[quote]Dr.PowerClean wrote:
DrSKeptix,
The picture may not show this well, but there is bilateral atrophy, but by palpation there is some functional muscle on the right side, not the left. NCV was only done on the left, showing complete denervation. Did they do the NCV above the knee-you know, I dont remember. I believe they did, just above.
I came across one isolated case of bilateral medial gastoc atrophy, with tibial nerve entrapment on both sides. I actually spoke to the neurologist, one M.K. Hagy, who reported the case in a journal. I sent him my pictures and he did not believe it was a tibial nerve problem but most likely spinal trauma in my case.
But yes, despite a grand total of 17 docs and five PTs, it is still amazing that I am not 100% sure what the hell denervated my medial gastocs. And a big part of this is because they STILL did not do sufficient tests.
Many people who know me well have told me that at the time of the accident, I was in excellent physcial shape (I call it Men’s Health shape, you know, machine work and running). Many doctors took one look at me and automatically assumed there was nothing wrong with me. Yet I had no previous history of lawsuits, workers comp, or any of the red flags that worry doctors that a patient is presenting false or exagerrated symptoms.
I’ve lost a lot of faith in my own profession over how this was handled, even though I try to keep it in perspective, it is, after all, only half my calves. And my diskectomy relieved me of the radiculopathy that was horrendous, really brutal pain. The radiculopathy is really why I never doubted the atrophy was spinal related. Doc
BTW-you really got me rethinking…the accident was a lady smashing into my SUV from behind at 60mph. I smashed into the dash, including my knees. Everyone was so worried about my concussion (I had a brief coma), and my back, that I know nobody looked at my knees. Hmmmm… I never considered I could have had BOTH spinal trauma with radicular pains, with a separate case of bilateral tibial nerve damage from my knees slamming into the bottom of the dash. Man, what a remarkable idea…bravo, Dr. Skeptix.
Doc[/quote]
“When one eliminates the impossible, what is left is the probable.”
–Sherlock Homes?
Of course, bilaterality implicates spinal level disease or stenosis. But really, you really are quite a specimen there, and persistent denervation and atrophy selectively in medial gastroc really points to peripheral nerve damage. (Recovery at the peroneal nerves and not at the tibial nerves may suggest, as you point out, spinal disease restricted to L5-S1–bilaterally! But, gee, you’d think that would be obvious on MRIs. Have I seen spinal disease with only isolated medial gastroc weakness? No, but then I am only an amateur neurologist.)
Anyhow, I would vote with Bushy for an exam and repeat directed NCVs–with the aim of distinguishing spinal from lower motor neuron disease. What could it hurt? (Ooops!) But what if it could be fixed?
[By the way…high foot arches or low?]