Rate & Critique

Success!!

What’s up with bumping these old threads, Smash? It’s definitely hilarious when people respond as if they weren’t months old and dead for almost as long, though.

Meh didnt look at dates, assumed that since i hadnt seen it before it was new, someone bumped it.

Great abs for sure. Chest and biceps could be a bit bigger but you’ve already acknowledged that.

…and being 31 and looking like that is very impressive.

B-3

ooppsss didn’t look at the dates either. sorry.

[quote]darlenetextil wrote:
ajweins wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
I think the OP looks very good. I understand that he’s not enormous but 95% of men would love to look like that.

[/quote]

Yes and the other 5% of men are actually men

[quote]bmitch wrote:
Leggies?[/quote]

Yeah! A physique is your entire body, not just your upper body. So, here I go again with my infamous question, what about the legs?

[quote]venusismyplanet wrote:
bmitch wrote:
Leggies?

Yeah! A physique is your entire body, not just your upper body. So, here I go again with my infamous question, what about the legs?[/quote]

Sure hun, your infamous question.

-Z

you need to eat more and bulk up

[quote]Defekt wrote:
So this guy who posts no pictures but anything of his abs, no back shot, no leg shot, nothing but abs and a half assed most muscular which showcases subpar chest development and this guy gets the rating that he does?

Seriously?

What the fuck has happened to this site, I thought this was rate my physique not rate my abs, and i really cant see how his physique is anything special at all.

I thought this was T-Nation not abercrombie.com

I am so dissapointed with you guys right now.

[/quote]

er…damnit smasher…

Ellos no entienden que voz no entendes mucho ingles. Ellos quieren pruebas de todo, como yo, cuando pregunte…que paso con tus piernas? Bueno, quisas ya te cansaste de ser parte de este sitio; te deseo suerte.

Paz!

Mi madre nacio en Buenos Aires tambien.

[quote]6PackZack wrote:
venusismyplanet wrote:
bmitch wrote:
Leggies?

Yeah! A physique is your entire body, not just your upper body. So, here I go again with my infamous question, what about the legs?

Sure hun, your infamous question.

-Z
[/quote]

And, as long as people keep posting threads for a rating without leg pics, I will continue to ask the same question…

[quote]theflowjob wrote:
darlenetextil wrote:
ajweins wrote:
Bonn1997 wrote:
I think the OP looks very good. I understand that he’s not enormous but 95% of men would love to look like that.

Yes and the other 5% of men are actually men[/quote]

Hheheheeheh!!!

What a moron. Your Dr., I mean. I can’t begin to tell you how much “help” I’ve gotten from doctors over the past 4 years for my pain.

too much stuff to read all thorugh, but in that first picture it looks like you are throwing your shoulders back beyond where they’d naturally hang, which would make you look less wide (i think?)

even though it’s not really a “pose”, it looks a little odd

First off I do not know if this guy is a troll or not but either way this is a great physique. 99.9 percent of the people on this site are not in this good of shape and probably not as strong as this guy. This poster does not need to do a thing for his physique to be better. I see some people giving him advise on how to improve and thier photos clearly show that they are not in the same class as this guy. What a joke. And as for legs go why would you need to see them with an upperbody like that who would even notice. I rate it a 9. Way to go!!!

From what weve seen you’re right, he doesnt need to do a thing.

Well aside from sprouting legs, and other major muscle groups.

[quote]BIGERIC wrote:
This poster does not need to do a thing for his physique to be better. I see some people giving him advise on how to improve and thier photos clearly show that they are not in the same class as this guy. What a joke. And as for legs go why would you need to see them with an upperbody like that who would even notice. I rate it a 9. Way to go!!![/quote]

I’m sorry, but you are completeley wrong. We are in a “rate my phyhsique” forum, not a rate my “upper body” forum. Haven’t you noticed how many guys on here post pics of just their upper body and then when they do post leg pics, they’re legs are not impressive at all? You know why? B/c some don’t train their legs at all! To rate a physique in this forum, a photo showing your ENTIRE physique should be posted.

Also, his upper body is not worth a 9, maybe a 7-8. We all have differing opinions of what a physique is and that’s why we’re here; to express our opinions and rate.

Well, that’s enough.

[quote]BIGERIC wrote:
First off I do not know if this guy is a troll or not but either way this is a great physique. 99.9 percent of the people on this site are not in this good of shape and probably not as strong as this guy. This poster does not need to do a thing for his physique to be better. I see some people giving him advise on how to improve and thier photos clearly show that they are not in the same class as this guy. What a joke. And as for legs go why would you need to see them with an upperbody like that who would even notice. I rate it a 9. Way to go!!![/quote]

You obviously haven’t seen some of the people who HAVE gotten 9s here. The difference is MARKED. I would hope that 99.9 perecent statistic is wrong. That’d be sad for T-Nation. But really besides the point. When taking into account those who HAVE taken the plunge and posted pictures, he’s not a 9. The guy is quite lean which is always very good. Good lines. Some decent development of the upper body. But much less devloped than the equally lean and well-proportioned people here who got ratings of 8 or 9.

Let’s pretend for a minute that this thread is not MORE THAN A YEAR OLD… :wink:

It will be a sad day when the majority of posters here consider a physique like this impressive or worthy of praise. Not to take anything away from the OP, he obviously put some effort into it, but all I see is a lean upper body with visible abs and pretty decent development. Nothing more, nothing less. Acting as if this was the pinnacle of what can be achieved is limiting yourself by your own beliefs.

This is clearly “rate my physique” and as stated in some post before…“if you cant stand the heat, dont post your pics in the first place!!!”. He is lean, BUT yep, needs size totally.

Ive posted my pics and was ready for the pounding you can get in here…if anything it made me work harder!! This topic is deffo not ment for the “timid”, and for all out there including this dude, if you think you are ready to post in here, ya better get used to the slamming. If he was that lean but bigger, I would have given him at least a 8…maybe.