of the singular events” Basically you are celebrating and promoting MEDIOCRITY ! There is not a tri-geek that could keep up with Fabian Cancellara on the bike nor a tri-geek who has run a sub 2:25 marathon time. The International Tri Union has actually dumbed down the olympic tri by allowing DRAFTING.

I do believe there is a track and field event known as the decathlon. Maybe that is what they are trying to run with here…thanks for the spew

[quote]Grey Sweatpants wrote:

[quote]Jim Wendler wrote:

[quote]Grey Sweatpants wrote:
I think of Crossfit as fitness hipsters.

It’s funny that reebok is a big sponsor since so many of them wear either five-fingers or oly shoes. It’s also funny that for a minimalist sport dues are so expensive. But still it’s good that cross fit gets some wealthy professionals off of the elipticals at planet fitness.

II think one of the reasons crossfit is getting ahead of powerlifting is that powerlifting has three lifts that are measured in absolute terms. And some guys are unwilling to compete until they get their bench above 300. But crossfit has unconventional exercises. So a crossfit hipster can smugly announce he can do 30 burpees and 50 kippers in 15 minutes and his peers and like “what is a burping kipkins?!”[/quote]

“Fitness Hipsters” is absolutely hilarious. My hat is off to you. I’m going to steal this one.[/quote]

Go ahead. The way crossfit does obscure exercises is just like how hipsters are like, “The band I listen to is one you’ve never heard of.”

If powerlifters start beating them at their own exercises, they will resort to smugly saying, “Well, I was into muscle-ups way before you were. And I have the torn labrum to prove it.”
[/quote]

LOL. That last line golden.

IMO, Crossfit is no different than the difference between Bodybuilding and Powerlifting. People doing Crossfit just have different fitness goals. Crossfit is of no interest to me by any means but the comparison isn’t apples to apples. Although I will say that the competitors’ chin-ups look like spastic siezures.

[quote]LiquidMercury wrote:
Minimize the federations. I think this is the biggest thing affecting the popularity of powerlifting. It’s very off-putting in my opinion. At least with crossfit if you win crossfit games or whatever you know you’re king of the cultards, in powerlifting you may set a world record in one federation and it doesn’t mean anything to another federation.[/quote]

I just read an article from Donnie thompson on the subject it was pretty sweet:
create a lifters union independent of all federations(and free to join) the union votes on what they want and only competes in the fed that meets the criteria they have decided on. we could fashion certain feds for raw lifting or multi-ply/single ply, then we could petition for the remaining feds to combine.the infastructure for the remaining feds would operate as normal but only focus on whatever division they were selected for(in other words no fed would be engulfed by any other fed).

pretty shitty explanation of it, but I probably got the gist across

[quote]iluvgmas wrote:

[quote]LiquidMercury wrote:
Minimize the federations. I think this is the biggest thing affecting the popularity of powerlifting. It’s very off-putting in my opinion. At least with crossfit if you win crossfit games or whatever you know you’re king of the cultards, in powerlifting you may set a world record in one federation and it doesn’t mean anything to another federation.[/quote]

I just read an article from Donnie thompson on the subject it was pretty sweet:
create a lifters union independent of all federations(and free to join) the union votes on what they want and only competes in the fed that meets the criteria they have decided on. we could fashion certain feds for raw lifting or multi-ply/single ply, then we could petition for the remaining feds to combine.the infastructure for the remaining feds would operate as normal but only focus on whatever division they were selected for(in other words no fed would be engulfed by any other fed).

pretty shitty explanation of it, but I probably got the gist across

[/quote]

I already disagree with the methods of the Lifters Union and will form my OWN organization called the Lifters League, wherein we will engage in the same activity!

And we’ll have black jack, and hookers. And we’ll squat to REAL depth.