Box Squat to Free Squat Carryover?

[quote]tedro wrote:

I don’t think anybody at Westside or Elitefts advocates rocking, yes it is nearly impossible to completely eliminate, but it should be minimized. By rocking you maintain and even build momentum. One of the biggest benefits of teh box squat is the complete separation between the concentric and eccentric phase, which teaches you to explode out of the hole.
[/quote]

Here are three videos, you can decide for yourself. The first one is called Big Mike from Elite Fitness box squatting (I assume since EFS is in the title they support his form).

The second is Louie I believe squatting, less of a rock

And I found another that is EFS made with a safety squat bar with a lot of rock

[quote]Hanley wrote:
For the guys out there that have used a box, what sort of carryover have you seen to your normal squat? Max to max like…

The box I’ve been using is slighty below parrallel so it should be a decent enough indicator right? (this is the height Box Squat 120kg x5 - YouTube )

I did 190kg raw off the slightly below parrallel box today, just a belt. So I’m tryna get a sense of where my actual squat should be (assuming I was to spend a few weeks training it to become fully comfortable with it again).

Thanks guys![/quote]

hard to say, first off, those looked like regular squats, just a box underneath you. if you listen to some of the hardcore multi-ply fed guys, they will tell you that a box squat has a very different path than a regular squat, and if you ignore the box, look very different from a regular back squat.

[quote]tedro wrote:
Tim Henriques wrote:
From your video I do think you need to push your hips back more and keep your shins vertical. Personally I don’t think you rocked too much, as I recall (I could be wrong) Louie and Dave atually recommended rocking on the box to intentionally break the stretch reflex. Also after doing a search of Elite Fitness people box squatting on youtube I saw one of Big Mike rocking a whole bunch (much more than you) and Louie rocking a little bit. I used to rock some when I did them, so I don’t think you need to be motionless on the box, that is my opinion. Definitely don’t plop on the box as that can hurt your lower back.

I don’t think anybody at Westside or Elitefts advocates rocking, yes it is nearly impossible to completely eliminate, but it should be minimized. By rocking you maintain and even build momentum. One of the biggest benefits of teh box squat is the complete separation between the concentric and eccentric phase, which teaches you to explode out of the hole.

I know there are some methods that teach you to rock off of the box. Bigger, faster, stronger, a common high school training program teaches a high box squat with a forward rocking motion. I am not a big fan of theirs.
[/quote]

Just out of interest, has this stuff worked for you personally? Have you seen good increases in your box squat over the last 6/12 months??

[quote]Hanley wrote:
tedro wrote:
Hanley wrote:
Tedro, rip me apart Box Squats PR's - YouTube

First, you are not pausing at all. One of the major benefits of the box squat is that it kills your momentum and diminishes the stretch reflex, teaching you to explode out of the hole. You don’t need to pause for long, but just a split second goes a long ways.

Second, it looks like you are initiating the movement by bending your knees. Your hips should be the first thing to move on the descent. This will help you sit back further, and force you to use more of your glutes and hamstrings. You will also be less likely to rock backwards upon hitting the box. At first I thought this may just be due to fatigue, but then I watched some of your free squat videos and noticed that you tend to bend your hips and knees at the same time.

Third, you are still rocking quite a bit. On your way back up, your first movement is forward. The goal of a squat is to move the weight up, and to do this you need to force the bar back. You don’t rock forward in your free squat, so why would you rock forward off of the box? You are putting yourself into a different groove by doing this, and this could lead to falling forward in your free squat. It also diminishes the carryover since the movement is slightly different.

Part of the reason you rock forward is simply because you are lifting at or near your max weights. It is very unlikely that you will be able to completely get rid of the forward rocking motion. Make sure, however, when the weights are lighter that you don’t rock at all. As the weights get heavier, make sure to push back against the bar as you initiate the concentric portion of the lift. Again, you probably won’t be able to eliminate the forward rocking, but you should be able to reduce it quite a bit.

To sum up: Sit back, pause, and force that bar back. Then read Dave Tate’s article:

http://www.T-Nation.com/readArticle.do?id=459391

Wow. I didn’t mean literally tear me apart :stuck_out_tongue:

  1. I thought I was pausing for long enough… Maybe not! I was looking at this vid of Chuck V (and alos his XXX vid) and he doesn’t seem to pause for that long either? chuck vogelpohl the legend - YouTube

  2. I don’t know how much value there is to sitting wayyyyy back as a raw/single ply lifter. There just isn’t as much support there to sit back into as the multi ply guys have. Also, it’s been my exp. that with a relatively close/medium stance, sitting back too much creates either too much foward lean, or a bar that’s gonna pull you backwards arse over tit because your COG is fucked up!! Hence the hip/knee break at the same time. I was trying to keep the box squat form at least similar to how I’d do it in gear or raw like…

  3. On moving the bar back, if you look at where it is relative to my feet when I’m on the box, it’s exactly over or a little bit behind them, surely trying to move the bar back would result in me falling backwards?? Maybe it’s a result of me ending up in a bad position on the box, perhaps with more of a forward lean when I touch down this problem would be alleviated?

I’m not touching box squats other than on DE day for the next 5 or 6 weeks so hopefully it’ll give me a chance to play around and try to implement your suggetions. Nice one![/quote]

that is a good question, not sure the box squat technique used by the multiply feds is going to give much carryover to a single ply IPF lifter.

even if you do not lift APF, some wide higher box squats can still have value in training. i have been doing mostly heavy deep raw front squats and high rep deep olympic style back squats, but just yesterday i worked up to 500x3 RAW off a “high” box squat with a stupid-wide stance. reasoning was it gave me some time under a decently loaded barbell and worked my hips quite a bit, and gave my low back and quads a much needed break.

[quote]tedro wrote:
Tim Henriques wrote:
From your video I do think you need to push your hips back more and keep your shins vertical. Personally I don’t think you rocked too much, as I recall (I could be wrong) Louie and Dave atually recommended rocking on the box to intentionally break the stretch reflex. Also after doing a search of Elite Fitness people box squatting on youtube I saw one of Big Mike rocking a whole bunch (much more than you) and Louie rocking a little bit. I used to rock some when I did them, so I don’t think you need to be motionless on the box, that is my opinion. Definitely don’t plop on the box as that can hurt your lower back.

I don’t think anybody at Westside or Elitefts advocates rocking, yes it is nearly impossible to completely eliminate, but it should be minimized. By rocking you maintain and even build momentum. One of the biggest benefits of teh box squat is the complete separation between the concentric and eccentric phase, which teaches you to explode out of the hole.

I know there are some methods that teach you to rock off of the box. Bigger, faster, stronger, a common high school training program teaches a high box squat with a forward rocking motion. I am not a big fan of theirs.
[/quote]

I think BFS sucks but my plifting coach keps trying to push iit on me. I just can’t see hte point of squatting on a box THAT DAMN HIGHER. Is it just me or does it seem riciculous to other people too?

[quote]heavythrower wrote:

that is a good question, not sure the box squat technique used by the multiply feds is going to give much carryover to a single ply IPF lifter.

even if you do not lift APF, some wide higher box squats can still have value in training. i have been doing mostly heavy deep raw front squats and high rep deep olympic style back squats, but just yesterday i worked up to 500x3 RAW off a “high” box squat with a stupid-wide stance. reasoning was it gave me some time under a decently loaded barbell and worked my hips quite a bit, and gave my low back and quads a much needed break. [/quote]

Yeah you see that’s why I’m sorta sitting on the fence as to how I’m doing them. I was trying to sit back enough, but not so much as to get miles away from my normal squat groove. I know you’ve been around alot of great lifters, have they all been multi ply or have you seen some single ply guys train?

As a point of reference, this is my “normal” squat:
Squat 230kg x1 - YouTube (last workout before last meet, opener in single ply gear)
Squat 170x5 - YouTube (raw near max work)

[quote]zephead4747 wrote:
tedro wrote:
Tim Henriques wrote:
From your video I do think you need to push your hips back more and keep your shins vertical. Personally I don’t think you rocked too much, as I recall (I could be wrong) Louie and Dave atually recommended rocking on the box to intentionally break the stretch reflex. Also after doing a search of Elite Fitness people box squatting on youtube I saw one of Big Mike rocking a whole bunch (much more than you) and Louie rocking a little bit. I used to rock some when I did them, so I don’t think you need to be motionless on the box, that is my opinion. Definitely don’t plop on the box as that can hurt your lower back.

I don’t think anybody at Westside or Elitefts advocates rocking, yes it is nearly impossible to completely eliminate, but it should be minimized. By rocking you maintain and even build momentum. One of the biggest benefits of teh box squat is the complete separation between the concentric and eccentric phase, which teaches you to explode out of the hole.

I know there are some methods that teach you to rock off of the box. Bigger, faster, stronger, a common high school training program teaches a high box squat with a forward rocking motion. I am not a big fan of theirs.

I think BFS sucks but my plifting coach keps trying to push iit on me. I just can’t see hte point of squatting on a box THAT DAMN HIGHER. Is it just me or does it seem riciculous to other people too?[/quote]

My highschool coach used to do that to, only we did everything to a 10RM and instead of sitting on the box(which was a normal dumbell bench) we just kind of touched it and basically did a quartersquat with more weight than we had any business touching except it was a 10RM so its not so bad but twice as lame.

Rocking off the box was causing me some serious scary back problems. I may rock forward a tad because I’m 6’4" and squating off a 10in box but I never rock back when I sit down. I don’t deload because of back problems either, I just pause on the box leaving everything tight(hopefully).

[quote]Tim Henriques wrote:
Here are three videos, you can decide for yourself. The first one is called Big Mike from Elite Fitness box squatting (I assume since EFS is in the title they support his form).

The second is Louie I believe squatting, less of a rock

And I found another that is EFS made with a safety squat bar with a lot of rock

You are comparing squats with bands to a regular box squat, so they are not going to look the exact same.

In your first video he is rocking quite a bit, but look how far back he is sitting. He has to rock forward a bit to get the weight back over his feet and into a powerful position. Our OP is not sitting back near this far, and when he rocks forward his shoulders begin to drop and the weight looks to come to far forward.

The second video looks fine to me, I see only minimal rocking, with a distinct pause.

I am not sure I would say that he is using good form in the third video, but he is also using a safety squat bar so it is a whole different story. His lower back is rounding and his shoulders are rounded forward, but again, a lot of this is due to the bar he is using, so this video doesn’t really give a good comparison.

I think most of the OP’s problems would be solved by sitting back more, I never said the rocking motion would be completely eliminated, but his problem is that his chest begins to cave and he gets the weight to far forward on his feet.

Also, I am nitpicking a bit. Overall, his form is not that bad, but he wanted some advice and we all always have some room to improve. I am under the impression that this is what he is looking for, tips to get better.

[quote]Hanley wrote:
Just out of interest, has this stuff worked for you personally? Have you seen good increases in your box squat over the last 6/12 months??
[/quote]

My box squat used to look similar to yours, but with a narrower stance and a longer pause. My deadlift went up, but my free squat was only about 15-25 lbs more than my box squat.

Now, I box squat two different ways. I frequently still use the narrow stance because of the deadlift carryover, but I sit back more. This narrow stance does sometimes put me into a semi-good morning position where I am forced to come forward a bit. I also already have a large degree of hip flexion at the bottom because of the narrow stance and the sitting back.

I will also box squat with my typical squat stance. This is the only way that I have gotten a good carryover from the box to a free squat. With this stance, the goal is really to drive my shoulders back into the bar to get my hips extended quickly.

[quote]Hanley wrote:
heavythrower wrote:

that is a good question, not sure the box squat technique used by the multiply feds is going to give much carryover to a single ply IPF lifter.

even if you do not lift APF, some wide higher box squats can still have value in training. i have been doing mostly heavy deep raw front squats and high rep deep olympic style back squats, but just yesterday i worked up to 500x3 RAW off a “high” box squat with a stupid-wide stance. reasoning was it gave me some time under a decently loaded barbell and worked my hips quite a bit, and gave my low back and quads a much needed break.

Yeah you see that’s why I’m sorta sitting on the fence as to how I’m doing them. I was trying to sit back enough, but not so much as to get miles away from my normal squat groove. I know you’ve been around alot of great lifters, have they all been multi ply or have you seen some single ply guys train?

As a point of reference, this is my “normal” squat:
Squat 230kg x1 - YouTube (last workout before last meet, opener in single ply gear)
Squat 170x5 - YouTube (raw near max work)[/quote]

yeah, scott cartwright used to come and train at diablo every now and then when i trained there, you can search for his vids on youtube, or check out jack-ass’s(now “guy-no”) thread, or go to team supertraining for some of his vids. i dont see much difference with how he squats down on a box verses the other guys, though i believe he has some sort of single ply record in the total?

now, i trained with a lot of really good highland games athletes, some were olympic level/national level throwers at one time, and they had some very impressive olympic back squats, and power clean numbers. when they box squatted, it looked more like how you did them.

heres a question for all you guys: if i pause too long or rock at all on my box squats, my hip flexor gets torn to shit. anyone else experience this? (box is slightly below parallel)

[quote]masonator wrote:
heres a question for all you guys: if i pause too long or rock at all on my box squats, my hip flexor gets torn to shit. anyone else experience this? (box is slightly below parallel)[/quote]

thats just it, box squats overload the hips and low back if done properly. heavy high rep leg presses tear the shit out of most peoples quads, that is why pro bb use the hell out of them for thigh development.

use a pair of reasonable briefs, or increase the time between sessions until you hip flexors adapt. another option might be to raise the box up a little bit, get used to that, then gradually lower as your hips adapt to the workload.

[quote]heavythrower wrote:
yeah, scott cartwright used to come and train at diablo every now and then when i trained there, you can search for his vids on youtube, or check out jack-ass’s(now “guy-no”) thread, or go to team supertraining for some of his vids. i dont see much difference with how he squats down on a box verses the other guys, though i believe he has some sort of single ply record in the total?

now, i trained with a lot of really good highland games athletes, some were olympic level/national level throwers at one time, and they had some very impressive olympic back squats, and power clean numbers. when they box squatted, it looked more like how you did them. [/quote]

I’m not sure what records Scott holds in the USPF, but he’s a strong mo-fo for sure.

That’s interesting about how the throwers box squat. Maybe I’m just closer to some who box squats for raw gains instead of someone training on a box to get max carryover from multiply gear…?

Here’s a vid from DE squats yesterday. Is this the sorta speed I should be looking for??

[quote]Hanley wrote:
Here’s a vid from DE squats yesterday. Is this the sorta speed I should be looking for??

DE Box Squats - YouTube [/quote]

They look fine. As long as you’re exerting max force, you should be good.

[quote]Hanley wrote:
heavythrower wrote:
yeah, scott cartwright used to come and train at diablo every now and then when i trained there, you can search for his vids on youtube, or check out jack-ass’s(now “guy-no”) thread, or go to team supertraining for some of his vids. i dont see much difference with how he squats down on a box verses the other guys, though i believe he has some sort of single ply record in the total?

now, i trained with a lot of really good highland games athletes, some were olympic level/national level throwers at one time, and they had some very impressive olympic back squats, and power clean numbers. when they box squatted, it looked more like how you did them.

I’m not sure what records Scott holds in the USPF, but he’s a strong mo-fo for sure.

That’s interesting about how the throwers box squat. Maybe I’m just closer to some who box squats for raw gains instead of someone training on a box to get max carryover from multiply gear…?[/quote]

i think you are correct.

Kevin Nee box squating, Kevin Nee 705 box squat - YouTube

maybe it helps

[quote]Scrotus wrote:
Kevin Nee box squating, Kevin Nee 705 box squat - YouTube

maybe it helps[/quote]

Dear fuck- that kid is crazy strong.

[quote]Pinto wrote:
Scrotus wrote:
Kevin Nee box squating, Kevin Nee 705 box squat - YouTube

maybe it helps

Dear fuck- that kid is crazy strong.[/quote]

Yeah. Except his stance is too narrow and his bar position is too high. He needs to sit back more. Also, I think he needs to drive the traps harder and from that video I don’t think he adequately spread the floor therby by not utilizing his posterior chain to it’s full potential…

He must not get on the internet much. Maybe somebody here can set him straight. Turn him into a real lifter.

;>