[quote]Professor X wrote:
Brick,
Is this forum for the “get them off the couch and computer” crowd? I do believe they made the effort to name this forum for bodybuilding and added “conditioning” so that we would NOT get bogged down with the “get them off the couch and computer” crowd.
Those people won’t make much progress anyway so why would we care which program they use?
One poster actually wrote that he doesn’t want to know why what he is doing works or not. This is now the “Mediocre Lifter” forum?
What should the topics be in a forum like that?[/quote]
Like you, I don’t care what programs that demographic uses. Despite my goals changing form pure bodybuilding, I STILL don’t have the mindset as they for designing my program. My program includes lifting, conditioning (sprints on a REAL indoor or outdoor track - not a treadmill), and some low level intensity running; it’s still hard work and I don’t do it just to get off the couch and “get some exercise in”.
I was speaking universally because from a public health standpoint (I work in health as do you) I simply LIKE seeing people getting SOME exercise - even if it means doing whatever in the gym or outdoors. As I said a thousand times, there are people who are incoherent and incapable.
(This is not written to make fun of people. If they are that bad at it, then they should hire a fuckin trainer and/or dietitian or nutritionist. I suck at some things, and will never be good at them, let alone have minimal competence in them. For those things, I either don’t bother, or hire someone to do it. I can’t fix cars, reprogram computers, or do my own taxes, and I wouldn’t be able to serve as my own lawyer. So I go to the service shop. I have a computer guy. I use an accountant. If I were in trouble with the law, I’d need a state appointed attorney or to cough up the dough for an independent one.)
I suggest a general training or fitness forum. You weren’t fond of it. A conditionign thread wouldn’t cover what we speak of here. 5/3/1 is a lifting program with conditioning and other elements in it (as do bodybuilding programs with cardio and stretching).
How do you keep irrelevant threads (irrelevant to bodybuilding) out of here? I don’t know. You’re not a mod. You can choose to make your own forum and website (for cheap) for which it wouldn’t be hard to get traffic to considering your fan base, ignore irrelevant threads, and/or go to a forum that actually has a great deal of behemoths and competitors (those forums do exist but I can’t list them here). Wouldn’t that save you some frustration? You seem frustrated, but I could be wrong.