[quote]WhiteFlash wrote:
mj_gk wrote:
I definetly didn’t state that I thought he’d be good, if that’s what is being implied here. Sometimes it’s difficult to get a grasp at what people are trying to comminicate over forums, so pardon my ignorance.
Also, I must say I wasn’t aware of the three mentioned as having professional boxing matches. I’m sure it’s be done many times, such as is stated before, but has it been with the attention that Andrei is likely to attract?
Secondly, I think the arguement is crazy with MMA vs. boxing. The two are seperate sports and both have different qualities of athletes involved.
While many are quick to point out that they feel boxers are superior, I once remember seeing a Japanese boxer in a PRIDE ring get taken down, while attempting to backpeddal. I think it is a gross underestimation of the MMA athletes to say they couldn’t take down a boxer.
EDIT: It sounds like I’m saying UFC athletes would take down a boxer everytime. That’s not what I mean. Rather I think they would get take downs often, and not get stuffed or look foolish by falling on their faces chasing a ghost boxer, like is being portrayed in the statements above.
The people mentioned before started as boxers, couldn’t hack it and switched to mma. Arlovski is doing the opposite, and as far as I know is the first to attempt it.[/quote]
There have already been many boxers and kickboxers, who ran the gamut from mediocre to very good, who have tried their hands at MMA and not fared too well.
Matt Skelton, Nishijima, Stefan Leko, Francois Botha, Ray Mercer, Jerome LeBanner, Peter Aerts. We’ll see how Jeremy Williams does once he steps up in competition. Now the apologists will say that insert name here was past there prime or not very good in the first place but on the other hand they say that any club level boxer could come in and dominate in MMA.
I don’t believe either is better but from a historical perspective MMA has done more to prove it’s point then boxing. Guys like Gene Lebell were choking out boxers 40 years ago.
I agree that a good boxer will always have a punchers chance but there are subtle differences in the application of technique between striking in MMA and boxing or kickboxing.
Sitting on punches, standing to upright, excessive bobbing and weaving, clinching, even not squaring their stance. All these are habits which get many boxers in trouble in MMA. Most guys at a high level aren’t going to bum rush in for a double leg takedown. They are going to set it up with strikes and feints or go for a takedown from the clinch.
Anyways I don’t see Andrei doing much in the world of boxing. He hasn’t shown the chin to hang with MMA guys so I can’t imagine him being able to take too many shots to the chin from a heavyweight boxer with true heavyweight power.
That’s the great thing about fighting though. It’s all just conjecture until two dudes (or chicks) actually get in there and mix it up. As the cliche goes it all comes down to the individual.