[quote]Dr. Manhattan wrote:
I’ve got to say that all this information seems pretty dubious to me. I flat out do not believe that anyone could, with less than 2 years experience, lift 90%+ on the snatch, c&j and front squat 12 times a week with much, if any, success. “Overtraining” shouldn’t be put in quotes - I’ve seen more experienced athletes in the sport overtrain easily with far less work. Its not just an issue of ‘sleeping enough/eating right’, either.
Moreover, someone new to the sport still needs time to work on their form. You just don’t work on your form at 90%+. All your bad habits come out at those types of weight. Top level lifters from other countries (like Bulgaria) could do this because their form was already impeccable when they got to that level.
I think making the recommendation of working at maximal weights all the time to anyone outside of the most experienced athletes is irresponsible. It takes a highly skilled coach to write a program at that intensity that won’t just rip an athlete to shreds. It takes years to prepare to handle something like that. Moreover, newer athletes do need things like push presses, snatch balances, pulls, block work, etc. Its time they need to focus on their form, to fix flaws in their strength, and in general, to learn to lift.
As for “America is weaker”… Shane Hammon had just as big of a back squat as anyone around the world, yet he wasn’t that competitive in the supers. Its more of a technique issue - Kendrick is c&j’ing 200+, yet snatching 160 when the top guys in his class are snatching 180, cleaning 210. Its not his strength or else his clean would be further down.
There are a lot of reasons why America is not overly competitive these days. There’s no money in the sport. Simple. Why be a weightlifter when, if you are that talented, you could make money elsewhere? There’s no interest in/publicity for the sport. Very little of our talent learns about it in time to be good. The sport is heavily tested in the country. No brainer.
In China, the government backs the sports, recruits for it, etc. There are huge incentives to do well. Here… if you win the Olympic gold in weightlifting, you are lucky to get a wheaties box out of it. People actually look down on the sport here because they associate it with bodybuilding in this country.
[/quote]
With regards to lifters training this style with less than 2 years experience, I can tell you that I saw a 14 year old Bulgarian kid start out under this system. I’m pretty sure he only trained once per day during the week because of school and possibly trained twice a day on the weekends. I hadn’t seen him for roughly 6-8 months, saw him a few weeks back and I want to say that he added about 30-40Kg to his total.
It can be done. If I recall he trained a little differently too. After working up, I’m pretty sure he’d work back down and do some doubles to work on his technique. I also remember seeing him doing presses and good mornings as well.
As far as Americans being weak, as a whole they’re weak. Shane was an anomaly, and had he had more years in Weightlifting, he may have been a few places higher. However, if you talk with the coaches at the OTC, they were frustrated with how weak lazy Shane had become, and one of the coaches told me that his squat max at that time was in the 275Kg range…that’s a far cry from squatting a grand years earlier! Granted, he doesn’t need to have the ability to squat that much, but I think it sort of puts it in perspective.
That said, as you pointed out, we don’t have our best athletes lifting weights like other countries, however, the sport of Powerlifting isn’t struggling as far as US dominance goes. I know it’s not an apples to apples comparison, but it’s worth mentioning.
A very big problem with why the US doesn’t have betters lifters competing is that they do a terrible job encourage younger lifters into the sport. I saw a video of a HS Powerlifting competition between schools in Texas…there was probably 500 kids (boys and girls) competing, all raw! I’d bet that they get 10% retention from that and maybe more.
You’d be hard pressed to find kids of that age at a USAW sanctioned meet to outnumber the amount of fingers on two hands. We can argue that kids want to play sports where there’s more of a chance to get paid, but clearly the sport of Powerlifting and other like Wrestling don’t have nearly the same troubles encouraging athletes into participation, and they clearly aren’t money sports.