[quote]SirenSongWoman wrote:
MaximusB wrote:
SirenSongWoman wrote:
MaximusB wrote:
speakman wrote:
Funny to see all the stereotype stuff flying around here: “Fat people are lazy.” “Fat people think they’re victims.” “Fat people try to claim special rights.” Etc… I would bet there’s an inverse relationship between a person’s age and his/her tendency to over-stereotype other people.
Translation: It’s the younger guys that have it all figured out!! Or at least think they do… (oops, did I just stereotype?)
That said, chronically overweight people tend to get on my nerves a little, too. Mainly because I’m an FFB myself, and it gets annoying to see people go year after year after year deceiving themselves into thinking/hoping that there’s a silver bullet or magic pill out there for their weight problem. There isn’t.
And then there are the yo-yo people: They actually lose weight, look and feel better, and then a couple of months later the weight is back on, sometimes more than before. I have one friend who is the most committed, hardcore guy there is when it comes to losing weight.
He can diet and exercise off 100 pounds and so impress the community that he’s asked to teach classes and give talks. He’s good at dropping weight like this because he’s done it at least half a dozen times in the ten years that I’ve known him. I don’t even know where he is in the brutal cycle at the moment: losing his 100 pounds or putting it back on…
As for me, I’ve been guilty of all of the above. I was in pretty good shape (though not much muscle; just low BF) when I met my wife. After we got married, we both had a ten-year honeymoon with each other and with Dairy Queen. Then I’d had enough (of Dairy Queen, not my wife), so I went to work trying to figure out how to get healthy.
For the first few years, it was just solving the amazing riddle of losing the fat (which turned out not to be a riddle at all, but “eat healthy and exercise” just doesn’t sink in easily once one makes it to 250 pounds of pure fat). For the last few years, my focus has been on adding muscle.
An equally staggering challenge for me, and, again, because I tend to over-complicate things. Really, I only very, very recently figured out that I actually need to eat MORE if I want to add muscle!! Imagine that…
But here’s the interesting thing: In the midst of all of this (getting terribly fat; taking forever to figure out how to undo the damage; spending several years more just trying to get a simple plan for adding muscle; etc.)
I was going to school and earning a 4.0 GPA and a Master’s degree in international business; I was building a very successful business that hasn’t even really been hurt by this current economy; and engaging in all sorts of other VERY DIFFICULT AND CHALLENGING intellectual pursuits. I don’t think anyone has ever called me lazy, except me, and I’ve never been a victim of anything except myself.
I was lazy physically for awhile there – actually, more irresponsible than lazy, and choosing to focus my efforts and energy on non-physical things.
Now, I’m miraculously applying my energy and efforts to both areas: intellectual and physical. It can – and should – be done!! How many people do the reverse of what I did – they focus all their efforts and energy on physical pursuits (like bodybuilding) and are negligent in other areas (like school and work)?
Just a thought next time anyone is tempted to throw around overly-simplistic judgments of overweight people or anyone else who is struggling with something…
Why is it, that when the show The Biggest Loser comes on, those who are massively overweight and plagued with illness, are THEN able to get off their ass and try to lose weight? It’s not about their ability to start working out, it’s that they are NOW willing to TRY. If it takes winning $250k to get people off their ass and begin a program where they eat right and exercise, then YES I will call them lazy. You have people who have sleep apnea who wear masks at night to help them breathe, while taking every pill under the sun, yet STILL willing to finally bust ass. LAZY.
Don’t bother with that excuse of their desire to get healthy and live a long life. BULLSHIT. That idea was present before the show, and will be there after the show. Then they have this epiphany, you know, where they break down and cry and see that they actually CAN do this eat right/workout thing. They always could, it was the money that was the catalyst to get them off their ass to even try.
BTW - the winners of last seasons show were the 2 oldest people, still think the average chunky isn’t lazy?
I have a lot of issues with That Show. But I know the money isn’t the reason people want to get on. The pressure of EVERYONE watching (and the support that comes with it) is the true lure.
Why would you have issues with the show? People who go on it know what to expect. Why is it that people act like they are so in the dark with life?
So you are saying that the pressure of people watching is enough for them to do what they say they can’t at home? What about the pressure put on them while they are in their home towns? Their friends, co-workers, and family members pressure isn’t enough to get them off their ass? Come on. Take away that $250k prize and see how badly people are fighting to get on that show.
On The Biggest Loser, the TV audience offers positive reinforcement and the coaches WANT the contestants to succeed. The pressure contestants get at home is negative.
My late mother (who wore a size 2, at her largest, and who was traffic-stopping gorgeous) would fairly routinely comment on my weight, always punctuated with “I don’t want a FAT daughter.” Mom and I were tight, but after well over a decade of fat remarks from the woman who was always my best friend, my mother passed away and I was obese. About six month’s after, without ever considering why, I started working out… and I never stopped. Coincidence?
As for The Biggest Loser, the contestants do nothing all day long but work out. It’s unrealistic to imagine such quickly achieved results can be maintained after they return to their families and jobs. And I think everyone who participates is destined to fall prey to serious overuse injuries. If I sat and made a list I’m sure I could come up with pages of why TBL sucks. TBL is about tv ratings, before all other considerations.
Evidently, the topic of fat people is polarizing and few change their way of thinking, regardless of how persuasive the argument. I know I’ve exhausted all mine and cannot imagine what else I could add, so I’m done. In the end, though, I still believe in staying out of people’s business. Thanks.[/quote]
The method by the the show achieves it’s success is questionable and debatable of course, but what it does do successfully, is show that people are not as helpless as they would like to think. After all, that would remove their rationale for being so fat. The show is after rating obviously, but that doesn’t change the fact the show can show that people are capable of busting ass while being older, sicker, and clearly heavier. Whatever it takes to motivate them, whether it’s money or internally driven desire to win, people DO have the capacity to make it happen for themselves.
I am sorry to hear of your late mother. But from what I gather from your statements regard her, it seems your weight issue stems from your mother’s comments.
It sounds like you have been on both sides of the equation, and do you still think you were so helpless to not ever accomplish this? How is it that YOU did what 2/3 of Americans cannot? What do you possess? You possess drive. You finally decided that whatever stopped you before, was not less of a deterrent, than your desire to change into the new you. Something told you that you can overcome whatever was stopping you before, whatever the reason is or was. Are other people not capable of this too?
In the end, if you request that fit people stay out of fat people’s business, then I request fat people stop complaining about their fatness. No one wants to hear it. They know they are fat, and everything that comes along with it, while some of it can be hurtful. I personally am tired of them talking about how they don’t fit into clothes, airline seats, how they complain when they have to walk up a flight of stairs because the elevator is broken.
If you are going to be pro-fat, accept ALL that comes with it.