[quote]KBCThird wrote:
greekdawg wrote:
KBCThird wrote:
If you have to put on 50 lbs of bodyweight to add 5 lbs onto your lift YOU GOT STRONGER.
I’m sorry than you did not get stronger. So yould potentially sacrifice 50 lbs of weight (not necessarily muscle) just to say you got stronger by 5 lbs? That is the saddest thing I’ve seen written. And yes, I’m a powerlifter. I
This is an honest question: if adding 5 lbs to a lift doesnt qualify you as having gotten stronger, do you have a definition of “getting stronger” that does not involve bodyweight ratios? I’d use myself as an example: I benched 320 at a bw around 185-190, and 360@230. The weight gain just came from lifting over the years, not as a concentrated effort to up my bench. My ratio was better at 190, but I dont see how you can say that a 40 lb increase in an exercise isnt a gain in strength simply because there was 40lb gain in bw
[/quote]
We just agree to disagree then. When I first started PLing the first gym I went to practiced the GFH plan: eat everything and keep moving up in weight,train hard, etc. They were strong, but they also keep getting bigger and bigger and it wasn’t all clean (fat).
Eventually, one guy reached a cieling. You go to a nationals and you see that the guys in your weight class are outclassing you because they much more muscle. Not to mention, all of the negatives that come with carrying extra bodyfat. Eventually, my old coach had to cut back down to be competitive and regain his health.
Sure, gaining weight (be it muscle or fat) will make your lifts go up. Carrying more bulk wil definitely help the squat and of course the bench.
fast forward, I now train at a PL gym with a group of guys who are realtively lean, watch their diets to a certain extent and focus on getting stronger through gaining muscle and heural adaption. The result, I now outclass all of those guys at my old gym and they are much heavier than me.
Like I said, maybe we just have two definitions of what you consider strong and the means to get there. But I would never pat myself on the back getting stronger but just letting myself get sloppy.
Take your example of you, you gained 40 lbs increase in your bench. You also gained 40 lbs of bodyweight. Now if most of it was muscle than hey, of course it is a positive. More muscle is always a good thing.