Does Training Need to Suck for the Best Results?

Are you saying though for you that the harder training gets (and I mean hard) you like it more rather than less? I am talking about the actually training itself, not how you feel after, not any sense of accomplishment after but in the moment when you trying not to puke.

1 Like

Yeah kind of. I enjoy harder sessions MORE than easier sessions, but I enjoy easier sessions than none at all.
For me it’s just mindset though, which has definitely changed over the years.

I wonder if because I’m not training for a specific event, but rather to position myself to be more effective at work (which I can notice the carry over in many situations) if that makes a difference compared to someone training for a competition?

Maybe because I ā€˜compete’ on a weekly basis my training remains enjoyable

2 Likes

A good example is that I absolutely used to hate running. And now when I’m running a 600m or a mile time trial or whatever I LOVE the feeling of pushing myself to the limit and feeling my lungs burst in the moment. And it’s almost a let down when it’s over and you catch your breath.
Not because I love pain but because feeling yourself at 100% is such a rare and wonderful thing and I won’t be able to do it forever

2 Likes

This is a nice way to think about it and a great positive mindset to have. Usually when I am running an 800m at full pace I am not able to think at all, I am just trying to breath and keep going.

1 Like

I can’t speak for what it takes to get results when you’re at the level of someone like @T3hPwnisher or @ChongLordUno or any of the other strong af guys, but I don’t think training has to suck to reach a level that for most would be a lifetime goal, like a 405-440 lbs squat, a 315 bench, an 185 lbs ohp ect (assuming you’re not too light)

Sometimes I feel like training sucking has way more to do with people looking to wear pain as a budge of honor. Not wanna sound judgemental though, train as you like and view it as you want, not my place to tell you what to do

Also views like ā€œdo not program hopā€ do not help either. Especially as a newer lifter, though you shouldn’t be changing routines more often than underwear, I feel like if you hate your plan you should try something different. After all, progress also comes from training hard, especially in an earlier stage, so even if you decide to hop around a bit it’s not like your progress will be lost

2 Likes

If progress comes from training hard, does doing training that is hard enough to suck give more progress ?

1 Like

If you’re at an elite level and competing, yeah it probably does have to suck. Not just the lifting part, but everything else - being constantly on top of food intake, sleep, mood, etc.

For the average person to get to a point to be considered ā€œstrongā€ by most people, I think it can be done pretty painlessly. If you’re not competing and it’s not your livelihood, I don’t see the point of torturing yourself in the gym if you don’t enjoy it.

3 Likes

Thank you! I agree - good strength programming can be simultaneously effective and not grueling/sucky.

Side bar - I define ā€œsuckyā€ as both emotionally/mentally and physically difficult, with the emotional component carrying greater ā€œsuckā€ weight.

Yep, I get the same pre-workout jitters before a particularly intense session that also has high volume. I wouldn’t describe that as ā€œsuckyā€ though, not in the sense of a marathon calisthenics/ barbells/ and running mixed session can be.

1 Like

So here is an interesting question for those that enjoy training, enjoy the feeling of suffering and pain, and in turn, enjoy overcoming challenges.

Are you really doing the latter if you are doing the former?

Again, my perspective is that of a hedonist rather than a masochist. I enjoy feelings of pleasure rather than pain. Eating nachos, for me, is joy. I love the feeling of eating nachos. Were I to eat a lot of nachos, in no way would I claim to have overcome a challenge or bettered myself in anyway. I find betterment to be a process of asceticism: denial of the self of pleasure and exposure of the self to discomfort for the sake of growth.

If you enjoy training, wouldn’t self-improvement necessitate the DENIAL of training?

I will admit, these thoughts came to me at 0600 this morning in the middle of a hellish front squat based conditioning workout where I had said ā€œf**k meā€ about a dozen times…man I want nachos.

4 Likes

#humblebrag :joy:

1 Like

To answer the questiinL IDK if training necessarily requires going ā€œto a dark placeā€ to see results. I managed to hit a 3x bodyweight deadlift doing everything wrong and never going to a dark place like @T3hPwnisher or @ChongLordUno and I’ve heard many coaches advocating for sub-max effort when lifting. For ā€œbest resultsā€ I’m really not sure

On a (related) tangent
I’d say I ā€œenjoyā€ training, not because it feels good but because it keeps me present (if only for an hour) and I feel worse not doing it.

I’ve never regretted completing a session, but have regretted skipping/procrastinating. Also, I’m novice enough to still think heavy squats are ā€œfunā€. heavy 10x3 or 10x5 are my new favourite

With that said, I feel kind of in a funk lately, not really pushing to a dark place and just tired. My dream would be to be able to be a couch potato for a bit and not suffer consequences, but it doesn’t really work like that…

You frequently describe what many would consider to be depression-like symptoms.

2 Likes

No, because training isn’t, to me, something that needs to be ā€œovercomeā€. I like training, and it’s self-improvement through make me stronger, faster and healthier.

So do I, training is simply a pain that I enjoy. Taxes and housework, on the other hand…

Without expanding this topic beyond its borders, there are some things where this need not apply. Such as training. Denying myself of training doesn’t really ā€œimproveā€ me. It may for a short time in the form of healing or learning patience, but there are very quick diminishing returns through the loss of health.

Same. Still haven’t tried your bacon nachos yet.

1 Like

In such a case, I imagine you weren’t among those I was addressing. I saw a few folks mentioning that they enjoyed the feeling of overcoming. It sounds more that you’re seeing training as practice, which is absolutely a great approach.

And man, I had an opportunity for some more bacon nachos the other day. Had to avoid it, haha.

1 Like

This dude!

Okay, now I must dive deep into my thoughts. If I enjoyed it, did I overcome a challenge? I don’t alway succeed. I failed today on the BB military press. Failing does suck. Sometimes the challenge is the rep range. 100 100# deadball over the shoulders being the challenge. It hurts, sweat is dripping, HR is 150 plus. I’m suffering, but, I’m still enjoying it. Reverse hacks, the weight is at 600+, The challenge is 5x5x5. I’ll of course see how many more I can do. If I accomplish it and don’t break, then I enjoyed the challenge. I will be in a world of hurt, but I enjoyed it. I enjoyed every hard rep. The feeling of the burn in my legs, etc. I know at that weight if I fuck up, I’m fucked. The first time I pulled 405 off the floor, I felt like my insides were going to come out, I felt every muscle screaming, but I still enjoyed it and the feeling of accomplishment.

However, today on my DB curl presses. I was going to 8. I was cussing out loud as my shoulders were burning and I didn’t think I would get to 8 on the last 2 sets, but I pushed through. Maybe the challenge wasn’t enough since I got it. But I’m also at a place where I know that I have to reel myself in check. I will do something until I break. People who have known me for a while always tell me I need to back off. I’m too 0-100. And I enjoy pain from lifting. Edit: I don’t enjoy all pain. There is a chick that gives me deep tissue and that shit hurts and I don’t enjoy it at all.

I just struggle to see where the overcoming is in doing something you enjoy doing. Whenever I observe someone doing something they enjoy, I don’t think ā€œthere is someone overcoming somethingā€.

1 Like

When I used to tournament fight, I didn’t always win. and even when I did win, I took damage in the process. I enjoyed it and kept signing up for more.

When I do sled pulls, my HR is 150-160ish, I’m blacking out while doing it. I have to drop to the ground after each trip and lay there until I recover. I enjoy that. I look forward to it.

1 Like

Yup. I don’t understand it, haha.

3 Likes

Applies to the concept of ā€œthere is no courage without fearā€. I spent a lot of time doing things I was afraid of, and I initially envied people who didn’t seem to be afraid at all until I realized there was nothing special about doing something you weren’t afraid of.

3 Likes

EXACTLY! That’s what I’m trying to get at. These all sound like very hard things…but if they’re being enjoyed, it’s missing out on one of the key elements of overcoming.

3 Likes