[quote]Mr. Push Ups wrote:
baretta wrote:
uberswank wrote:
baretta wrote:
jehovasfitness was right, as soon as you add weight it ceases to be “bodyweight”. By your reasoning, deadlifts should be body weight as well. I’ll think you will find no one agreeing with you on this.
No. Bodyweight exercises mean moving your body through a range of motion, with or without added weight, i.e. pullups, dips, pushups, and squats. Non-Bodyweight exercises mean moving an external object through a range of motion, i.e. curls, benchpress, etc. The former is superior.
I always thought bodyweight was using your own bodyweight as the load you are lifting. Why call it bodyweight if you are lifting more. Like i said, is the deadlift a bodyweight exercise?..i dont think so, but by your reasoning it is because you are moving you body up and down through a range of motion. That definition just doesn’t hold up. every excercise is using and external load through a range of motion.
“the deadlift”, is a bodyweight exercise because it includes a bentover squat…its just a lousy bodyweight exercise without some resistance, you would be better of doing a squat for bodyweight exercise, and a bentover row bor a non-bodyweight exercise…if you had no weight to the deadlift
with weight its excellent
it sorta uses both, the squat part is the bodyweight movement
a better defined bodyweight exercise is one without alot of added resistanse to be effective. lipke a dip, or pull up, are some of the front runners.
same goes for non-bodyweight exercises
the better they are, the more resistance you will need to make them effective
bench presses need alot of resistance to be effective
IMHO, the more weight you need to make an exercise effective, the more inferior it is to one that doesn’t need resistance
peace
[/quote]
you are surely suffering from some form of mental retardation. I am not even mentioning the fact you just called a deadlift and squat a bodyweight exercise. When i read your posts my brain starts to hurt, you dont even make any sense and your all over the place.
So the more weight you need to add the less effective the exercise? That means the leg curl is more effective that a squat or dip is more effective than a bench for building chest
BTW, cant wait for grade 2…but i always was a fast learner …hahahah