[quote]StormTheBeach wrote:
[quote]simonsky96 wrote:
[quote]StormTheBeach wrote:
[quote]michael_xyz wrote:
It was definitely parallel.
The only thing I can think of is form. But like I said, I’ve read that if you’re a raw lifter it’s better to do box squats similar to your free squat - so without pushing your hips WAAAAAAY back like Westside do. Even so, I would have thought breaking up the movement and relaxing would lose some of that stretch reflex so should be weaker anyway. I wasn’t rocking or anything either. So maybe that explains some kind of strength and weakness I possess if it’s the case for me?[/quote]
It’s definitely NOT more beneficial for raw squatting. Squatting wide and sitting back harder will make your raw squat go up. Squatting narrow and doing a free squat with a box under you completely defeats the purpose of box squatting. No one likes boax squatting this way because its really really hard… which should tell you something.[/quote]
If you are DE day also serves as a “practice” for the competition lifts, why can’t a form similar to your free squat be used?
Also, I’ve seen the old westside DVD’s and louie lists close stance box squatting even as an ME movement(though I think it’s done raw). What would be the cons doing “not wide” box squat?[/quote]
For DE work, it is ok as the competition gets closer to use a stance the is closer to your competition stance. With gear, withour gear it doesn’t matter. What matters later in training is specificity and transfer to sport. What matters early in training is developing weaknesses. Everyone sucks at box squats when they are done correctly. Doing the same squat, with the same height, with the same stance, year round, is just shitty programming.
You can do whatever you want for ME work as long as it is working on something you are bad at. So a close stance, raw, low box squat would be great for lower back and quad strength (i.e. the start of a deadlift) while a wide, raw low box squat would be much more benenficial to the hips and hamstrings (more mimicing the abbduction/global extension required for squatting).
Again, if your raw box squat is the same as or more than your raw free squat, you are doing something wrong.[/quote]
That or maybe theyre scared of max weight…