I think both ways work, and many others too. Even on the AD, despite it’s magic and rule breaking, at some point its about caloric intake. Not in the normal sense, but you get my drift.
I like Vas’ creativity. I have no problem whatsoever recommending his ideas. My thought is that (quick synopsis) if you are carb sensitive, then the best way to reduce/cut is to shorten the load and allow for a longer fat cycle.
CAREFUL HERE: Even possibly taking a single meal on wednesday (for about 100-200g CHO in the evening as last meal) and then doing the 12 hour load on Saturday will work well for many. Mixing the “tricky” mid-week spike with much longer of a weekend load can really screw you up though, so I usually only advocate it for cutting on folks who are carb sensitive AND yet feel run down mid week. They are a minority. If you find that you handle the loads easily enough, then feel free to keep the load longer and swing low-cal in the week. Randomness is really the key, in addition to making sure that your weekly amount is below maintenance.
For those who feel a bit weak and sluggish, I first like to spike calories on wednesday and go lower on mon, tues, thurs, fri. For this spike, I’ve done well with two things more than all else. Steak and olive oil. They are just energizing and satisfying. Just put the oil on your salad and steak or take a few spoons. Great for a pickup.
It’s all so relative and individual that you get to have fun and really learn yourself. As long as the CHO is kept in the acceptable range, and the load’s aren’t made too short or too long (12 being low end, @40 or so being high end) then all is good. We deal in “absolutes” with respect to the diet’s basic concepts, but allow for great lattitude with it’s practice thereafter.
Again, the one caveat on all this is to make sure you’ve been on the AD for a few weeks to get that initial adaptation. Don’t start out dieting or it could be rough on you. But really, if you can stick it out, then even that isn’t wrong in an absolute sense.
I don’t know about ya’ll, but that freedom makes the AD all the more appealing.
Now for lean gaining, I’ve seen it work best a few different ways. Opposite ways. ;-0.
For the carb sensitive person, keeping cals about 20+% (depends on YOUR body) above maintenance during the fat/protein phase and then spiking the cals on the load by only a bit more (say another 10%). The intake is pretty evenly distributed with this approach.
For the guy who does well on CHO loads, then moderate/maintenance weekdays and big loads can do well. Just watch that waistline!
For the cautious gainer, try waving the cals in a “coin-flip” fashion. Make tails your maintenance day, and heads your surplus day. Say 30% or more if you like. This should statistically give you 3-4 high days per week and a roughly equal amount of maint. days. It’s a gradual coaxing the works well for people who tend to be endomorphic.
In the end, the inverse caloric truth is in effect on gaining. No surplus = No mass gains.
But you knew that didn’t you? ;-). I just never cease to be amazed at how folks don’t realize that you have to measure and record to be sure. One of the “secrets” of results…measurement
best,
DH
[quote]mozhne wrote:
toddjacobs13 wrote:
Gentlemen,
I have noticed a difference in the recommendations for cutting while on the AD.
DH seems to recommend shortening the carb window and reducing carb intake to around 400 grams per weekend.
Vasu recommends waving calories throughout the week at low levels overall and then spiking with extremely high cals and high carbs on weekends.
I am interested to hear from the AD experts about the relative merits and drawbacks for each approach.
Todd
Hey Todd, Like Vasu I like waving calories. I used this approach with great results a few years ago cutting for a BodyBuilding contest. Personally I don’t ‘count’ cals, after this long in the trenches I have a pretty good idea of what/how many carbs/cals I’m getting. It seems to me that the rebound affect you get from going from low cals to high goes hand in hand with the AD.
Not sure of the science but practical experience has shown me time and again that once you ‘starve’ your muscles of something, the body super compensates when you give that something back to it. Witness the ‘Pump’ you get just from wolfing down some carbs on the weekend. Like anything give both a try. Follow the basic template of the AD and success is sure to come your way.
Barry[/quote]