[quote]FightinIrish26 wrote:
[quote]VealChop wrote:
Getting silly in here. Hasn’t it already been proven in both professional and amatuer venues, in all different kinds of real fighting, MMA, wrestling, boxing, karate, judo, both ways, up and down, countless times that there is no inherent advantage to having ripped abs, tall or short, fat or skinny, bodybuilder vs powerlifter appearance, and a million other criteria. If you are always betting on the guy who looks like he works out and does cardio more, you just don’t know much about fighting.
The only criteria that matters across all fighting venues is WEIGHT. To the guy who mentioned BJ earlier, he is amazing in his weight class, but comes right back down to earth when he moves up. There are weight classes for a reason, in ALL FIGHTING SPORTS!!! I think the only time weight BEGINS not to matter is when both fighters are at LEAST heavyweights. That is, there is less difference between 300 and 340 lbs, than there is between 160 and 200.
I’m not saying a trained and ready 150 lb guy can’t surprise the shit out of a 250 lb. shit talker, I’m saying if there are two LEGITIMATE tough guys staring each other down, i’ll put my money on the 250 lb guy every time. [/quote]
I disagree with this. Most guys weigh around 180 and up, and if they know how to punch, they’ll be able to knock most other guys out.
Once you get above a certain threshold, weight doesn’t matter- but it’s lower than you think. I would say once you’re at 189 (cruiserweight) its a safe bet you can throw a knockout punch.
I am really wondering what American you guys are walking around in where people actually weight 150… most of the people I see are fuckin fat. [/quote]
You’re not disagreeing with anything. “IF THEY KNOW HOW TO PUNCH” is saying a hell of a lot for “MOST GUYS” walking around at any weight. Most guys don’t have any idea how to throw a punch, let alone two or three punches, have no idea how to wrestle, and are uncoordinated in an athletic sense, let alone in a fighting sense.
That 250 lb bear in the video clearly doesn’t know how to punch, wrestle, or do just about anything in a fighting sense other than lift weights.
I said weight matters quite a bit as it pertains to two LEGITIMATE fighters. You don’t have to be 189 lbs to knock someone out. A fist and the ability to move it through the air at a decent rate of speed and hit a target is all it takes. That is why a 150 lb fighter can surprise the shit out of any size shit talker.
They don’t put cruiserweights up against heavyweights for a reason, the weight advantage, even in pure BOXING makes a huge difference.