[quote]ZEB wrote:
I agree greed is yet one more vice…that libertarians will do nothing about.
When you say thinks like “some woman having an abortion doesn’t impact my life…” that says more about you and the other young males who follow this idiotic libertarian philosophy. Because I have a surprise for you, eventually everything impacts you!
There are many things that on their face do not impact you but in reality will eventually impact you in a very nasty way:
Who cares if people take drugs it doesn’t impact you, until someone breaks into your home, or a loved ones home and kills them for their TV because they need another fix.
Who cares if prostitution is legal it doesn’t impact you until there are numerous outbreaks of STD’s, HIV and a host of other sexually transmitted diseases. And families are broken because of marital infidelity. And it doesn’t just effect someone else, it effects people that you know. Do you care now?
Who cares if people drink until they can’t stand up, until one of those drunks hits one of your loved ones head on in an auto accident and kills them.
I can’t explain it any better than that.
You are a young male who is enthralled with libertarianism. It sounds cool, cheap and the way things ought to be…but it just totally wrong minded and takes the short-term view to an extreme degree. And all the words typed on a message board won’t change your mind because you just have not lived long enough to see the impact DIRECTLY ON YOU of the many ills of which I speak.
The only thing that will change your mind is living another 10-15 years. And that is not a put down, it’s just the way it is.
Anyway, I want to deliver my thread back to its original purpose of “Why Obama Won”[/quote]
My first question would be how old you think I am? I’m 44 and have lived or traveled (either through personal travels or deployments) to every continent. I’m a father to a young son and husband to a wonderful woman. I’ve done a lot of thinking about these subjects and unfortunately my ideas aren’t always articulated most clearly on an internet forum. But I am pretty sure that I’ve got enough life experience to have an intelligent conversation here.
I differ from most libertarians in that I do think that abject greed does need some amount of checks and balances. We used to have some of that in place and I would put my views more inline with someone like Teddy Roosevelt in that regard.
In every one of your examples you both showed the extremes of would could happen and you looked at the symptom of a different problem. People break into your home to get money for drugs not because of the drugs themselves but because of their addiction to them. There’s a world of difference there. My grandfather was an alcoholic and killed himself when my mom was still a teenager. But it wasn’t the booze that’s to blame there. It’s just the way that his mind worked. If it wasn’t booze then it would have been gambling, or food, or anything else. Does it suck that he went that route? Of course it does and it very much impacted my mom. But, even she doesn’t blame alcohol and herself will drink in moderation from time to time.
HIV and other STD’s can be easily prevented through the use of condoms. And I can get either of those even through a committed relationship and once dated a young woman who was given herpes by an old boyfriend. We were really careful but it was still a risk. The only way to be 100% sure of not contacting anything is to abstain. So should we ban all sexual contact?
My point in all of this is that we need to give the individual more responsibility not less. Legalize pot but make it illegal to drive in an altered state much like we do for DUI’s. Legalize prostitution but make it illegal to use their services without a condom.
Abortion is a sticky one to be sure. I fully admit that it’s murder. But so is the death penalty and so is war but we say that both of those are “justified”. And making abortion illegal isn’t going to stop the practice from happening. Yeah, that’s a shitty answer but it’s a realistic one. We live in reality not theory and it seems to me that many people forget that.
james