[quote]kylec72 wrote:
BONEZ217 wrote:
kylec72 wrote:
Chris Colucci wrote:
AccipiterQ wrote:
I posted a few weeks ago about how I was 189 at 12.4% BF … Today I weighed in at 181 … a hair over 9% (9.3%).
189 @ 12.4% = 165.5 pounds lean body mass.
181 @ 9.3% = 164 pounds lean body mass.
Just sayin’. Keep this up, and you’ll disappear soon enough. But as long as you’re looking and feeling better today than you did a few weeks ago, I guess you’re headed where you want to go.
Is that normal to drop that much body fat while losing only 8 lbs? I would have assumed it would take more than 8 lbs to drop 3.1% body fat because of water weight, and that doesn’t even include the 1.5 lbs of lean body mass lost subtracted from the 8 lbs. I must be confused about something.
UMMM it’s a percentage.
He started off with 23.436 lbs of body fat at a body weight of 189 lbs. He’s now at 16.833 lbs of body fat at a body weight of 181 lbs. That means 6.603 lbs of body fat were lost out of the 8 lbs of body weight, which equates to .825 lbs of body fat lost per each lb of body weight. Whether it’s in percentages or integers that doesn’t mean anything. My question is whether this is a normal rate of fat loss (82.5% body fat lost per lb of body weight)? That seems like an insanely high rate of fat loss per lb of body weight.
How do we know the other 17.5% wasn’t mostly water weight, not lean body mass? If the body fat percentages are accurate for the beginning and ending body weight, then I’m curious to hear if this is a normal rate or what?
By my estimation and Accipiter’s remarks regarding his increase in strength I doubt he lost much lean body mass, if any at all. I may be wrong about the water weight loss, though, and that’s the reason for my confusion. [/quote]
I has everything to do with the individual in question. If someone is 40% bodyfat and loses 50 pounds chances are a larger portion of that 50 pounds is going to be fat mass, compared to someone who is 15% bodyfat and loses 50 pounds.
Even if you consider one person the results will vary at different times. The lower your bodyfat percentage is at the beggining of a “cut” the more likely it is that you will lose LBM along with fat mass, if the person is training without AAS.