[quote]ChuckyT wrote:
Shortest Straw wrote:
What I was getting at was POWERLIFTERS, Do practice Powercleans and will often teach football players (in the gym technique).
THe difference. Well a powerlifters only focus is to get the weight up. Ie Usually extra wide stance, overleaning back, really wide grip on bar.
for cleans, basically a slowcatch and squat it up.
For football you stance should mimic the stance of your position.
You should be focused on EXPLOSION, not just moving the weight. Your back should mimic how you set your stance. Ie a linebackers shouldbe straigher than an O lineman.
this especially transalates to powercleans there is a big difference in a well timed exploaded, quick catch, powerclean and how it transalates to the field. Than a jumping reverse curl, thats squated up.
Would the hundreds of authors, coaches, lifters, and athletes that have posted why that is a bad idea dissuade you from this line of thought? I’ll rehash why this is a general consensus no-no:
There will be ZERO transferrence of motor skill from a lifting activity to the field (squatting in your football stance with a barbell on your back and getting into your stance and making a tackle are so far removed from one another that they just won’t help one another). By altering the form, you will sacrifice working on the muscles or groups that you might have been targeting, and neccessarily have to reduce the load… the worst of both worlds!
If someone does a squatting reverse curl, call it that. A clean is a clean. Properly taught, by its very nature it’s explosive. You can no more clean very slowly than you can jump very slowly.
[/quote]
I agree with the second post here. Weightlifting for any sport is general, meaning that mimicing your “football stance” while you squat is not going to translate.
With all the drills on the field being done, practicing stance, getting out of the stance, etc etc etc (the list goes on), no need to overthink things in the weight room and complicate/risk form. Squat and it’s variations done to at least parallel should suffice fine; As far as the clean goes, I feel as long as you’re getting the speed out of the movement and triple-extension achieved, then the lift is going to benefit that athlete. That is why the clean/powerclean are very much emphasized my most if not all major college and high school football programs.
Im not a fan when people say "you’re never going to do this movement in football, so why do it? " or something around these lines, you get the picture… Save the specificity for on the field!
Hope that helped.