[quote]Dirty Gerdy wrote:
Cephalic_Carnage wrote:
That One Guy wrote:
Yeah, it seems the general consensus is that you can tell within the first year or so of training if you’ve got the genetics to be the best of the best bodybuilders on the planet, no?
Nowadays, yes. Back in Yates day that wasn’t the case yet (not quite, anyway), and that wasn’t so long ago…
But hey, it’s only for the absolute elite shows and such… Though genetics can definitely bite you in the ass with some features (short bis AND short tris at the same time are something nobody likes being cursed with 
I agree, there are still those with sub-par genetics that make it in the biz. Paco Bautista comes to mind for one…I personally am not a fan of his but respect him for getting to the level he is with what crappy genetics he may have for bodybuilding…at least in the aesthetic dept.
Same goes for Dave Palumbo, Markus Ruhl (altho I think Ruhl has some amazing genetics for getting f*ckin HUGE!)
DG
[/quote]
Well, here we have the different aspects of the genetic issue…
Individual muscle-shape etc (Rühl’s triceps vs. his bis or delts) can be all-over the place or completely crap, but the guy can still blow past his peers due to being able to gain mass/strength so much faster…
And as I mentioned before, some guys can eat relatively little/low protein and still get large, yet for the vast majority of people (even most guys with good genetics for everything else) this would result in instant stalling/regressing.
So Rühl (genetics-wise, and this is just for the sake of discussion ok?):
Necessary Food Intake/Efficiency of nutrient absorption: Normal (I know he eats a ton, though there are guys who eat more)
Rate of Strength-Gain as it pertains to bbing and thus mass-gain (both on and off-gear): way faster than average (also somewhat different depending on which muscle-group we’re talking about. Also very high top levels for some bodyparts, shoulders especially.)
Can stay very lean year-round even when gaining weight? No. (i.e. average in that regard)
Genetically favored bodyparts:
-Shoulders (both strength and size-wise, some of the best genetics ever seen in that area)
-Biceps (Peak-wise, but very noticeable gap between bicep and elbow… Which can make his arms look comically small in t-shirts and such due to his also underdeveloped tris)
-Quads (not in a crazy way compared to Platz or so, but way better than average)
-Abs. Yeah, you read right. He often sports a visible six-pack even in the off-season at drastically higher BF levels. Also imo has much more “symmetrical/better looking” abs than Cutler and Ronnie, just a very large waist…
Genetically weak bodyparts:
-Triceps (no matter what he does for them, they just keep lagging)
His back is “weak” mostly due to exercise-selection imo, so I won’t include it here.
Ok, I think that’s enough over-analyzing for the next 2 decades…
I felt dirty even writing that stuff 