[quote]Professor X wrote:
[quote]Spidey22 wrote:
- Aren’t we talking about Ryan and Bauber? Fine, you are also now in this category, of wanting a very large and very lean physique. Nice to have you aboard.
[/quote]
I wasn’t aware that was in question.
[quote]
2. Ryan wasn’t giving his opinion.[/quote]
He was. That is why he said that Bauber gained too much fat.
[quote]
The person Ryan referred to in previous posts who is roughly the same size as Bauber, who is also cutting but pretty damn lean already, gained without having to put on as near as much fat.[/quote]
Who??? It isn’t and never has been about carrying some specific amount of body fat…/.or gaining some amount of body fat.
It is about the approach…so until we talk to this guy you speak of, all of this is in the air.
[quote]
There are people who’ve gotten to that size, without having to get that sloppy.[/quote]
I don’t see Bauber as “sloppy”. If I saw him in the gym I would be very impressed with what he built. It matters little what you think of how fat someone got…and no one is saying that getting “sloppy” is necessary for growth. That is up to the GENETICS OF THE INDIVIDUAL.
[quote]
Ryan was just giving his opinion,[/quote]
You just said he didn’t give an opinion.
[quote]
- LOL yeah. We are all discussing a relation between size AND leanness. Ryan made a comment addressing Bauber’s bodyfat, correct? He’s lean, he should be able to do so in your eyes, considering one can’t really seem to have an opinion on a subject unless they personally have experienced it. [/quote]
Then how can he claim he gained too much fat to reach that size?
You are now saying ryan was making a statement that Bauber is too fat…to be Ryan’s size?
Wow…some of you will do anything to defend the “posse”.
He didn’t give an opinion…but he did.[/quote]
Whoops, accidentally put ‘wasn’t’ instead of was in “Ryan wasn’t giving his opinion”. Typing from my phones so sorry for errors in theses posts. So disregard that random mistype lol.
Anywho… So because we don’t name specific names, we can’t use them as examples? You’ve claimed multiple times that guys at your gym’s development surpass those who have pretty solid physiques, but don’t name names? You said you’re related to a pro athlete, but unless we talk to him are we to assume you are lying? C’mon dude…
So Ryan thinks Bauber got sloppy. Seriously who cares? Like this is a website about physique development? Is everyone suppose to post pics and no matter what everyone’s just suppose to say “great job, you’re doing perfect”? Ryan just said he felt Bauber got a little sloppy, and that he probably didn’t need to get put on that much BF to achieve the size he will be in contest shape. I don’t think 60+ lbs from contest shape is ‘optimal’ either if the goal is too compete. Don’t think that’s all too insulting, and it seems you’re getting more upset about this then Bauber would haha.
And you say you’d be impressed with what Bauber has built if you see him in the gym, yet say immediately after say it matters little of how fat I think someone’s gotten. If it matters little what I think about someone’s physique, why in the hell would you even mention what you think of it? We may have differing opinions, but apparently neither really matter. So why bring it up?
And WTF is this ‘posse’? Who is it? What’s the group name? Please tell me. I’m just stating my opinion on a subject. But regardless, yeah, considering once again we are discussing being BIG AND LEAN, with LEAN being half that equation, how can Ryan not say he may have strayed too far from one half of the goal? Bauber is competing. He’s not just getting big for the sake of being big. It’s inevitable for people commenting to talk about leanness in reference to size and vice versa, because in the BIGGER, stronger, LEANER forum, they are all apart of the goal. I thought you gathered that I think it’s dumb to even say certain people can’t comment on this aspect while others can’t, but apparently you really believe that to be a good idea. LOL. I think it’s silly that you wouldn’t be able to comment on someone’s leanness because you’ve never hit an arbitrary number on BF reading, because I feel you have enough experience to make said comment. So it’s just as stupid to say Ryan can’t comment on anything remotely referencing someone’s size because he hasn’t hit an arbitrary number on scale.