[quote]heavythrower wrote:
[quote]yolo84 wrote:
[quote]DoubleDuce wrote:
If health is the issue, why not stop all drug testing and require physicals to compete? If you have a huge enlarged heart, or are so fat you might keel over, you can’t compete. Why discuss the health implications of drugs when there are 400 pound obese lifters, who are that way to increase their total too.[/quote]
this doesn’t make much sense. what exactly is your argument? why would they have to stop tests if they implemented physicals?
how many competing under the IOC are so fat they are about to keel over lol.
and yes - if you have an enlarged heart you shouldn’t be allowed to compete - tests for this are being introduced in soccer due to high profile cases where a couple have died and one came very close to. it would be a good idea for this to be introduced in all sports and maybe save some lives. are you saying it wouldn’t?
of all the athletes under the IOC banner - 400lb obese lifters constitute a miniscule number. a MAJOR reason they are that weight is due to their drug regimes too btw.
i fail to see how it can be disputed that if there were no tests abuse would be absolutely rampant at every level.
it is a good idea on health alone for there to be tests.[/quote]
his argument makes LOTS of sense to LOTS of people.
you are entitled to your opinion but what I am sick of is people(I am not singling you out btw) who think their opinion is the intrinsically right one all the time.
its a big world and their are lots of different personalities.
right now it seems political power is more leaning toward the way you are thinking on this particular issue, seems western society in general is hell bent on regulating peoples lives more and more, but trust me, their are millions of people who do not see it this way and i hope enough will get fed up with it to swing the pendulum the other way some in my lifetime.
keep it up, you are heading toward Professor X territory.
[/quote]
erm… you are also entitled to your opinion too - where did I say anyone wasn’t?
it is called having a debate and discussion - it’s not like I am screaming and swearing at people in this thread.
my point was he doesn’t have an argument. what is his argument exactly - that if you have an enlarged heart you can’t compete? that if you are so fat you are about to keel over you can’t compete?
in all seriousness can you explain to me because his argument is literally nonsensical from what i can see.
also - to the earlier post about cars and other medication being more dangerous - what % of adults abuse steroids and what % of adults drive cars? you can’t make an intelligent conparison. if the same % of adults abused steroids as drove cars then yes i would expect a monumental upsurge in medical problems as a result.
im not saying i must be right but all of these examples do not compare in any way whatsoever and make no sense.