[quote]tom63 wrote:
[quote]Theface wrote:
[quote]TheBodyGuard wrote:
[quote]Theface wrote:
Tom, where are you in practice? I’m an ART doc myself in Ohio, worked at the Rev3 (Ironman distance) at Cedar Point over the summer, and I was shocked by the amount of people who finished but looked like they would keel over if they tried even a .5 bw squat, Ironman is just a totally different type of training.
That being said, powerlifting, crossfitting, oly, endurance, what have you, I think it’s obvious that either is better than neither, so I’m not sure why we’re having the debate on what’s best, set your goals, post them, hold yourself (or get someone to hold you) accountable and accomplish them.[/quote]
why are you missing the point? I’m talking overall HEALTH. Are you seriously arguing that an activity like powerlifting is healthier over the long term than crossfitting, other things being equal? Seriously? Why is my point so hard to understand? This isn’t a debate about “what’s best”…it was a remark about crossfitting and health. [/quote]
TBG- not arguing with you…or are you just being contrary to anything anyone says? I completely understand your point, but you two are taking up positions: One saying powerlifting, you saying crossfitting, regardless of if or if not it’s a “what’s best” argument, you two are discussing, which of the two workout styles is better for overall health.
That was the point of my statement, to do what you want, id what you’re striving for, and then work to get it, whether that goal be good health or having a 1500+ total. I’d rather have people doing any form of physical activity than to sit around and eventually be a burden to society via lifestyle diseases.
Besides, I’m with you, I’ve been dabbling in the crossfit from time to time, especially on days where I have a limited time to warm up, work out and shower. From a general physical fitness standpoint, I agree, crossfit is better than powerlifting.[/quote]
I’m not saying powerlifting or crossfit is better to maintain and increase your health. My opinion is first do no harm, the second, do something. but you don’t need to do much to improve your health workout wise. I mean long term increase in longevity and quality of life as you age.
IMO, exercise people overrate the importance of exercise for your health compared to other things. Regular activity is needed. Controlling weight is important. Not abusing alcohol and not smoking might be more important.
For activity, do what you can and what you like. Just walking is better than just talking about what is optimal or bemoaning the fact that you can’t do a particular activity.[/quote]
As far as quality of life vs. longevity, I’m going to second that cross fitters would do pretty well to help maintain muscle mass/lean mass, strength levels, bone density, blood lipids, and cardiovascular health. Other programs can do all these things too - but competing as an elite powerlifter will not give you the same benefits. And I’d rather have quality life than simply be living…