I think part of the problem with this thread is that there is what DO women like, and what SHOULD women like.
Really it would be healthier for all if what people were attracted to was healthy behaviour.
Unfortunately a lot of the population instead practise easy, lazy behaviour. And get out of shape. And then, maybe they are only comfortable being with someone else who isn’t out of shape, they feel more secure.
Also, when young, there is a good chnace that a person who has unhealthy habits is still pretty OK looking at far as physique goes. This might not be the case so much these days (especially with all the fat kids around) but it used to be. So rather than being attracted to good healthy habits / lifestyle they go for the look, which may be lean and even a bit “muscly”, even if the lifestyle is a disaster that is taking that person on a one way trip to fatville.
I think many people who read T-Nation are at least subconsciously aware that what the public SHOULD be attracted to is healthy habits, ambition and the desire to improve, taking care of your physical self. And I think most readers get frustrated to hear that the general public do not think that way, because it belittles their efforts, AND because it is just plain stupid to neglect your health.
Also, lots of people are insecure about themselves and seek out partners who will make them look good … someone who is rich, stunning, young, famous etc… both men and women are guilty of this. And again, I consider this unhealthy behaviour and not what the public should aspire to.
If you think of your son or your daughter and ask yourself "what sort of person do I want them to be attracted to " well I always think someone who is healthy, active not lazy, dedicated to training but not obsessed (unless it is their profession), hardworking, lighthearted, devoted, well built and not fat but not cut to shreds (unless it is their profession), eats well, cooks well (guy or girl), is independant and ambitious but has a good idea of the big picture too. And above all a good sense of humour.
I think most people would think something along those lines if thinking about their children, and yet when thinking about themselves they start going crazy. Fat, OK. Not too muscly. I like really skinny guys. I don’t care what he is like as long as he is rich, or famous.
Another thing is some women tend to look at an ugly guy with a gorgeous girl and think “gee, what has he got that makes him so special?” I also think they do the reverse - they see a guy who is known to be famous, rich etc… and look at the girl, and think “gee she must be something special”.
What is my point? I don’t know I’m lost myself. Thank God I’m not single and trying to second guess crazy wimmin and found someone with a good head on her shoulders, who hits me with a big stick if I gets even a little bit fat.
Good luck you single guys