[quote]cgeezy wrote:
Uber N3wb wrote:
again, pulling your shoulder blades back will make your reach shorter, and tighten your upper back up which will also make your reach shorter. This inst the form for someone interested in useing the most weight possible.
Also, again with the shoulder blades over the bar, this would put your shoulders way over the bar and wouldnt be good for your leverage at all.
If sounds like your trying to tell him how to deadlift as if he was trying to clean the weight.
Well the technique I described is in line with many strength coaches suggestions and to me it makes the most anatomical sense.
I just finished reading this article as well: http://stronglifts.com/why-your-shoulder-blades-must-over-the-bar-on-deadlifts/
Mark Rippetoe contributed to that piece and he says similar things in “Starting Strength.”
I didn’t suggest the technique for the sole purpose to move as much weight as possible (but isn’t that pretty much the point for most people? Not even just powerlifters) but to make sure there isn’t undue stress in the wrong places.
With your scapulae over the bar, you pull the barbell in the straighest line which is also the most efficient. Correct me if I’m wrong but when you’re moving big weights (400+ lbs is big!) you need to stay as tight as possible. It’s the irradiation principle capitalized by Pavel Tsatsouline.
Clearly there is more than one way to skin the cat, but to me, the points I made seem like good advice.[/quote]
I would say your way would be safer, I just dont think it would be stronger. Then again theres no way I could keep my shoulder blades back if I was close to my max on deadlifts so I guess I am biased.
EDIT: im not completley sure about pulling the bar in a straight line being more beneficial, all I have read on the subject is dave tats stuff about leverage.
I personally dont try to pull it back, or in a straight line, I just pull it and Im sure it wouldnt make that much difference either way. I just said it because I read it and it made sense to me.