[quote]jsbrook wrote:
Doesn’t mean that there aren’t legitimate purposes for anti-depressants and anti-anxiety drugs. They are overused, and many people would benefit more from changing their approach to life and taking accountability. But chemical and hormonal imbalances are real, and for some people all the self-actualization, positive thinking, and talk therapy in the world is not sufficient. [/quote]
I never said they should not be used, and can see times they should. Yet the current idea is if you are having a bad day, medicate.
Hormonal imbalances, true disease, those problems should be treated as hormonal imbalances and diseases. Psychological problems are different most of the time.
A good example is ADHD. This is a real problem, yet too many kids are diagnosed with the problem, and given the drug. Yet it has been shown (mid to late 80’s if I remember right) that something like 50% of the kids who were put on Ritalin without psychological or behavior treatment ended up in prison at some point in their life.
Also every time I hear the term chemical imbalance, I begin wondering if that really caused the problem, or if the problem led to that chemical imbalance? I believe the latter.
Lets use Tony here for an example. (Sorry Tony) He was depressed, house arrest ended, depression ended. Was that a chemical imbalance? Is this evidence that chemical imbalances can be corrected without drugs? It is wasn’t a chemical imbalance, would the drugs have worked in the first place?
Now before I turn this into a major rant, let me boil this down here. If it is used as a temporary thing with the assistance of external treatment, great. By itself, not so great.
This is just like the idea of prescribing drugs for fat loss without diet and exercise change. Or the same with heart medicine.
If a person is put on a heart medicine, the doctor most often tells them to exercise, and diet. To adjust their lifestyle. Too often doctors just prescribe the mental pain killer, and don’t ever treat the actual problem, or even think about it.
Now going to the opposite side, I also have a problem with most psychiatrists, psychologists, and psychotherapists. Not all, but most. I believe there are as many of them who truly understand the field as there are medical doctors who understand anabolic steroids.
This belief of mine is reinforced by watching the events around a close relative of mine. Nice girl went in with a minor problem, and suddenly all hell broke lose, and this nice girl turned into a total nightmare. The parents took charge, pulled her out, and she reverted to that nice person again. Years later a very bright and becoming successful person. And interestingly with that same initial problem that was supposed to be dealt with in the first place. (Little obsessive/compulsive behavior.)