[quote]atypical1 wrote:
[quote]LittleThuggie wrote:
That argument is always completely an ego thing. Competitive powerlifters use it to say, “look what I did! You’re not ‘real’ until you compete like me.” Insinuating that they put more effort, work, whatever, and others don’t measure up. It seriously is ego. Usually because powerlifters are powerlifters because they failed at other sports - football usually - and want something that they can call their own, or be good at. [/quote]
Why are you posting up in a powerlifting forum if you have such a low opinion of powerlifters?
And it’s not an ego thing at all. Just the opposite in fact. I became a LOT more humble after getting onto the platform because it makes you realize how strong other people are, how much effort other people put into this, and how helpful and caring other people can be.
Powerlifting to me is no different than playing in a local softball league or football league in that at some point you’re going to compete against someone else. If I just go to the batting cage I can’t call myself a baseball player. But if I put on a uniform every Saturday morning and head down to the county park to play then I can. Make sense?
james
[/quote]
I love powerlifting more than anything but my daughter. I just despise this argument. I’ve been going to meets since I was two years old, helping fellow lifter friends, competing myself, etc. Probably 15 meets total. I get your argument, but my point is that in your argument you made the “baseball player” JUST a guy that goes to the batting cage. If a guy/girl lifts, trains, eats, sleeps, learns, etc. to excel at powerlifting (3 lifts), then I consider them a powerlifter. Just not a competitive one.
Other arguments are if I play guitar, study music, practice 5 hours a day, am I not a guitarist? Or do I have to be in a band? Or does my band have to play a show? Also MMA. If I train jiu-jistu, boxing, strength and speed training, etc. and put all free time into getting better at mixed martial arts, am I not a mixed martial artist? (go fight that person and see lol). It’s just too subjective. What if I only did one meet my entire life?
What if I did a meet and was all alone in my weight/age class? I didn’t compete against anyone but myself. How many meets do I have to do to be considered a “powerlifter”? Who decides when and if I am a powerlifter? If I don’t do enough meets per year, does my powerlifting title get revoked? If I just do one my entire life, am I a powerlifter? What if someone trains half-ass for a month and enters a meet, are they really now a powerlifter? No.
I just think if someone trains hard, consistently, puts the effort, learns the sport, etc. than they can consider themselves powerlifters (or guitarists, mixed martial artists, whatever). I’ve seen guys compete in powerlifting, MMA, etc. that should be embarrassed to call themselves practitioners of their art. And I have seen guys bust ass that don’t compete, that earn the title. That is my opinion.