[quote]speakman wrote:
ZeusNathan wrote:
Speakman
Nathan, are you sure you’re reading this thread? I’m not sure you’re paying attention… I’m not “making excuses”, “being stubborn” or failing to make progress.
My goal (suggested by another poster) is to work up to deadlifting and squatting 315. Not sure what my goal will be from there, but for now that’s what I’m shooting for. I’m now up to 265 on squat and 235 on deadlift. That’s up from 75 on both exercises (no joke!!) when I started Rippetoe’s on 4/14/08 on Stronghold’s (and quite a few others) recommendation. Is that not progress? Maybe it’s not as fast as a guy in his 20’s with “better potential” than me, but so what???[quote]
75lbs onto your deadlift is indeed progress, because you definitely did get stronger… but to take 16 months to achieve it, is a fucking debacle my friend. So I just pulled out my calculator and that is an average of 4.6lbs a month. I wish not to comment any further on this because I genuinely dont like to denounce someones personal victories.
[quote]The reason I recently “upgraded” from Rippetoe’s is that Rippetoe’s program is specifically for beginners. His book, as a matter of fact, is titled “Starting Strength for Beginners”. My progress was slowing down on that program, so I mixed things up a bit. I’m now making progress again. Are the hormones helping? Undoubtedly!! Isn’t that what they’re supposed to do?[quote]
I like 5x5
…just not for beginners. case in point.
[quote]As for 6x10 being “f***ing terrible” compared to your magic formula of 4x12, that just seems to be a bit of an exaggeration to me, to say the least. Is there really that big of a difference between 6x10 and 4x12? Rippetoe’s was 3x5 and I made great progress on that for awhile…[quote]
there is indeed, a huge difference in 6x10 compared to 4x12. When it comes to hypertrophy, volume is king. I would also add maximal lifts to aid in total muscle recruitment, but all in all, you need volume. One of your fatal flows in your program is the mundane templates you use. Its either always 3x5 or always 6x10. Id personally be bored as shit using the same shit template for every shit workout, but i digress. 6x10 reminds of something like a GVT, the 20 rep squat, the 50 rep leg press… all fuckin fantastic ideas, but not so great if used everyday. (what you should think about is, “if i can perform 6x10 every time, every week… am i really using enough weight?”) And believe me, its not because you are abnormally stronger than your peers.
So why use 3x12/4x12… for you specifically that is. For one, I dont trust that you are using enough weight for your exercises. Before you get your panties in a bunch, one must truly be pushed to the limit, before he knows what the ‘limit’ is.
If i asked an overweight housewife, whos last memory of physical activity was archery in elementary school, to gauge from 1 - 10 (1 being easiest,10 being very difficult) how hard a 30 second plank is, what would her answer be??? granted her deteriorating physical condition is the prime reason for her answer, it definitely wouldn’t be exemplary of her potential… even in her current, unhealthy state.
With 12 reps, I believe its low enough to allow you to perform multiple successful sets, and high enough to induce fatigue.(resulting in moderate to high volume)
I still consider you a beginner, so the repetitive movements will be better learned by your neuro-muscular system, allowing your body to function at a higher potential.
*NOTE your body will not allow you to perform at a level beyond its comfort zone. Of course, unless, you’re in a life or death situation… a mentality you should have everytime you step under that bar. The dilemma is that this is how injuries happen, but that is also why we have coaches and trainers to prevent that whilst exposing your truest potential. Experience works also.
Does a beginner truly know how to harness air in the diaphragm… and have the intuition to pick the right weight for a 5x5?
[quote]So, here’s a challenge: If ANYONE ELSE HERE besides ZeusNathan thinks he’s right and that 4x12 is the ONLY way to make progress, can someone please come to his defense?? Seriously, I’m open-minded and am willing to try anything. But, Nathan, the reason I’ve been resistant to your advice is that you’re just SO EXTREME about it!! You seem to be saying that YOU AND ONLY YOU knows the magic formula for bodybuilding, but reality just doesn’t seem to bear that out…[quote]
LoL
Come to my defense? Are you looking for a comrade to help dispute my statements? Dude, dont cry to the other members. Fight your own battles.
I can definitely sweet talk you into trying my personal program for you, but youre not paying me. Nor are you at all receptive to my ideas.
I was kind of hoping to piss you enough so that you come out and said something along the lines of… ok! give me your program, so I can show you and everyone else how worthless it is.
and of course youd try it for a month, get mind blowing results, and eat all your words.
im terrible, i know. you should ignore me just on the principle of not speaking to evil men.
One thing about me is that I genuinely like to spread and share what I know. The only way I would write up a program for you is if you decimated whatever program you’re on now, and implemented mine with 100% conviction for only one month.