[quote]BlakeAJackson wrote:
[quote]TheBodyGuard wrote:
There is so much wrong with the above.
If you don’t hear notion of superiority coming from blacks, you need to get out more.
To just state “you disagree” and then offer a personal anecdote is not a rebuttal. Tell us exactly why we do not share the same relative resources.
You don’t find the same amount of minorities holding positions of management b/c by the very definition - “minority” they will largely be underrepresented in terms of qualified candidates as compared to the majority. Furthermore, I believe there are actual differences in the mean educational level between the two races. So, by virtue of being a “minority”, you might have 9 white qualified candidates for a job for every black that passes thru the door. This is not intended to deny racism exists, only that the algebra isn’t always so simple.
I spent 17 years of my life in management and not once did we have a whitey only meeting and talk about how we can’t hire the next black guy. Management is generally delighted to find a fucking qualified candidate that will do the fucking job.
[/quote]
Funny how you use a personal antidote as a rebuttal to my antidote while telling me that is not sufficient. Just saying…
Anyway, I honestly don’t think that we are in disagreement. I agree that population size is different and that based on that alone you will always have far more whites than blacks in management positions. However I know that if you look at the statistics based on percentage of that population represented in managerial positions it would show a vastly different story.
Your point about qualification could be true, and I will look into it, but doesn’t it just by the very virtue of the statement then imply that there must be a discrepancy in access to resources? I’ll agree that much has been done to address this issue in the last 10yrs and honestly the pendulum as it often does may have over swung in the way of student loan access, but for everyone not just minorities.
Most white families until recently identified themselves as middle class. With the economy over the last few years it is known to all that the middle class is shrinking, meaning more and more whites are finding themselves in the same positions so many minorities have been in for decades. The fights and struggles that many of these predominately minority based communities have been facing are about to hit many more white Americans then ever before. We have possibly dismissed them not because of race but because of social issues found in the groups like drugs, abuse, crime, divorce, poverty, ect. However these are becoming a reality for a growing segment of middle america. Listening and working to solve the discrepancies for minorities, which to me are more about economic access is an existential way to ensure the security of all races. Don’t take this to mean hand outs or socialism, but figure out a way to ensure that they do have on a percentage bases as many qualified candidates for job positions. Otherwise you have to acknowledge that this demonstrates that there is a disadvantage to just being black/poor. Which means there is an advantage to being white/wealthy.
[/quote]
I’m not sure my reply was anecdotal given my considerable management experience with multiple companies, in multiple settings and moreover, my unique experience with race. But to reply further…
First, is there an uneven distribution or access to resources? Good question. Maybe. I could be inclined to agree, but I’m not sure it explains the under-representation. I also think there are social issues at play. We still have black kids running around our cities that think it’s “acting white” to be smart. I can go to one of the poorest cities in the U.S. (Camden NJ) and tell you that they have access. Do they have the same “access” and resources as their white (and black) neighbors in Cherry Hill, NJ? No. But they do have access and college is available to them - but I think the cultural and social issues are a bigger hurdle than actual “access”. The Camden NJ school system sends countless kids to higher education, yet it doesn’t explain why the graduating class does not contain as many young men as it did when it entered school. So, it’s a complex problem. But is it an issue of racism?
I can agree with most of your closing paragraph. But I think it’s more a socioeconomic issue at not necessarily always race. Poor whites don’t fare much better, and they certainly do not comport themselves any better socially.
I fully agree we’re all in this together and that if anyone is suffering, we will all suffer in some manner. Some form of socialism might be the only way to fix it. I’m not against fixing it, I’m against throwing money at it blindly. It has to start with the very young kids, while they still have a chance, with a commensurate effort on their parents. I believe they were doing something like this in Harlem and it was working.
I knew there was a better dialogue to have here other than the prior bullshit.