[quote]maraudermeat wrote:
Kritikos wrote:
Hey guys, I’ve got a question but I’ll also introduce myself too. I started a more powerlifting style of training this past August after having dropped about 70lbs in about a year. Decided to get back to what I love, lifting heavy things, as when I was dieting down, I unfortunately lifted like a big nancy.
Anyway, decided to throw in a TBT phase for the hell of it, and then finally did some research, followed this thread and your logs and started my West Side style training in the beginning of December. I got some pretty good gains, and definitely love the style and philosophy behind it.
Anyway, question is about GMs. I find that as the weights get heavier (heavy for me) and I drop the reps down, it just seems more “comfortable” to do them with a pretty good bend in the knee. It seems that I hit more the lower back, though I can also feel it in my hamstrings, but not as much obviously as if I kept my legs fairly straight.
So I guess my question is, should I keep on doing them like I do, or drop the weight down and do them with legs more straight? I hope this makes sense, let me know if I need to clarify the question.
This thread kicks ass.
I’m of the opinion that both are good. It is only natural to bend the legs once the weight gets heavy. As long as you protect the lower back during the movement it’s all good. I like to keep some sort of arch going. AS you get stronger you will be able to handle more weight with less leg bend. alternate the two types of GM’s. go heavy with the knees bent and go moderate with only a slight bend. If you really want to do a brutal exercise- throw in good morning squats.
meat[/quote]
Amen. Jim Wendler shows a version which is a bit of a hybrid of both straight-legged and bent-knee GMs. It involves keeping the knees bent druing the eccentric portion until you’re in the bottom position, THEN straightening your legs before coming back up.
Like Meat says, though, at all times protect the low back. You may find that straightening the knees in the hole could cause your back to round out slightly to compensate. Be cautious.