[quote]trivium wrote:
My computer crashes every time I try to view the link for some reason.
I do recognize that the lighter guys are going to lift a higher ratio to their weight in a lot of cases (due to different levers, and what not), and to answer your question, both are impressive to me.
I personally want to be a bit heavier than 130 (I do admit to having some sort of physique goal as well), so I aspire to be more like the 200 lb guy. 220’s who press 405 are awesome too. If I thought I could be 220, that is what I would weigh, but I honestly think I am built to be around 181 and I don’t have good levers for anything. That is where I feel I will carry the most lean weight and have my highest hp to wt ratio some day. Would I be stronger at 300 lbs? Probably, but that sort of thing does not interest me.
I do also recognize that there comes a point where that standard (1.8 BP) isn’t capable of being met anymore. At that point, I don’t see the point of just being heavier for the sake of lifting more. It seems pretty pointless to me. (No I am not saying that 1.8 is my standard for bench. I just used that to make my point.)
I hope that answers your question.
I do think everyone should find what they think is impressive and work to hit that, and I do recognize that some people don’t like ratios. That is fine. I like them.
[/quote]
Yep. I suppose I like absolute strength. At the end of the day, the 150lb guy with a 3xbw bench press, while very impressive, is still weaker than a 275 guy with a 500lb bench press.
[quote]trivium wrote:
Do you think a guy who weighs 350 lbs and totals an elite 1730 total in the super heavy weight class is as impressive as a guy totaling elite 1655 in the 275’s?
Both are elite, but the heavier guy is stronger.
[/quote]
Those are both some nice raw totals (while not best of the best), particularly drug free. I can’t really say which I find more impressive.
Looking at this: http://www.usapowerlifting.com/results/2013/2013USAPLRawNationalPowerliftingChampionshipsResults.pdf 1655 would be the 7th best total at 275 open. And that’s out of 18 competitors at the nationals. The elite SHW guy ended up in 7th place out of 8 competitors. Heh. I don’t really have a point here. I just felt like looking up how well those hypothetical guys would have done.
I do find Ray Williams ~2100lb total very impressive; I could care less if he weighed 315 or 400.
[quote]trivium wrote:
Also, this is way up there on my list of impressive shit. Probably top 5 impressive lifts of all time to me.
[/quote]
Dan Green is a beast, no doubt.