[quote]jit07 wrote:
Spry wrote:
I wish you all the best, Jchavezj, in your challenge.
jit07, should we punish a lion for killing another animal and eating it? What should the punishment be? Death?
I put to you, why is it wrong to eat another animal?
I think you missed my point. Eating other animals is right.
I am not a big beliver in absolutes like Right and Wrong.
Things which are right to me are wrong to other people. I have not found a universial definition of right and wrong which makes any sense.
My current theory is:
Right = Good for me or my loved ones.
Wrong = Bad for me or my loved ones.
Try it out. Eating animals gets a tick in the Right box.
About the lion, obviously the lion has no other choice but to kill and eat other animals- it’s necessary for his survival.
It’s a personal decision on how someone decides to eat. Many choose to be vegetarians based on their personal beliefs pertaining to health and ethics.
Humans don’t absolutely have to eat meat for survival if other food sources are available. You said it was “morally right” to eat meat as if it’s your duty to god to eat it. Like I said earlier, what someone chooses to eat is a personal choice.
I don’t think it’s right to kill an other animal if it isn’t necessary. Which in my case and many others it isn’t. Is a human life more important than say a dog’s life? A dog’s life more important than a squirrel’s? I can’t answer that, I’m not so sure myself. As humans we identify with other humans and therefor value our lives and other humans lives above other creature’s lives. Here’s an example; A cute little puppy gets run over by a truck and is killed. Everyone feels sad and terrible. However, a pig is slaughtered and served for Christmas dinner and everyone digs in not thinking about the pig who lost it’s life so that everyone could eat. Those who do think about that pig’s life sluff it off and continue to eat.
All I’m saying is… is it necessary to kill and eat an animal even though it isn’t vital to one’s survival? What makes one creature’s life more important than another?
If you choose to eat meat cool- that’s your choice. People have their own beliefs and those beliefs should be respected.
[/quote]
Plants live, bacteria live, viruses live. But im sure that you eat plants, try and get rid of the flu and take antibiotics. A vegaterians view of life is just as predjudice as a person who eats meat. We draw the cut off line at humans, we avoid cannoblism and thats about it.
You draw a random, unnatural line in the sand between animals and non animals when literally everything in this world is responsible for supporting life in a various way. Why not protect the trees by ONLY eating meat? To me its simple a very stupid attempt at making a difference.
Respect the fact that whatever your eating has givin its life for you, and your good to go. Dont kill anything for no reason. Those are the rules you should live by. Not an arbitarily drawn line in the hierarchy of living organisms