[quote]angry chicken wrote:
[quote]EmilyQ wrote:
[quote]Dr. Pangloss wrote:
[quote]EmilyQ wrote:
On another note, I think rape is EXTREMELY interesting from an anthropological perspective. Why are women stigmatized for this by men when having had a consensual partner does not? Once upon a time it would have been because women were expected to be virgins. Not so today.
Yet the stigma and fear persists.[/quote]
Are women stigmatized for having been raped? I’ve heard of horror stories about cruel cops, and nurses, and doctors, and DA’s but I don’t know. It wouldn’t dawn on me to stigmatize a rape victim.
[/quote]
Are they not? I think from women’s perspective there is an assumption that men (romantic partners and prospective partners) find it somewhat repugnant. Like an unclean thing.
Is this just the women’s own feeling projected?
AC, is it JUST about the emotional piece?[/quote]
I don’t find it “repugnant”. I mean the act, of course, but not the victim. Now I think that rape can be a slippery slope and not a black and white issue and there are various level of trauma involved. I mean two people getting drunk at a party and fucking can be considered rape (and men have been convicted of just that). Just as a predatory attack can - but those are FAR different scenarios. But the same word is used to describe it…
I also think that sometimes women put themselves in situations that are fucking STUPID. Like they think the world is a safe and pretty place filled with rainbows and butterflies. Then they get raped and fall into the victim mentality. Well, PERHAPS if she didn’t cut through that ally alone, wearing that short skirt, drunk from the club, etc… and made a more responsible decision, it wouldn’t have happened. Not in any way saying a rape victim isn’t a “victim” of a crime, but let’s face it, people make stupid decisions and then bitch about the results.
I know some guys who have an opinion that they are “damaged goods” after that, but these are the same guys (often with religious convictions) who put women up on a pedestal and want to marry a virgin.
An Iraq veteran friend of mine told me how when Sadaam Husein was in power, he (or someone in his gov’t) would often arrest the wife of a political enemy and force the man to watch as his wife was raped by a guy with a horse cock. Then the guy would often kill THE WIFE! Or divorce her at least. So some people have some very fucked up insecurities or convictions about it.
As for your question, FOR ME, it’s just the emotional piece. I don’t view her as any more damaged as someone who got into a car accident. It sucks, but sometimes bad things happen to good people. And sometimes good people make bad decisions that cause a negative cascade of events.
I may seem like I’m coming off a little harsh about a rape victim’s decisions being a factor, but that’s how I feel. I did 4 years in prison. As a young white guy (who is good looking), I was often the target of rape, either by innuendo, threat, or an actual attack. However, my ass is still exit only. Why? Because I didn’t put myself in a position of vulnerability. I knew my environment was unsafe and I made adjustments. I didn’t take the sanctity of my asshole for granted. And I never got raped. I had to stab a few guys who tried. But for the most part I was able to AVOID the scenario that would make me vulnerable. Many women don’t do that. They think they are “entitled” to a safe walk through a dark ally alone late at night or with a skinny guy wearing tight pants. And then they wonder, “why me?”.
Not saying the trauma is any less, but the lack of responsible decision making is a contributing factor. I also recognize that there are plenty of attacks that occur in what “should” be a safe environment and that a woman is a true victim of a predator. But that’s not always the case, yet the same word is used. I don’t like that.
[/quote]
I worked in an inner city high school in Texas and we had an anti-violence student group. It was supposed to be an awareness-building group, but most of the kids in it had trauma backgrounds, so there was a lot of processing and group therapy. Anyway, it was all do-gooder girls until a boy joined because, I believed, he wanted to meet the girls. The kid eventually became a core member of the group and someone I saw individually for counseling. LOVED that kid, though he was a complete nightmare.
Anyway, one day in group the girls were trying get across to him how much it sucks to be a female and vulnerable to attack and one said dramatically “I don’t have a choice about walking through Zilker Park alone after dark.” And the kid goes “You think I walk through Zilker Park alone at night?” And then laughed his ass off.
I agree with you. Women and girls don’t deserve to be raped any more than that kid would deserve to get jumped, but they should still be mindful of safety regardless of blamelessness.
I also agree that there is a difference between types of “rape” and there should be different terminology for some of the date/hookup situations - though some date rape is rape in its purest sense.
Thank you for clarifying your views on the “unclean” piece.