[quote]Canada_K wrote:
TOO… MUCH… CUTENESS… ARGH!!!
The kittens are adorable. I just got my weeks’ worth of sugar looking at the pictures.
I have to say, I get all wrenched out of joint listening to you PL types wringing your hands over dieting and losing muscle. I’m going to cook up a full essay on this while I’m on holidays this weekend, but I simply gotta unload a few thoughts here and now before my head explodes.
When it comes to food, the bodybuilders have you powerlifting types beat hands down. When a person is eating at a deficit and partitioning their carbs, it is physiologically impossible to lose muscle if you are still lifting hard. IT SIMPLY DOESN’T HAPPEN! What usually goes on is you suffer from lethargy and low energy, which you strength junkies incorrectly interpret as strength loss.
My personal experience, having dieted real hard a couple times now, is that I even scored some PRs after 4 months of eating 1600 cal/d of nothing but meat and spinach.
All this garbage about “losing muscle” is inappropriate mental hijinks based on the fact that dieting affects your mood. At several points in every diet you get hysterical, and start looking for reasons to justify quitting. If you’ve got a good support system (like this board) that can help you with the vaginal inflammation, you get through it.
I believe the real difference between bodybuilders and powerlifters is that powerlifters refuse to control their eating. Now that I’ve irritated everybody here, you may flame me.
[/quote]
Uh…I have no problem with that. In fact, I am pretty sure that I am actually gaining a bit of mass. Of course, I don’t know that I am really running at a caloric deficit. I am trying to partition my carbs, as you say, and clean up the diet overall.
And the lethargy/low energy (running out of gas quickly) is definitely an issue. I think I need more protein in my diet, as well, to counter the “frailty” that I feel on my MEs, when the weights get heavier.
I think there is some validity to your last paragraph, EXCEPT, I think that most powerlifters seek the strength and relish the mass as an added benefit. Bodybuilders seek the mass, and relish the strength as an added benefit. Different goals that can yield both, to varying degrees. Not needing to be cut (for PLs) does provide a nice excuse not to reign in the diet too much though.
Edit: Wait…who’s powerlifting? I am definintely doing more of a BB, rather than PL, routine right now.