You may be right about durability, time will tell on that. The 3.5L is one of the most proven engines ever made, so I’m not too worried about long term durability. Same with the transmission, which I think is outstanding in the Avalon when paired with the V6. If I did more city driving I would have definitely considered a hybrid and CVT, but most of my miles are highway and rural roads with few stops.
32mpg is still pretty efficient. Having fun with the throttle bumps me down to about 28 mpg on my commute, which is still pretty decent. Overall it is still a very efficient and economical vehicle compared to an SUV, sports car or a more luxurious sedan.
Most importantly, I can use the Avalon’s acceleration and speed to further aggravate inconsiderate drivers from Massachusetts who want to tailgate me. After making them drive under the speed limit for miles and miles and miles, I can just hit the gas pedal when an opportunity to pass me arises. Unless they have a sports car, chances are the Avalon is quite a bit faster. Then, when we’re back to winding mountain roads with no opportunities to pass, I’ll go back down to 5 mph under the speed limit, leave my blinker on for no reason and continue frustrating the out-of-state jerks who wanted to ride my ass when I was doing 10 over the speed limit. You can’t put a price on that.
Even for the most practical people, car purchases still have an emotional component that can explain any purchase made by anyone. Even my company’s CFO, who collects crappy old Pontiacs when he could afford just about any normal car he wants. Or my wealthy uncle, who likes to go out in public with no evidence of his wealth.
I’ve put 7k miles on the Avalon in a little over two months. That included multiple road trips in addition to my normal driving. It’s nice to drive something really comfortable that handles nice, has lots of power and doesn’t cost a lot to keep on the road. I enjoy my time spent in the car, as opposed to being something I just have to put up with to get from point A to point B.
In summary, going fast is fun.
Edit: Saving money is also fun, and the Corolla is a great car for getting the job done and being nimble and zippy around town. So is the Civic, which I’ve never owned but have driven a few times as rentals.