Balanced Exercise Selection?

I’m trying to pick assistance work for a 5/3/1 training template and wanted to quickly run my choices past you all to verify that it’s a good selection â?? with an eye to balanced development, long-term injury prevention (currently injury rehab), and aesthetics (strength and physique are both important to me).

Notes: Barbell Overhead Presses always seem to fuck with my shoulders, so I substituted Weighted Chins as a main lift. 1-arm DB Bench and 1-arm DB OHP are included to ensure right/left balance and to simultaneously train obliques/core stabilization. Rows are the seated cable variety because I never feel like I’m activating the right muscles when doing (heavy) barbell rows and a Cressey article persuaded me that this wasn’t just pussing out. I may add KB Swings to the lower body days as I love how they help my conditioning and glute activation in general.

Here it is:

Squat
Bulgarian Split Squats
Good Mornings
Weighted Planks

Bench
Seated Cable Rows
1-arm DB Bench
Trap Bar Shrug [need that yoke ;-)],
Tricep Rope Pulldowns
Facepulls + Rotator Cuff work

Deadlift
Bulgarian Split Squats
Romanian Deadlifts
Weighted Planks

Weighted Chins
1-arm DB Overhead Press
Lat Pulldowns
Trap Bar Shrug
DB Curls
Facepulls + Rotator Cuff work

Thanks for any feedback!

Seriously? You substituted a major pressing movement for a pulling movement? If you’re making substitutions at least try and get close, not the exact opposite.

[quote]LiquidMercury wrote:
Seriously? You substituted a major pressing movement for a pulling movement? If you’re making substitutions at least try and get close, not the exact opposite.[/quote]

I don’t have my copy of 5/3/1 on this computer, but I vaguely recall Wendler allowing for such substitutions provided the replacement was a good compound lift that could be progressively loaded. Perhaps I shouldn’t call what I’m doing 5/3/1, but having a heavy pressing day and a heavy pulling day seemed like a pretty sensible thing to do in terms of program design.

[quote]dekd wrote:
I’m trying to pick assistance work for a 5/3/1 training template and wanted to quickly run my choices past you all to verify that it’s a good selection â?? with an eye to balanced development, long-term injury prevention (currently injury rehab), and aesthetics (strength and physique are both important to me).

Notes: Barbell Overhead Presses always seem to fuck with my shoulders, so I substituted Weighted Chins as a main lift. 1-arm DB Bench and 1-arm DB OHP are included to ensure right/left balance and to simultaneously train obliques/core stabilization. Rows are the seated cable variety because I never feel like I’m activating the right muscles when doing (heavy) barbell rows and a Cressey article persuaded me that this wasn’t just pussing out. I may add KB Swings to the lower body days as I love how they help my conditioning and glute activation in general.

Here it is:

Squat
Bulgarian Split Squats
Good Mornings
Weighted Planks

Bench
Seated Cable Rows
1-arm DB Bench
Trap Bar Shrug [need that yoke ;-)],
Tricep Rope Pulldowns
Facepulls + Rotator Cuff work

Deadlift
Bulgarian Split Squats
Romanian Deadlifts
Weighted Planks

Weighted Chins
1-arm DB Overhead Press
Lat Pulldowns
Trap Bar Shrug
DB Curls
Facepulls + Rotator Cuff work

Thanks for any feedback![/quote]

Ummmm… x2 for what LMercury said.

but… I think you need more variety between days that you pick the same exercises (duh)

Facepulls are awesome (1 of my favorite exercises), but dump the second one and hit the rear delts SOMEWHERE, very directly. While you’re at it, do like Jim does and add 100 band pull aparts each day, this is great for injury prevention/yoke.

Why weighted chins and pulldowns? I don’t follow that thought process. Add some rowing, of any kind.

I’d do 2-arm DB presses on both exercises, but that’s me.

And def drop the second trap bar shrugs, pick anything else, anything, get some variety in that program.

Planks are cool I guess [how are you not bored to tears with this current exercise plan?, props to you if you aren’t]. Once again, I’d drop the second one and do something like hanging leg raises.

summary of my thoughts: don’t duplicate exercises, since I’m assuming your rep/set scheme is exactly the same each day

Maybe this could work:

5,3,1 deads + upperback and rear delts.
deads: 5,3,1.
widegrip row variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
shrug variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
rear raises or facepulls: 3-5 x 8-12.

5,3,1 bench + chest, shoulders, triceps
bench: 5,3,1.
db bench variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
1 arm OHpress: 3-5 x 8-12.
dip variation or tricep extension variation: 3-5 x 8-12.

5,3,1 chins + lats and biceps.
chins: 5,3,1.
chins/pulldowns: 3-5 x 8-12.
lat row: 3-5 x 8-12.
bicepcurl/hammercurl: 3-5 x 8-12.

5,3,1 squat + legs.
squat: 5,3,1.
squat/legpress variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
lunges/single leg squat variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
rdl/good morning/back raises/ghr: 3-5 x 8-12.

Abs can be done every session.

Just a suggestion from a guy who is weak as shit, but who used to be anal about creating balanced splits for himself, so this might be atleast balanced.

To me the weighted chins actually seem like a decent idea. Especially for someone with shoulder problems. I’ve always thought of the OH press day as more of an “upper-body exercise day that’ll help my other lifts” day. But Wendler suggests that if you don’t want to OH press substitute it with floor press, incline press, close grip,etc.

Awesome; I really appreciate all the feedback.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
Ummmm… x2 for what LMercury said.

but… I think you need more variety between days that you pick the same exercises (duh)

[/quote]

Yeah, you’re probably right. I liked the idea of slightly higher frequency - hitting the same muscle groups twice per week, but I should at least vary the exercises.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
Facepulls are awesome (1 of my favorite exercises), but dump the second one and hit the rear delts SOMEWHERE, very directly. While you’re at it, do like Jim does and add 100 band pull aparts each day, this is great for injury prevention/yoke.
[/quote]

What do you think a good rear delt exercise would be? I experimented with rear delt flyes at one point, but they never felt quite right so after reading the Bill Hartman/Mike Robertson article on shoulder pre-hab, I moved exclusively to facepulls (I definitely feel these in the rear delts).

Do you do band pull aparts mostly/all in the horizontal plane or also in the vertical plane? All I have is a pink EFS mini-band, but if I’m doing 100 reps I presume that will provide enough resistance.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
Why weighted chins and pulldowns? I don’t follow that thought process. Add some rowing, of any kind.
[/quote]

Weighted chins because they’re awesome and help balance the pressing. Pulldowns as assistance because I find it much easier to specifically recruit my lats & scapulae (whatever the attached muscles are called). I am doing rows on the bench day.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
I’d do 2-arm DB presses on both exercises, but that’s me.
[/quote]

Yeah, I tried the 1-arm DB Bench today and have mixed feelings. It sounded better on paper I think. I’ll try it a few more times but will probably end up doing a 2-arm DB Bench.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
And def drop the second trap bar shrugs, pick anything else, anything, get some variety in that program.
[/quote]
Reluctant to slow down the yoke development :-), but roger that.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
Planks are cool I guess [how are you not bored to tears with this current exercise plan?, props to you if you aren’t]. Once again, I’d drop the second one and do something like hanging leg raises.
[/quote]

I’m rehabbing a back injury and need more isometric core strength so I’m going to stick with the weighted planks I think.

[quote]florelius wrote:
Maybe this could work:

5,3,1 deads + upperback and rear delts.
deads: 5,3,1.
widegrip row variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
shrug variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
rear raises or facepulls: 3-5 x 8-12.

5,3,1 bench + chest, shoulders, triceps
bench: 5,3,1.
db bench variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
1 arm OHpress: 3-5 x 8-12.
dip variation or tricep extension variation: 3-5 x 8-12.

5,3,1 chins + lats and biceps.
chins: 5,3,1.
chins/pulldowns: 3-5 x 8-12.
lat row: 3-5 x 8-12.
bicepcurl/hammercurl: 3-5 x 8-12.

5,3,1 squat + legs.
squat: 5,3,1.
squat/legpress variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
lunges/single leg squat variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
rdl/good morning/back raises/ghr: 3-5 x 8-12.

Abs can be done every session.

Just a suggestion from a guy who is weak as shit, but who used to be anal about creating balanced splits for himself, so this might be atleast balanced.[/quote]

Hm, I like this. I was originally thinking of trying to hit the same muscle groups 2x/week, but given that I’m an intensity addict and tend to go balls out on everything, maybe a bodybuilding style split (never done one) like this would work better. Only thing is that I’d also want to add low back work (Good Mornings/RDLs) on Deadlift day as I really need to strengthen my back.

[quote]dekd wrote:
Hm, I like this. I was originally thinking of trying to hit the same muscle groups 2x/week, but given that I’m an intensity addict and tend to go balls out on everything, maybe a bodybuilding style split (never done one) like this would work better. Only thing is that I’d also want to add low back work (Good Mornings/RDLs) on Deadlift day as I really need to strengthen my back.
[/quote]

Okay cool, happy to be helpfull :slight_smile:
You can do a hipdominant excercise instead of one of the listed excercises on the deadlift day. I would personaly replace shrugs, but thats just me.

So it can look like this:

deads: 5,3,1.
RDL: 3-5 x 8-12.
seated widegrip rows: 3-5 x 8-12.
facepulls: 3-5 x 8-12.
abs: 3setts.

Oh, also, what’s a “lat row”?

[quote]dekd wrote:
Oh, also, what’s a “lat row”?[/quote]

Well as far as I know it is any type of row where you pull to your hip and with your
elbows tucked to the sides as oppose to a row variation where you pull higher with your elbows fleared that hits the upperback more.

[quote]dekd wrote:

[quote]LiquidMercury wrote:
Seriously? You substituted a major pressing movement for a pulling movement? If you’re making substitutions at least try and get close, not the exact opposite.[/quote]

I don’t have my copy of 5/3/1 on this computer, but I vaguely recall Wendler allowing for such substitutions provided the replacement was a good compound lift that could be progressively loaded. Perhaps I shouldn’t call what I’m doing 5/3/1, but having a heavy pressing day and a heavy pulling day seemed like a pretty sensible thing to do in terms of program design.
[/quote]

I like how you have it laid out. There’s already a core pressing exercise, so no need to be redundant. Another good reason to make chin-ups a core lift is if you suck at them(don’t know if that’s you, but it was another reason I did it that way).

[quote]dekd wrote:
Awesome; I really appreciate all the feedback.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
Ummmm… x2 for what LMercury said.

but… I think you need more variety between days that you pick the same exercises (duh)

[/quote]

Yeah, you’re probably right. I liked the idea of slightly higher frequency - hitting the same muscle groups twice per week, but I should at least vary the exercises.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
Facepulls are awesome (1 of my favorite exercises), but dump the second one and hit the rear delts SOMEWHERE, very directly. While you’re at it, do like Jim does and add 100 band pull aparts each day, this is great for injury prevention/yoke.
[/quote]

What do you think a good rear delt exercise would be? I experimented with rear delt flyes at one point, but they never felt quite right so after reading the Bill Hartman/Mike Robertson article on shoulder pre-hab, I moved exclusively to facepulls (I definitely feel these in the rear delts).

Do you do band pull aparts mostly/all in the horizontal plane or also in the vertical plane? All I have is a pink EFS mini-band, but if I’m doing 100 reps I presume that will provide enough resistance.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
Why weighted chins and pulldowns? I don’t follow that thought process. Add some rowing, of any kind.
[/quote]

Weighted chins because they’re awesome and help balance the pressing. Pulldowns as assistance because I find it much easier to specifically recruit my lats & scapulae (whatever the attached muscles are called). I am doing rows on the bench day.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
I’d do 2-arm DB presses on both exercises, but that’s me.
[/quote]

Yeah, I tried the 1-arm DB Bench today and have mixed feelings. It sounded better on paper I think. I’ll try it a few more times but will probably end up doing a 2-arm DB Bench.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
And def drop the second trap bar shrugs, pick anything else, anything, get some variety in that program.
[/quote]
Reluctant to slow down the yoke development :-), but roger that.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
Planks are cool I guess [how are you not bored to tears with this current exercise plan?, props to you if you aren’t]. Once again, I’d drop the second one and do something like hanging leg raises.
[/quote]

I’m rehabbing a back injury and need more isometric core strength so I’m going to stick with the weighted planks I think.

[quote]florelius wrote:
Maybe this could work:

5,3,1 deads + upperback and rear delts.
deads: 5,3,1.
widegrip row variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
shrug variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
rear raises or facepulls: 3-5 x 8-12.

5,3,1 bench + chest, shoulders, triceps
bench: 5,3,1.
db bench variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
1 arm OHpress: 3-5 x 8-12.
dip variation or tricep extension variation: 3-5 x 8-12.

5,3,1 chins + lats and biceps.
chins: 5,3,1.
chins/pulldowns: 3-5 x 8-12.
lat row: 3-5 x 8-12.
bicepcurl/hammercurl: 3-5 x 8-12.

5,3,1 squat + legs.
squat: 5,3,1.
squat/legpress variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
lunges/single leg squat variation: 3-5 x 8-12.
rdl/good morning/back raises/ghr: 3-5 x 8-12.

Abs can be done every session.

Just a suggestion from a guy who is weak as shit, but who used to be anal about creating balanced splits for himself, so this might be atleast balanced.[/quote]

Hm, I like this. I was originally thinking of trying to hit the same muscle groups 2x/week, but given that I’m an intensity addict and tend to go balls out on everything, maybe a bodybuilding style split (never done one) like this would work better. Only thing is that I’d also want to add low back work (Good Mornings/RDLs) on Deadlift day as I really need to strengthen my back.
[/quote]

My forum skills are lacking so I will reply via bullets haha

-for rear delts I like the hang and swing that john meadows does, its a personal favorite of many of my friends that needed a nice rear delt exercise.
I have yet to read the article that you’re talking about, maybe you could supply a link?

-you can do the pull aparts in the vertical plane, but that would just be for “lat activation”, so stick to the horizontal version

-weighted chin DO NOT balance out the bench, they make it worse if you have shoulder problems. Lats are internal rotators and weighted chins would be the last thing I would add for someone who has shoulder issues, especially in a max effort type setting that you’ll be doing.You would be better off doing a max effort row instead.

-you wont be as restricted with the weight if you perform the 2 arm version for pressing. I would rather hit the chest hard with 2 'bells, unless of course it wreaks havoc on your shoulders.

-I didn’t mean stop the trap work, just pick a different exercise, be it dumbbells, bar or even cables, just dont repeat the exercise 2 times per week (this advise is just for accessories, and that doesn’t always apply either, but you don’t need to practice your trap bar shrugs for technique, hope that explains it)

-fair enough on the planks. I would add in pallof presses for sure then. I’d actually like to see pallof presses than weighted planks. Unless you are awesome at planks the weighted version may be too strenuous so I would just consider pallof presses or bw planks (of course I don’t know what your plank form looks like)

Shoot the questions if you have any more, I’ll try and help. Good luck!

What about an upper/lower split?

Monday-Upper

Bench 5/3/1
DB row 4x10
Chins 3x10
DB press 3x10
Face pulls 3x10

Tuesday-Lower

Squat 5/3/1
RDL 4x10
Shurgs 3x10
Curl 3x10
Pushdowns 3x10

Thursday-Upper

Row 5/3/1
DB bench press 4x10
Pull ups 3x8
Military press 3x8
Band pull aparts 1x100/2x50

Friday-Lower

DL 5/3/1
Front squat4x10
Calvers 3x15
Hammer curl 3x10
Close grip bp/dips 3x10

I would add planks/hypers twice a week and there you hace it.

Just my 2 cents.

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
I have yet to read the article that you’re talking about, maybe you could supply a link?
[/quote]

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
fair enough on the planks. I would add in pallof presses for sure then. I’d actually like to see pallof presses than weighted planks. Unless you are awesome at planks the weighted version may be too strenuous so I would just consider pallof presses or bw planks (of course I don’t know what your plank form looks like)
[/quote]

Just looked up pallof presses and they look awesome. I’ll definitely include them. I didn’t find a clear explanation on the hang/swings. Judging by his video, you lay face down on an incline bench and basically just do partial ROM rear delt flyes for super high reps?

[quote]HatersGunaHate wrote:
What about an upper/lower split?

Monday-Upper

Bench 5/3/1
DB row 4x10
Chins 3x10
DB press 3x10
Face pulls 3x10

Tuesday-Lower

Squat 5/3/1
RDL 4x10
Shurgs 3x10
Curl 3x10
Pushdowns 3x10

Thursday-Upper

Row 5/3/1
DB bench press 4x10
Pull ups 3x8
Military press 3x8
Band pull aparts 1x100/2x50

Friday-Lower

DL 5/3/1
Front squat4x10
Calvers 3x15
Hammer curl 3x10
Close grip bp/dips 3x10

I would add planks/hypers twice a week and there you hace it.

Just my 2 cents.[/quote]

Looks pretty good, but I’m a bit confused - arms are done on leg days for… training economy?

[quote]dekd wrote:

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
I have yet to read the article that you’re talking about, maybe you could supply a link?
[/quote]

[quote]VTTrainer wrote:
fair enough on the planks. I would add in pallof presses for sure then. I’d actually like to see pallof presses than weighted planks. Unless you are awesome at planks the weighted version may be too strenuous so I would just consider pallof presses or bw planks (of course I don’t know what your plank form looks like)
[/quote]

Just looked up pallof presses and they look awesome. I’ll definitely include them. I didn’t find a clear explanation on the hang/swings. Judging by his video, you lay face down on an incline bench and basically just do partial ROM rear delt flyes for super high reps?

[quote]HatersGunaHate wrote:
What about an upper/lower split?

Monday-Upper

Bench 5/3/1
DB row 4x10
Chins 3x10
DB press 3x10
Face pulls 3x10

Tuesday-Lower

Squat 5/3/1
RDL 4x10
Shurgs 3x10
Curl 3x10
Pushdowns 3x10

Thursday-Upper

Row 5/3/1
DB bench press 4x10
Pull ups 3x8
Military press 3x8
Band pull aparts 1x100/2x50

Friday-Lower

DL 5/3/1
Front squat4x10
Calvers 3x15
Hammer curl 3x10
Close grip bp/dips 3x10

I would add planks/hypers twice a week and there you hace it.

Just my 2 cents.[/quote]

Looks pretty good, but I’m a bit confused - arms are done on leg days for… training economy?
[/quote]

The hang n swing is as full range of motion as possible, so find a heavy weight that you can only move to maybe 135* degrees range of motion and do a drop set with say about half that weight and as much range of motion as possible. Meadows asked for about 20 reps for each weight if i remember correctly, but mix it up some.

I had read the push-pull article before, i thought you were saying that the rear delts didnt need to be trained.

The articles focus is on dysfunction, and having a nice ratio between the scapular muscles is great, but you also want rotators evened out too. They both are super important in shoulder health. If you think you need to focus on one over another do so, but dont make another dysfunction in the process.