[quote]heavythrower wrote:
RickJames wrote:
supermick wrote:
Kara is a powerlifter and Not a goddess, although im sure some of you think otherwise.
No-one in this thread is personally attacking her, its more critising her gear, ROM, maybe shes been on test etc. IMO there is nothing wrong with this and nothing wrong with having a different point of view but all the overprotective posts are a bit pukeworthy to be honest.
If i posted a vid of me benching i’d expect criticism - why should she be different? As long is it wasnt personal i wouldnt bat an eyelid.
Maybe it’s because I’m actually around people that lift everyday, but to me, it was no big deal that she arched, reduced ROM, used a shirt, etc. It is what it is. If you can’t figure out that what she did is impressive for a female (or even most guys her size), you probably don’t spend a lot of time around women or people that lift. I know what it takes to arch, reduce ROM, and all the other tricks powerlfiters use, and I know the difference between that and flat backing a close grip bench.
It seemed that people got their panties in a wad about how she was lifting when it was, in fact, a training video with no claims attached. This lead to some very ignorant comments from a lot of people. Luckily we have several people aspiring to be the next Captain Obvious, so facts from the video were quickly pointed out. With some of the comments made, you’d start to think people here couldn’t imagine Kara able to bench 95lbs in any other way, shape, or form.
This of course harkens back to the one thread about the bodybuilder benching 225 for, what, 47 reps? That, too, was just a performance. Those that have actually benched something for an appreciable number of reps had a good idea of what that would translate to the way they lift. I think it’s just a basic misunderstanding on a lot of people’s parts on how different ways of lifting can relate to each other.
rick, i think what is going on here is more than just the usual complaining by the masses about “roids” or etc. when they see somebody extraordinary(Kara for example) doing something they cant do.
i think that the gear issue in PL has reached a critical mass, and people just do not want to deal with it anymore. it has gotten to the point that people know how ridiculous it is, and refuse to acknowledge that these people are as strong as the numbers they put up up in gear.
the general lifting community are just sick of it. if it makes you or anyone else upset that when somebody posts a video or something of somebody hitting numbers in a jacked up shirt or 4 ply squat suit 3/4 to parallel, that LOTS of people say “big deal” or “not impressed”, GET USED TO IT. either do something to change the sport, or keep it even more underground and keep the vids and proclamations off the more diverse boards such as this.
only a few more tolerant individuals, and those who are actually in the sport take this shit seriously anymore. i understand that extreme gear is a feature of the top level of this sport, but i just think it is silly for anyone to expect acceptance of this crap by people not “sold” on it.
it is like asking the average american to take world cup soccer seriously. " hey, this is the worlds best sport damnit!!! WHY dont you like it? it is BETTER than football i tell you!!!" but the average guy on the street here could care less, they do not like soccer. see the point i am making?
the hardcore PL and PL fans are running around and banging there heads against a wall, and throwing themselves on the ground and having a tantrum because most people (yes MOST) in the lifting community think the gear is out of hand.
it is funny actually. [/quote]
What does gear have to do with this training video?
Bear