[quote]Guardian58 wrote:
KBCThird wrote:
nonsense. thompson squatted 855 and got a BS depth call. Siders had just competed in an intl ipf meet 8 days prior.I have no idea whether these are the only two who could do it, but to say that theres no one is intellectually dishonest, and to say its not close is silly.
Maybe you should take a class in reading comprehension. How much do Siders and Donnie Thompson weigh??? Karwoski weighed 240 pounds for that 826. So the only thing silly is you bringing up two guys WELL over 300 pounds and lumping them in with a guy who is 240 and still clearly out squatting them raw. [/quote]
Dont try to back out of this one, you didnt say that there is no 242er close. you said NOBODY. dont try to foist of your writing inability by claiming I lack reading comprehension. You didnt say that nobody is close to coan, because there are guys deadlifting over 900 - yet none of them is 220, and you didnt mention this.
curious.
[quote]Dont disregard the effect that a geared squat of over 1000 could have on his raw pull. Im not saying 870 is a number kroc could def hit, but i would expect his dl to be higher in a meet in which he did all his lifts unequipped
Kroc hit his best deadlift of just over 800 in a meet where he did not squat, or took a token squat (one or the other). And that was with a deadlifting suit on.
Know what you are talking about before you start calling people silly. Mkay?[/quote]
If that is the case, I was wrong, I was under the impression that he hit 810 in his most recent meet unequipped, but since im nowhere near certain of that, I concede the point.
Nonetheless, my original comment that your statement was silly stands as it was referring to your comments about squatting.