The Walking Dead Season 2

[quote]borrek wrote:
I just read a casting note that Rutina Wesley (Tara from True Blood) has been cast as Michonne. If that shit is true, I am done with TWD. She is high up on the list of people that make me want to break my television.[/quote]

I’ve seen a list of 6 actresses up for the part a while back. She was one of them. If what you are saying is true…

Well this may be one of those things I am wrong about because I’ve only see her play in one thing true blood and she plays a nut job. Maybe she has more range than I know of but she would not have been on MY short list for Michonne…MY favorite character in the book.

Uggg…

Hate Tara! Annoying character.

Tara sure did get in good shape though, from season 3-4 on True Blood

I only saw the first two seasons of True Blood, but I always thought that Tara looked great.

I only know her from True Blood. I hope that her character on TWD is nothing like Tara.

Tara Sucks I hate the character. I only hope if this rumor is true and she is signed to play the greatest female Action/Zombie/Superfreakinhero ever that is just her character I hate and not the Actress.

Because I really do hate the Character Tara.

[quote]four60 wrote:
Tara Sucks I hate the character. I only hope if this rumor is true and she is signed to play the greatest female Action/Zombie/Superfreakinhero ever that is just her character I hate and not the Actress.

Because I really do hate the Character Tara.[/quote]

Well that would mean the actor has done their job then.

[quote]Derek542 wrote:

[quote]four60 wrote:
Tara Sucks I hate the character. I only hope if this rumor is true and she is signed to play the greatest female Action/Zombie/Superfreakinhero ever that is just her character I hate and not the Actress.

Because I really do hate the Character Tara.[/quote]

Well that would mean the actor has done their job then. [/quote]

She plays a good guy.

[quote]four60 wrote:

[quote]Derek542 wrote:

[quote]four60 wrote:
Tara Sucks I hate the character. I only hope if this rumor is true and she is signed to play the greatest female Action/Zombie/Superfreakinhero ever that is just her character I hate and not the Actress.

Because I really do hate the Character Tara.[/quote]

Well that would mean the actor has done their job then. [/quote]

She plays a good guy.[/quote]

I’d say she plays a mentally unstable, hostile bitch who manifests the very worst traits of children of a single-parent alcoholic mostly-absent mother. She has some good in her heart, and tries to be supportive of her friends and cousin, but she just as often alienates people.

In short, I think the actress plays Tara almost perfectly. I don’t think you’re really supposed to ‘like’ Tara (unless you’re my brother, who has some…odd fetishes)…the obviously ‘bad’ guys are much more likable, in general.

I’ve seen her in other roles, and it took me several minutes to recognize the actress, not from physical changes, but simply because her role was played so differently.

I think that Rutina Wesley (the actress) could pull off the role extremely well. It depends on other factors, of course, but…she has the chops.

[quote]kevinm1 wrote:

[quote]roybot wrote:

[quote]Robert A wrote:

[quote]roybot wrote:

[quote] Robert A wrote:

Maybe I didn’t. Just thought the episode was weak for a bunch of reasons.

From memory:

1.) The Bag of Guns-this is fucking weak at best. In Georgia a bag full of shotguns and a few deer rifles is unlikely to be the huge commodity. Ammo maybe, but a few 870’s, not so much. I get why the “group” would have wanted them, but the city should be fairly full of weapons.

2.) The hospital/retirement home-The “vatos” should either have been over-run, or would have been in a more secure compound. The whole “city is a death trap” thing makes this less than likely. Food, water, and medical supplies would also be a huge issue unless the hospital/home was “purged” of the majority of its residents. Most of these places keep less than a week of food, or meds, and rely on laundry services. They are not going to be all that self sufficient without serious restocking and up armoring.

3.) The lets have everyone sitting around a fire with no guards, and make a ton of noise thing was really bad. If they would have staged it better if wouldn’t have rubbed me the wrong way. The lack of perimeter at the camp seemed out of character even for a group of random people this deep into the zombie take over.

[/quote] I always assumed that the care home wasn’t in the city and they sent out scouting/ raiding/ scavenging parties to obtain the most accessible supplies - hence the run-in with Rick and Co.[/quote]

Well, I will go with that from now on. Makes me move towards liking the episode more. Still, number 4 is the biggie for me.

SPOILER at link

Regards,

Robert A[/quote]

I can’t comment on # 4 as I’ve never read the com-books. I’ve done enough reading around to know that there is a gradual shift in morality (which is why I mentioned both Shane’s and Rick’s change into civilian clothes as a move towards that- especially Rick).

I don’t know how the comic explains re-animation, but the explanation given by Jenner at the CDC /bunker seemed to be comprehensive enough to support the deliberate branching off from the comics. Maybe Jenner whispered to Rick that his little demo was a sham, more likely he saw Shane and Lori having a moment and told Rick what he saw. Yep.[/quote]
Walking Dead follows original Romero rules, anyone who dies becomes a zombie not just from an infected bite.
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
W
A
R
N
I
N
G

Shane is killed off very early on in the book and Rick actually goes back to where they buried to kill him because he Shane comes back as a zombie.[/quote]

Yup, and that is why hospitals, nursing homes, and anywhere there is a concentration of people that require medical interventions (drugs, procedures, etc.) to stay breathing would be fucking death traps. A month into no more insulin and diabetics would be time bombs.

It sort of explains why the national guard was executing apparently healthy people in the hospital flash back.

Regards,

Robert A

Tara is not playing Michonne

[quote]kevinm1 wrote:

Tara is not playing Michonne[/quote]

The Bad ass chick from Death Proof should get the part. Whoever gets the part will have to be a damn good actress. Go from bad ass to crazy to calm, slutty back to Super Badass.

Potential spoiler:

I am curious if they will expound on how the zombies got out of hand in the first place. Not necessarily the infectious agent (e.g., virus, nanites), but how it spread in the first place.

I am presuming everyone still alive at this point is infected and becomes zombies: (1) if they die for any reason; (2) if they are immuno compromised or don’t have some sort of inate partial resistance; or (3) get a huge dose of the virus (or whatever) via a bite.

I suspect No. 1 is what the doctor told Rick.

No. 2 is really necessary to explain how the zombies got out of hand in the first place — even if the recently dead were to rise and stumble around, normal humans would have them outnumbered 99 to 1. You’d have some deaths, but we’d pretty quickly get ahold of the situation — it takes of lot of zombies to get the aware, and people were quickly aware.

I also note that there are a lot of “kin” survivors, which indicate a level of genetic immunity, bolstering No. 2 a bit.

But most importantly, you’d need an initial critical mass of zombies (say, 1/3 or more of the population just get infected) to have the worldwide disaster on your hands. This would take a route of infection — air borne, or perhaps contaminated flu shots — other than a bite from a zombie.

^^^ – From what I understand of the specific zombie-logic of this series, is that it’s similar to the seminal Romero documentary trilogy (night, dawn, day). Everyone who dies, assuming an intact brain, rises. Plus, everyone bitten by a zombie will in fact rapidly die, and rise, of some massive infection. Part of the intrigue of zombie films is that there isn’t a complete explanation of why zombies rise – zombie films generally take place in the time period where people are still too confused by events to possibly study the phenomenon.

That said, as a general background, part of the speculation on the ‘why’ of spreading hints at the notion that if recently dead people start rising, people will gather around them to see what’s going on. Since the zombie’s first reaction is to bite, loved ones, first-responders, and hospital staff would get fatally wounded within hours of the first rising – and for several hours to a day, most of those fatally wounded people would have no idea that they were in fact fatally wounded.

It would take at least a few days worth of deaths to clearly understand that the bite is fatal and that all recently dead folks are inevitably rising, and in those few days people would panic in a way that would probably increase confusion, fatality, and additional risings.

Ah, the physics and metaphysics of zombies. Someone should start a discussion board for this type of topic, maybe even write a survival guide…

[quote]LHT wrote:

Ah, the physics and metaphysics of zombies. Someone should start a discussion board for this type of topic, maybe even write a survival guide…[/quote]

Fucking lol, you sir get 1000 internet points.

No deodorant! Everyone stinks.

[quote]Robert A wrote:

[quote]kevinm1 wrote:

[quote]roybot wrote:

[quote]Robert A wrote:

[quote]roybot wrote:

[quote] Robert A wrote:

Maybe I didn’t. Just thought the episode was weak for a bunch of reasons.

From memory:

1.) The Bag of Guns-this is fucking weak at best. In Georgia a bag full of shotguns and a few deer rifles is unlikely to be the huge commodity. Ammo maybe, but a few 870’s, not so much. I get why the “group” would have wanted them, but the city should be fairly full of weapons.

2.) The hospital/retirement home-The “vatos” should either have been over-run, or would have been in a more secure compound. The whole “city is a death trap” thing makes this less than likely. Food, water, and medical supplies would also be a huge issue unless the hospital/home was “purged” of the majority of its residents. Most of these places keep less than a week of food, or meds, and rely on laundry services. They are not going to be all that self sufficient without serious restocking and up armoring.

3.) The lets have everyone sitting around a fire with no guards, and make a ton of noise thing was really bad. If they would have staged it better if wouldn’t have rubbed me the wrong way. The lack of perimeter at the camp seemed out of character even for a group of random people this deep into the zombie take over.

[/quote] I always assumed that the care home wasn’t in the city and they sent out scouting/ raiding/ scavenging parties to obtain the most accessible supplies - hence the run-in with Rick and Co.[/quote]

Well, I will go with that from now on. Makes me move towards liking the episode more. Still, number 4 is the biggie for me.

SPOILER at link

Regards,

Robert A[/quote]

I can’t comment on # 4 as I’ve never read the com-books. I’ve done enough reading around to know that there is a gradual shift in morality (which is why I mentioned both Shane’s and Rick’s change into civilian clothes as a move towards that- especially Rick).

I don’t know how the comic explains re-animation, but the explanation given by Jenner at the CDC /bunker seemed to be comprehensive enough to support the deliberate branching off from the comics. Maybe Jenner whispered to Rick that his little demo was a sham, more likely he saw Shane and Lori having a moment and told Rick what he saw. Yep.[/quote]
Walking Dead follows original Romero rules, anyone who dies becomes a zombie not just from an infected bite.
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
W
A
R
N
I
N
G

Shane is killed off very early on in the book and Rick actually goes back to where they buried to kill him because he Shane comes back as a zombie.[/quote]

Yup, and that is why hospitals, nursing homes, and anywhere there is a concentration of people that require medical interventions (drugs, procedures, etc.) to stay breathing would be fucking death traps. A month into no more insulin and diabetics would be time bombs.

It sort of explains why the national guard was executing apparently healthy people in the hospital flash back.

Regards,

Robert A[/quote]

They explain that uninfected corpses rise upon death in the series. I thought you were referring to a point made in the c/books but not in the series with # 4. The whole point of that ep is to show how a certain type of person may not respond to a situation in the way you expect them to.

The people who would leave the weak for dead and get the hell out of Dodge to save their own skins are not going to survive because, sooner or later, they’ll come up against other like-minded individuals.

[quote]thethirdruffian wrote:
Potential spoiler:

I am curious if they will expound on how the zombies got out of hand in the first place. Not necessarily the infectious agent (e.g., virus, nanites), but how it spread in the first place.

I am presuming everyone still alive at this point is infected and becomes zombies: (1) if they die for any reason; (2) if they are immuno compromised or don’t have some sort of inate partial resistance; or (3) get a huge dose of the virus (or whatever) via a bite.

I suspect No. 1 is what the doctor told Rick.

No. 2 is really necessary to explain how the zombies got out of hand in the first place — even if the recently dead were to rise and stumble around, normal humans would have them outnumbered 99 to 1. You’d have some deaths, but we’d pretty quickly get ahold of the situation — it takes of lot of zombies to get the aware, and people were quickly aware.

I also note that there are a lot of “kin” survivors, which indicate a level of genetic immunity, bolstering No. 2 a bit.

But most importantly, you’d need an initial critical mass of zombies (say, 1/3 or more of the population just get infected) to have the worldwide disaster on your hands. This would take a route of infection — air borne, or perhaps contaminated flu shots — other than a bite from a zombie.[/quote]

LHT is right on about how the plague works in the books. The series, I am not so sure.

I sort of covered this earlier in the thread and linked to the Wiki for walking dead. The link is a SPOILER if you are trying to avoid any discussion of the comics.

Here is the way I see it working out. If we follow the Romero esque everyone is a zombie rules. We also have to recognize that the traditional zombie world is one where there is no zombie fiction. Otherwise this doesn’t work. None of the characters have the frame of reference to say “holy shit a zombie, shoot for the head”.

Initial Onset:
One day/night the event starts. This is not “patient zero” or even “zombie zero”, but thousands of “zombie zero’s” accross the globe. In first world countries there are going to be two major sources of “walkers”. First, any place where there are likely to be non-embalmed bodies in storage, and the general public.

So, the dead in hospitals/nursing homes/hospice start going “shambler” and bite some staff. No one knows what the fuck is going on. Pretty soon no one is dying, but they are getting tied down. HUGE issues with feral seeming patients with no vital signs but are mobile and aggressive. If it was one locus the call to the CDC would start a quarantine and even if the incinerated via MOAB it would be controlled. The issue is the CDC is getting a call from every hospital in the country. Actually, every hospital in the world.

Coinciding with this are all the “dead” who expired outside of the hospitals and turned/rose before they got carted off to a morgue. These bite/infect family members, people, and especially first responders. The fever post bite, if it would even happen with such fresh corpses, cycle people into the hospitals. Now we have a situation where police, fire, and paramedic/EMT services are dealing with large numbers of infected in their ranks and they have no protocol to handle it. The cops are still tazing/wrestling with the dead to little avail. No zombie movies, and no one is taking a headshot on fresh looking zombies who are un armed. Walkers are getting dumped into hospitals, people who manage to put down walkers are getting arrested and stuffed in cells, where they might infect others.

It builds/Civil unrest:
Quarantines and public announcements are made. People are getting fearful. There will be looting/fires/shenanigans. Martial law will be declared in some areas. Crowds doing the looting will be a source of food for any homeless turned walkers or walkers that come from other sources. At this point a dead body is not getting the Law and Order/CSI rollout. It is laying there and then getting up. People are told to stay in there homes. Curfew happens. Violence adds to the number of free walkers. Hospitals may have started to figure out that patients need to be in restraints. Walkers don’t need to eat so they can be “held” in quarantine. At this point the shamblers are still going to be “people” or “patients” legally speaking. They are not going to be being put down en mass. The medical and social systems are being taxed heavily.

Gen III problems:
Disruptions in normal order are leading to a bunch of problems. Hospitals are getting overloaded. Fear is building. There are runs on food/supplies in stores. Prescription meds are in short supply (this will be a huge source of zombies). Lack of transportation of food is a huge problem. Peoples desire to flee quarantine/affected areas coupled with martial law is creating a huge issue. The first responders are largely infected/“sick” or staying home. Military is probably supplying the man power for keeping order. Everything is under Federal control. It is apparent to government that the dead are just that, dead. They are not sick. Efforts to treat them as such is going to spur serious social issues. Heads of government flee to isolated/secure locations. The issue is that anyone who dies of natural causes is a threat, and politicians and generals tend to be old. There will be attempts to “sanitize” areas/volumes of infected. Two issues, people who see this as murder and people who see it as a sign all bets are off. Looting, rioting, every city is looking like post-Katrina New Orleans. At this point most of the damage is being done by living people.

Gen IV/Breakdown
Central control of government breaks down. The higher ups are AWOL or in secure locations (that are just a heart attack away from being nonnsecure). In The Walking Dead no nukes were used, but the military was using conventional weapons on population centers. That is the marking point for this stage. First, attacks are ordered on the population. Then no one is giving orders and the last order was “shoot anything that looks suspicious”. If you recall the hospital flashback where the National Guard was mowing down apparently alive people in hospital gowns, this is the background. Individual units are breaking up. There is no “rule of law” being enforced. People flee. Shit has gotten real. The highways are plugged up with people fleeing to wherever. Any death in a crowd is a new infection. Many of the flashbacks in the show are from this time. Between live on live murder and dead on live murder the scales tip to there being more dead than living. Nearly everyone who requires medical care to stay alive is dead at this point.

Undead World
Series opener. We are up to speed.

Regards,

Robert A

roybot,

I get that was supposed to be the message. Two things, first I missed where they said that uninfected rise in the TV series. I thought they were leaving it more open. Second, nursing home level care is going to be impossible. There will not be enough supportive meds for the patients and the death rate is going to make the place a ground zero every other day.

I thought they could have done a better job of creating a unexpected scenario that still would work by the rules the series follows. If direct infection/zombie bite is needed than it is more plausible to have a “nursing home” type facility.

I agree that the people who completely screw others would likely get theirs. It is why I am not on Team Shane. As soon as The Bionic Redneck realizes that Shane would just as soon use anyone as walker bait he would take him out. If Michonne shows up, Shane would get offed HARD.

Regards,

Robert A

[quote]Robert A wrote:
roybot,

I get that was supposed to be the message. Two things, first I missed where they said that uninfected rise in the TV series. I thought they were leaving it more open. Second, nursing home level care is going to be impossible. There will not be enough supportive meds for the patients and the death rate is going to make the place a ground zero every other day.

I thought they could have done a better job of creating a unexpected scenario that still would work by the rules the series follows. If direct infection/zombie bite is needed than it is more plausible to have a “nursing home” type facility.
[/quote]

When it comes down to it, there’s only so much story they can fit into one episode. We can only speculate over whether the remaining Vatos were aware of the relative weakness of their position and if they had a stockpile of meds from surrounding hospitals. It’s possible that they had a method of dealing with any “eventualities”. It’s equally possible that they assumed the disease was only transmitted through contact. The important part is that they appeared to be the most likely to put themselves first and they didn’t - most of their number had already left by the time Rick encountered them; that would make their situation more manageable.

[quote]roybot wrote:

[quote]Robert A wrote:
roybot,

I get that was supposed to be the message. Two things, first I missed where they said that uninfected rise in the TV series. I thought they were leaving it more open. Second, nursing home level care is going to be impossible. There will not be enough supportive meds for the patients and the death rate is going to make the place a ground zero every other day.

I thought they could have done a better job of creating a unexpected scenario that still would work by the rules the series follows. If direct infection/zombie bite is needed than it is more plausible to have a “nursing home” type facility.
[/quote]

When it comes down to it, there’s only so much story they can fit into one episode. We can only speculate over whether the remaining Vatos were aware of the relative weakness of their position and if they had a stockpile of meds from surrounding hospitals. It’s possible that they had a method of dealing with any “eventualities”. It’s equally possible that they assumed the disease was only transmitted through contact. The important part is that they appeared to be the most likely to put themselves first and they didn’t - most of their number had already left by the time Rick encountered them; that would make their situation more manageable.

[/quote]
People old enough to require nursing home level care would be time bombs. Anyone that is on multiple meds to get by would be in trouble. It is not that I am saying they needed to be abandoned, I am thinking that they would have been the first casualties. They would not be there to save.

I think a population that has strong family ties and is ready to commit acts violence would be in pretty good shape relative to the public at large. The “vatos” fit the bill, so I liked that aspect of it. My issue is not that the episode didn’t portray the Latino’s with tats as a roving band of savages. It’s that the writers put them in a situation where they were surrounded by a completely unlikely amount of “unexploded ordinance”.

It was my least favorite episode of season 1.

Regards,

Robert A