[quote]Nominal Prospect wrote:
Oh, I don’t know…perhaps by evaluating her performance against that of her competitors? She finished her performance, and beat everybody else in that aspect. That’s the actual sport. That’s what people are there to see. That’s what the athletes are competing against each other for. They’re not there to compete against one another in sliding 150m down a hill towards a finish line. Everything besides the actual performance is strictly a technical formality.
Who would want to be the declared “winner” of an event in which he or she was clearly inferior in skill level to the other contestants? Not me, for sure.
Ranking systems exist in athletics to present a reflection of the relative skill levels of athletes in their respective sports. Like any other hierarchical system devised by humans, ranking systems are not perfect - they have their flaws.
In the real world, being #1 in rank does NOT necessarily mean being the best, brightest, strongest, or most able in a particular field. This is as true in sports as it is in the military, the government, and private sector.
Three cheers for people who possess actual skill in their fields – not superficial ranks and titles.[/quote]
I don’t care about snowboarding personally, but I have to respectfully state that the paragraphs quoted above were retarded.
What is the point of sport competitions then?
Why should I strive to compete in a particular sport if my opponent is clearly superior in skill? Should I just throw in the towel and say “Oh well, even if I win that it would be meaningless because he is clearly superior in skill to me”
The whole point of competition is to show your skill when it MATTERS (i.e. in an actual competition event). Who gives a flying fuck if you can win every single sparring or a training race if you cannot perform at the event than matters.
There were thousands of situations where competitors or teams who were clearly inferior in skill or athleticism or whatever defeated “better” opponents in the Olympics, World Championships etc. I never saw anyone of those defeated simply shrug their shoulders and say “Oh nevermind, we could have beated them any other day, everyone knows were better, we were here just to have fun”.
This wholle “I’m just here to have fun and please the crowd” sounds like PC run amok and applied to sports.