[quote]fr0gger666 wrote:
[quote]BrickHead wrote:
I can see why in one’s first, serious bulk as a youngster, they MIGHT experiment and benefit from what I’d call an “all out bulk” in which they gain an appreciable amount of bodyfat with their first noob 20 to 25 pound gain. However, what I think X really doesn’t seem to acknowledge is that naturals can only gain about 40 to 50 pounds of muscle over a lifting journey. People can say all the bad things about Casey Butt, AA, and LM all they want, but the guys have done due diligence and have studied nutrition, training, and the stats of lifters since the 1960’s as much as anyone can and provided us with good information. And besides that, anyone following natural bodybuilding for some time will see the same weight trends over and over and over!
[/quote]
40-50 pounds of muscle over a lifting journey for a natural? so everyone above… like 200 is putting on fat, if they are natural? maybe they should quit bodybuilding because they will never gain more muscle
[quote]BrickHead wrote:
Even if one puts up bigger numbers because of fat mass, it doesn’t mean there is some definite increase in muscle mass to go with that “fat strength”. [/quote]
yeah, powerlifters putting up big numbers are just fat… its not muscle, or anything… fat gives you insane bench/squat/and deadlift numbers
and where did X advocate putting on fat? i must’ve missed that one
strong straw man arguments in this thread
[quote]paulieserafini wrote:
[quote]BrickHead wrote:
First year: 25 pounds
Second year: half of above (12 or 13 pounds)
Third year: half of above (6 or so pounds)
Fourth year and beyond: painfully slow, almost negligible gains over time
[/quote]
What? Why do you have to kill my dreams man I’m in year five and not happy with my size.[/quote]
just stop bro you’ll only get fatter post year 5
[/quote]
Oh yes, me recognizing that fat adds leverage to lifts, dismissed all the muscle mass that guys like Andy Bolton and Donnie Thompson are carrying. I mean, I’m really dumb enough to think that the fat’s doing all that work deadlifting and squatting 1000+.
Yes, I’m really that infantile! Thanks.
Oh, thanks for telling me I haven’t hung around and met some bigass powerlifters and strongmen, most of whom have more muscle than I.