The Crossfit Experiment

I’ve decided that for the next 2-3 months, starting Monday, I will be doing the Crossfit WOD. This is just an experiment to see how it stacks up against what I’ve been doing (full-body traditional weight training 3 days per week, little cardio).

I know the general attitude regarding Crossfit on this site but I’ve always been impressed by the videos on their site and I just want to see what it’s about.

I’ll be using some of their recommended substitutions when I lack the equipment (for instance, high-rep high pulls instead of rowing) and I’ll be scaling back the poundages on some lifts if needed (OH squat, since I’ve never done them seriously).

Any additional workouts I do will be with the purpose of bettering my WODs, so it may mean gymnastics-type work, interval training, etc., but I don’t intend on adding any extra weights work except maybe OH squats to work on form.

I’m building some makeshift rings today if I can find a place to hang them, and I’ll be finding out where my 400m and 800m marks will be in my apartment complex for the runs. I don’t have a bike yet so until I get one (if I do) I’ll be running a “comparable time interval” as recommended on their site. I’ll just have to guess how long it would take.

I’ll be recording my WODs and any additional workouts in this thread.

Hey, good luck with this, ive always thought that it would be interesting to give Crossfit a try, it definitly looks like it would be a learning experience.

How are you going about making your rings, ive been interesting in doing some ring training, but broke college student that i am, id be very interested to see how youre making them.

–WS4

This should be interesting, I’ll be reading. Good luck!

I’ve always wondered what the effects of CrossFit would be for someone who has been training consistently with good results using more conventional methods. It seems like the people they have on their site who rave about incredible results are usually people who seem to have never lifted seriously before trying CrossFit (at least on the whole).

I’ve talked to some of my friends who swear it’s the greatest thing since sliced bread, but every time I see the people on the website doing “broomstick squats” and the like, I get turned off. Keep us apprised of your results, and don’t get brainwashed.

It will be interesting to see your results. I may try it myself after another year or so of overall strength training.

Ironically, I found T-Nation by researching Crossfit.

I think I googled “crossfit critism” and thankfully found T-Nation.

Good luck, I look forward to hearing your thoughts.

[quote]WS4JB wrote:
Hey, good luck with this, ive always thought that it would be interesting to give Crossfit a try, it definitly looks like it would be a learning experience.

How are you going about making your rings, ive been interesting in doing some ring training, but broke college student that i am, id be very interested to see how youre making them.

–WS4[/quote]

Still kind of throwing ideas around in my head. Something like this:

www.crossfit.com/cf-video/1mubeach.avi

I gotta say, the more I look at CF the more interesting it gets. I will probably look into doing the Workout Of the Day (WOD) over the summer.

I’m very impressed with the functional strength of what I’m seeing people achieve on there program.

And Nicole is inspirational!

www.crossfit.com/cf-video/CrossFit_OHSComp.wmv

I’ve been supplementing the lifting programs I design for my athletes with crossfit for a couple years now. Sometimes it’s one day a week, and as we transition to off-season it gets ramped up.

If you want to have real world strength and stamina, crossfit will rock. If you’re looking for bodybuilding and bigger musacles, don’t expect to get them from crossfit.

Great program and ideals though.

[quote]csuson wrote:
I’ve talked to some of my friends who swear it’s the greatest thing since sliced bread, but every time I see the people on the website doing “broomstick squats” and the like, I get turned off. Keep us apprised of your results, and don’t get brainwashed. [/quote]

The broomstick stuff is for technique. Dan John recommends it too. I did the OHS workout yesterday with a broomstick just to try to get the movement down.

From the pictures on the site, they all look…well, skinny. That alone keeps me away…

But good luck, and I’ll be reading.

[quote]FightinIrish26 wrote:
From the pictures on the site, they all look…well, skinny. That alone keeps me away…

But good luck, and I’ll be reading.[/quote]

How’s that different from most people on this site? If you watch some of the videos, there are some pretty jacked guys doing some insane workouts.

[quote]OneEye wrote:
csuson wrote:
I’ve talked to some of my friends who swear it’s the greatest thing since sliced bread, but every time I see the people on the website doing “broomstick squats” and the like, I get turned off. Keep us apprised of your results, and don’t get brainwashed.

The broomstick stuff is for technique. Dan John recommends it too. I did the OHS workout yesterday with a broomstick just to try to get the movement down.[/quote]

My bad. That makes much more sense, I don’t know what I was thinking. Look forward to hearing the results.

Any more videos of nicole? :slight_smile: Daaauuuumn

I like many of their ideas. And it would be great to find a way to implement it along with traditional weight/strength training.

I like Mark Twight’s approach. He has some good videos and info on his web site as well (www.gymjones.com).

I incorporate similar ideas into my conditioning workouts between my strength workouts.

[quote]beaul wrote:
Any more videos of nicole? :slight_smile: Daaauuuumn[/quote]

No kidding. The girl is hot as hell and she can do more reps than me on the OHS with 95lbs!

I have been using Crossfit for the past two years, with a few deviations. I’m a Marine, and military is one of the target audiences for Crossfit. I think the crossfit critics (including TC) on this site miss the point and tend to focus on the sometimes idiot remarks of Crossfit’s creator, Greg Glassman.

In my opinion there isn’t much better for combat conditioning, despite the fanatical attitudes of some of the people associated with crossfit. I have been posting the workouts and my results on my personal blog here on T-Nation for a while. I tend to deviate from the WOD every couple of weeks. You all are welcome to check it out, I use the blog as a supplement to my workout journal, but it might be useful to someone.

Good luck with the WOD’s, I think you will find them challenging and fun.

Ill definitely be keeping with this thread…great idea! Think you could post before and after pictures and stats?

[quote]MurrDawg wrote:
Ill definitely be keeping with this thread…great idea! Think you could post before and after pictures and stats?[/quote]

Eh…it’s possible. I’m more concerned with performance so I may not post pics, but I do plan on keeping track of my bodyfat. I’ll put some numbers up later, I have to go to work soon.

I went ahead and started today. I subbed regular dips for ring dips, and used 95 lbs for hang power cleans instead of 135 lb full cleans. I haven’t done any oly variations in a long time so I’m starting slowly for that kind of thing. Today’s WOD was:

“Elizabeth”

21-15-9 reps of:
Clean 135 pounds
Ring dips

I was done in 7:34. Huge forearm pump and very winded. Heart rate was very high.

This link was posted in another thread on this site. Very impressive.

http://media.crossfit.com/cf-video/051204.wmv

[quote]FightinIrish26 wrote:
From the pictures on the site, they all look…well, skinny. That alone keeps me away…[/quote]

Yep. I generally train like the people I want to look like. Basic “7 Habits” stuff. Find successful people and model yourselfs after them. I’m not sure when this principle was lost on the world…