[quote]Sentoguy wrote:
Hi Magarhe,
Well, harder in what sense? Do you believe that the ordinary person would more easily be able to figure out free weight exercises, or how to build their physiques utilizing free weights on their own? Honestly, I doubt it.
[/quote]
Harder in THIS sense: with free weights, you have excellent control of the exact weight you are using and can therefore increase the weight with controlled progression, very easily. If you want to add another kg or so, no problem. If you calculate your 5x max using a formula you can set the weights at that and then do 4 reps, no problem. And so on and so forth.
With bodyweight ONLY exercises, you cannot easily vary the weight used. You cannot setup progressions as easily as you can with free weights. You can use different techniques, different speeds etc… but you do not have the luxury of precise weight variation.
Also it is much harder to do bodyweight only exercises that simulate lifting similar to a clean and jerk, overhead work etc… … handstand pushups don’t cut it.
I am not knocking bodyweight exercises at all. I am not saying you NEED precise weight variation but it sure helps. You can always add weight to bodyweight exercises, it is not as easy to take it away though. All things considered it is a lot more effort to setup the same effects.
I certainly am not saying average joe can work out a great system of free weights without doing some research.
And I realise there is a tonne of crap articles out there all over the place for free weights.
I don’t say they are the be-all end-all but neither is bodyweight only work.
The be-all end-all is progression, variation, stimulation, compensation.
The drawbacks of bodyweight work is the trap some might fall into that goes like this:
chins, can only do one or hang
chins, can do 3-5
chins, can do 10
chins, can do 20
chins can do 30+
stay at that level forever
Most people average people would get great results with bodyweight work as it brings them up to speed. But after reaching a certain point where the bodyweight isn’t enough, no further progress is made.