[quote]ronaldo7 wrote:
TheJonty wrote:
Koing wrote:
So Clean and Jerking 120Kg over head for a female isn’t athletic? Clean and Jerking 100kg for ANYONE, let alone a girl is fairly impressive imo.
I think people are just hung up over her body fat %. What about the big girls but that have a lower bf% then her?
It’s a sport about lifting as much weight over head as possible. The winner lifts the most. This isn’t who has the most ripped body that can lift weights over head as well. As much as the bodybuilder wins on aesthetics and not how much he can Clean and Jerk!
Koing
I think the vast majority of people (myself included) use the term “athletic” to describe people who are relatively lean (or not just a tub of lard) and capable of performing in a variety of sports to some degree, i.e. they can run, jump, have some level of strength, etc etc (this part of the definition probably varies from person to person). So, in that regard, is clean and jerking 120kg athletic? Not necessarily. Strong? Yes. Impressive? Absolutely. But not necessarily athletic. But regardless of whether or not you feel she’s “athletic,” I think we all agree that she’s an athlete, as she trains and competes at a high level in a physical performance-based sport.
On a side note, OF COURSE everyone’s hung up on her BF%. It seems that was the intent of the OP, to post a picture of an athlete with an obviously high BF% and stir some shit up.
You don’t think clean and jerking is athletic? LOL…how many times have you clean and jerked if I may ask and what was your max?
[/quote]
sigh
While clean and jerking requires a number of athletic (for lack of a better word) attributes such as flexibility and explosive strength among others, no, I don’t think the singular act of being able to perform a technically correct clean and jerk makes you “athletic,” insofar as most people seem to define the word. Do most people who train the classic o-lifts hard look athletic? Of course, generally with the exception of the superheavies. But really, I find the term “athletic” to be far too open for interpretation, and in my mind, it means dick. I prefer to class people as athletes or not, a definition which I’ve already gone into detail on earlier in this thread.
And it really shouldn’t matter, but as far as whether or not I’ve clean and jerked: Forums - T Nation - The World's Trusted Community for Elite Fitness
There you go. Since then I’ve hit a 145kg clean and jerk in training and a 143 in competition, progress has been pretty stagnant as of late, but I’m hoping to hit some PRs within the next few weeks/month or two.