[quote]Nikki9591 wrote:
Ample amount of cardio and circuits? Are you referring to the BodyRock vids I did yesterday for the first time in MONTHS? Or pushing 70 lbs across the floor as HiiT for 7-10 minutes?
Yes, I will get defensive when someone comes to my log for the 4th or 5th time to tell me that what I do is pointless. If I want to do 1000 BW squats, I don’t see how that should raise concern for others. If I want to do 10 sets of squats, I don’t see how that should raise concern either. I don’t agree with things that she does, but I’ve never once gone to her log and criticized her about it… especially sarcastically.
If I feel insulted? Nah. Kinda weird that you chose this time to be the first time to speak to me. But not insulted.
I’ve always been interested in periodization. The method I want to do isn’t much different from what I do since some still utilize doing 10 sets of exercises.
If I’m going to be critized for everything I do, might as well go all out huh?[/quote]
Nikki, it seems clear that you have some issues with people saying things that disagree with what you want to hear. I completely understand and have my own issues with that. This is why being on an online forum where personalities are hidden can be hard. It’s one of the reasons that I don’t comment on many people’s logs where I don’t know kind of lifter they are…because I don’t want to get messed up in conflict or get into some kind of debate (I’ve wasted too much time with that!). To my understanding the entire purpose of this forum is for all of us to not only be a support system, but to guide, critique, and learn from others. I’m not sure what your history with MIM is, but I can only comment on the last thing I read that she had said, and which I agree with.
Doing your workouts how they are now may be fun, but they don’t seem to have any purpose besides maybe making you feel like you are doing a lot. I know how it is to want to pack on the volume and feel good because you feel like you are accomplishing something (being tired, sore, sweaty, etc.). But working hard on that single day is the only thing that is being achieved. There does not seem to be any larger plan, mostly because these workouts cannot lead to anything more than just the day to day. For the most part I wouldn’t care, but with the amount of volume and potential for serious overtraining and the physical consequences it entails, this is not a sustainable means of progress. You seem intense about training so my only purpose in commenting is to be helpful.
I totally understand how doing tons of stuff can be fun…I used to do TONS of cardio in college and loved those endorphins (not saying you are doing tons of cardio). I kind of had a plan, but mostly just did whatever my energy levels could let me do that day. But that was when I didn’t know shit about strength training and had no clear goal besides knowing I wanted to look different. There is a science behind the combination of nutrition and training (I have only scratched the surface of trying to understand), and only by taking that into account when planning can goals be achieved. This is why year after year people go to the gym and do what they think they should do and never look any different. But planning is hard. I myself am in no man’s land right now, with no official commitment anything now that I am not powerlifting per se, so I can go in a do some cardio here, some heavy days there, etc., because I am not inside a structure. But it won’t get me anywhere. Training is just so much better when there is a clear goal and a clear plan to get there!
I’ll leave it at that. People are going to do whatever they are going to do. No one on here knows everything and I have realized being a lifter requires humility. But some do know more than others, simply from experience, and it is helpful to me and should be to you to want to learn from them.
By the way, if the method of doing ten sets that you reference is GVT, feel free to ask me any questions about it!