[quote]TheBodyGuard wrote:
[quote]DoubleDuce wrote:
[quote]CappedAndPlanIt wrote:
[quote]DoubleDuce wrote:
[quote]CappedAndPlanIt wrote:
“The only way to not have “stupid faith” is to have no beliefs at all about the nature of existence”
So, if I believe I exist, is that “stupid faith”?[/quote]
“nature of existence”
You must have missed the qualifier before existence.[/quote]
Clarify, then.[/quote]
Why/how you exist. Meaning. metaphysical origin. First cause (or belief in no first cause). perpetual existence. Existence in and of itself. Infinite regress. est.[/quote]
We’re having this discussion in Bible Contradictions 2.0. At the risk of unwanted spillover here to there and back, do you think humans are “hardwired” to have any frame of reference, any possible understanding, any grasp whatsoever on the concept of “eternity”. If we do, I’d like to hear it because all things we experience begin and end. Perhaps it’s this paradigm of of our minds that leads us to search so desperately for “why” and “how”. Maybe it just “is” and always will be.[/quote]
Well, if you are reasoning your beliefs from the experience in the universe it only flows that there is a cause.
The real monkey wrench is, what reason do we really have to believe our experience within the universe is in any way indicative of a possible reality outside/before it? There isn’t.
And I think you are missing that point. Having a why and how and being infinite aren’t mutually exclusive.
There is no real reason to narrow your view of existence based on the rules of the universe. Time itself is a component of the universe. There is no reason to narrow the scope of something outside the universe to our concept of time. In other words something infinite in the scope of the universe could still have an origin outside of time.
Most people have a problem thinking about time in non-absolute terms. Generally, people are okay with dismissing other internal components of the universe when discussing god or whatever. The concept of god generally has no length, width, depth, mass, or electric charge. People seem okay with throwing away those concepts when discussing god.
But the truth is that time is no different. It is just a dimensional component of the way the universe works. If you are going to have an honest discussion about god/origin/meaning you cannot apply time to it. And I think that is a harder concept to grasp at than infinity. Some times I feel like I have some insight into what without time would be and sometimes I don’t.
