[quote]jtrinsey wrote:
(a) Why are you so obsessed with this guy?[/quote]
I didn’t mean for this thread to be about a specific individual, more of a concept, and the individual provided an easy example.
quote I think the “you can tell a lot about somebody by how they roll” bit is tough to say. One guy at one gym I train at is a low-level pro MMA guy and has some submission grappling wins. He’s extremely explosive in his grappling and very strong. I’ve only been training BJJ for about a month, so needless to say we are on two different levels. When we roll, he doesn’t show me any mercy. In the beginning, it was to the point where I couldn’t even mount a coherent defense before he overwhelmed me and choked me out in 5 seconds. If you looked at the way that guy treated me (and some other new guys) when we roll, you would call him an asshole and say it wasn’t helping anybody.
But the thing is, after a couple weeks of that, I’ve started to adjust. I’m getting used to the speed and violence that he attacks with. Often, I still fuck up some technique and get tapped in 5 seconds. But, every now and then, I see what he’s going for and am able to defend. A couple times recently I have even been able to improve position or attempt some offense before getting submitted. After class, he’ll tell me what I messed up or what I need to work on to not get swept a certain way or not give up a certain choke.
So, just based on watching that guy roll, you might call him an asshole, but the bottom line is that I’m getting so much better from rolling with him. When I roll with some other guys, shit seems to be in slow motion because I’ve trained at such a violent pace with him. [/quote]
What’d you think he’s getting out of rolling hard with you? Maybe I’m just not seeing it, but what’s the benefit in constantly dominating someone you know you’re better than?
I occasionally go to a gym that has a heavy weight low level pro MMA guy, and unless he’s gearing up for a fight, or trying to break an asshole, he doesn’t train ground work like that.
[quote]I think it also depends on the environment of your gym. As a student, I think it’s good to roll with lots of different guys and, if possible, in more than one gym. One gym that I train at is a much more relaxed atmosphere and very technique focused. The other is much more violent in it’s approach and it is harder to try new techniques sometimes because you are just worried about not getting crushed. [quote]
I do the same thing, but I rarely roll at the latter.
Maybe I need to roll with violent guys more, this thread is making me wonder if I’m just being a pussy about it. I’ve been through my share of breaks and sprains though and the cost benefit ratio a doesn’t seem to be in the favor of it. Another popped ribbed doesn’t seem worth proving I can roll hard. I’m thinking I’m not seeing something important that you are. Sometimes I just want to roll and be smashed, so I roll with a violent guy, but I don’t see why it would ever be needed more than for competitions and once in a while to be rooted.