[quote]Travacolypse wrote:
Professor X wrote:
Travacolypse wrote:
And yes, it does smell like x-men. It almost has to, but not to this degree. I thought they were taking it in another direction, and I vastly preferred living with that illusion.
What other direction is there? X-Men has had decades to refine their own story lines and plots and have pretty much attacked every possible angle of how society would treat mutants.
I think it is a little strange for anyone to think they will come up with something completely original at this point that has never been touched on before in comics, tv or any other form of media.
I like Heroes for what it is…but I don’t expect them to break any new ground aside from simply not using costumes.
Good question. It’s hard to put into specifics, but the first season didn’t feel like I was watching live-action x-men. With some of the recent level 5 villains, it feels more like they’re just pulling these guys straight from the pages of a comic book instead of putting their own spin on things.
Like I said, there’s a pyro-clone, banshee-clone, and magneto-clone (I mean, okay, he’s german and not polish, but that’s close enough for government work).
I guess the bottom line is that I accept and expect some carryover, but I’d like the number of straight deja-vu moments kept to a minimum.
Still, to reiterate a post I made awhile back, it’s a lot better than everything else on tv, so the bottom would Really have to drop out before I stop watching.[/quote]
I can understand that. But I also don’t see how they could really do this that differently without making the characters very boring. X-Men has done this backwards and forwards for half a century. I don’t think there is any possible “power” they haven’t covered in detail.
The only thing they have done with Heroes is make the Rogue clones (Peter and Sylar) more powerful than all the others where as Rogue would eventually lose most of the powers she absorbed.
I think keeping them out of costumes is a good idea…and I agree, it may be one of the better shows on tv right now.
I just don’t expect anything ground breaking from it.
I will say this, Hiro’s development is moving along way too slowly (considering what they foreshadowed before).